Mini 496 - Wild West Mafia. Mod Abandoned

[ryan]

Simenon: I believe it's already been stated that your answers aren't being believed. I READ that earlier in a post.

That wasn't directed at you.

I didn't say it was, I'm just stating what I read earlier.

[Thin_Man]

I change my mind about my vote

Unvote

It really wasn't as justified as I remember.

Mod could we get a prod on Thin_Man?

His absence especially bothers me considering his consistent posting under his normal account

I'm sorry about this, (though I don't really think you can argue at all that I've been consistent under my regular account considering two of the games under that I'm lurking like hell, and I've barely posted under this account in the time I've been away so, it's certainly not unique to this game.) Basically it's because I've been trying to get my mini theme running as good as I can get it. I've finished I'm sending the roles out now, so it really shouldn't be a problem anymore. I'm aware there is a deadline, and I think I'll have more than enough time to hit the game before it.

[kabenon007]

Simenon, the fact remains, as I said before, I don't care that you posted your explanations earlier. The fact I wanted to investigate was whether or not you could remember your explanations, and would accidentally word them differently, or something that differed from them the first time than in a repost. And the fact that you posted it after I asked you to and gave you my reasoning nulled my point. I probably shouldn't have told you why I wanted to post your explanations, I had just hoped you would out of honesty, but no, it took me telling you that I wanted to compare, and this gave you the ability to go back and review, knowing exactly what I wanted. It was probably stupid to say it, but I figured you wouldn't post it unless I did, and now that it is there, it is less genuine than if I hadn't said anything.

[Paradoxombie]

1: Who is our best lynch candidate? AND why?

2: Who do you believe is town currently?

3: Who gives off the biggest scum vibes?

Hey Gorgon, could you answer these questions as well?

[SirWario]

1: Who is our best lynch candidate? AND why?

2: Who do you believe is town currently?

3: Who gives off the biggest scum vibes?

Hey Gorgon, could you answer these questions as well?

How about you too?

[Gorgon]

1. I'm not entirely sure. Perhaps GOW, although I'd really like to see more from him. He hasn't posted on the site for a week now, which is cause for concern.

2. ckd, SirWario, pdcakes, Simeon to a lesser extent.

3. GOW, Para, ryan.

P.S. I have a pretty strong suspicion that it's very likely that one of Simeon/ryan is scum, more likely ryan.

[Paradoxombie]

1: Who is our best lynch candidate? AND why?

2: Who do you believe is town currently?

3: Who gives off the biggest scum vibes?

Hey Gorgon, could you answer these questions as well?

How about you too?

I'm not really sure what I think. I definitely need to re-read before deadline. I know Gorgon is the only player who doesn't seem scummy at all, but that's not saying much at the moment. I've just been getting little pings on my radar recently. The most scummy vibe has been comming from SirWario, but I've got pretty much nothing to back it up, so I see little point in pursuing it.

[theopor_COD]

Votecount shortly. I think everyone's about . . apologies for my recent inactivity.

With the discussion improving I'm happy to extend the deadline by a week, if you all wish? Otherwise it's 6 days time.

[pdcakes]

Hey guys. I will not be able to post until at least tomorrow afternoon(EST) because i am going to the boston red sox cleveland indians baseball game(go cleveland!) and I have to head down to cleveland. I will post when i get back.

[Gorgon]

Yeah, extending the deadline would be good, especially with GOW absent. Which reminds me ...

Mod, could you poke GOW with a big stick please?

[kabenon007]

I was thinking more of a poke with like a cattle prod, or a branding iron, but whatever suits you, mod...

[Paradoxombie]

Is anyone NOT in favor of getting a deadline extension?

[theopor_COD]

God of Wine was prodded some four/five hours ago.

[ryan]

Deadline extension=GREAT idea

[kabenon007]

Yay extension!!! I would be highly suspicious of anyone who was against an extension.

[curiouskarmadog]

Yay extension!!! I would be highly suspicious of anyone who was against an extension.

well with a comment like this, who would say anything different?

I always love it when individuals clamor on about how an extension is great and protown, then they go back to light posting or lurking. Extensions are only good if the town actually uses them. In general, I like long days (if the conversation is good)...so far conversation has been stale here as of late..if GoW is replaced, I think we could use an extension, but if he is not...I dont think we need one..

so officially, I dont want an extension UNLESS GoW is replaced.

[Paradoxombie]

CKD, did you ever tell us what your night 1 action was? If not, would you mind doing so?

[curiouskarmadog]

i did nothing.

[kabenon007]

I think that there has been some good discussion today. Mostly against Simenon, which I have no problem with.

[Simenon]

I think that there has been some good discussion today. Mostly against Simenon, which I have no problem with.

Funny how you have still failed to provide an argument.

[SirWario]

I'm starting to grow weary of the same arguments thrown back and forth between simenon and ryan/kabenon.

[Paradoxombie]

Well I think I'm gonna

unvote, vote:CKD

Sure, GOW is pretty passively scummy, but CKD is pretty actively scummy(imo). I'm not buying his claim and I feel confident enough in my suspicion that it seems more dangerous to leave him alive. That not only gives him a vote, and forces us to waste another day, but also if he knows he will be lynched tommorow, his partners can sit back while he makes all the moves that would be condemning later(like blatantly voting townies or allowing a No Lynch) I don't like the idea of a player with nothing to lose like that.

But enough of the reasons I think we shouldn't give ckd a night to prove himself. Here's my reasons for suspecting him:
1. I don't like the way he went about his claim at all.
-The way he attacks simenon looks quite a bit like scum trying to take a townie out with them.
-The way he "soft claimed" looks like he was feeling out the situation so that he could worm his way out; Like he wanted as many town opinions as possible before he actually says anything he'll be held to.
-he waited as long as possible to give a name for his role, while SirWario, whose claim is more believable says that his role doesn't have a name.
-After SirWario gives a few specifics about his PM, THEN ckd says his is similar.
2. He didn't kill last night
-I'm just not buying that considering how much suspicion was being thrown around at the end of day 1
3. He doesn't think a deadline extension is "Necesary"
-The way he calls the deadline "not necessary" seems like a dodge of actually saying he is pro-deadline
-He talks of how conversation has stalled when his recent postings are sporadic and lack content
-^^^^ especially bad considering he should be killed tonight if his role is true. I'd expect him to be doing more scum hunting and want as much time as possible to give what input he can before he dies.

There might be other reasons I can't remember at the moment.(I don't use notes)

[curiouskarmadog]

silly Para..did you even need to ask me if I did something last night?

Is this about me having my vote on your scum buddy GoW?

way to set up that WIFOM arguement tomorrow, but shouldnt you wait to lynch me until tomorrow? I already know who I am vigging tonight, but I guess that is why you are scared today isnt it?

[Paradoxombie]

Oh yes, one more thing I forgot is that there is simply a higher chance of SirWario randomly picking scum than of picking the vig(if there even is one) to write the note about.

[curiouskarmadog]

(yawn)...so is your scum buddy going to be replaced or not?