Mini 1781: Plotinus Mafia: Game Over

[Gorkington]

or it can only affect two players?
iuno.
i really dont have any faith in my ability to parse this setup at this point.

[RadiantCowbells]

doesn't matter how many players it can affect.

being able to redirect the SK would be complete fucking nonsense.

[Titus]

Maybe scum didn't use it until they were aware of all the roles in play?

[Gorkington]

is that problem any different than a regular bus-driver?
im not sure i understand.

[Roshar]

In terms of who I would lynch, it'd be Aristo. A few things have made me question Gork (that he concluded bus driver instead of redirect before RC came in, him pointing to the fact that scum are really stupid for not lynching scum), but I wouldn't be comfortable lynching him as his argument when backed feel genuine. Call me naive.
If I was forced to come up with a second scum buddy, I'd do that after an Aristo flip and get an association there.



I feel like I really can't chip in rn due to the fact that I'm really weak with game mechanics and I'm not on the same page as the discussion. But here's my opinions from that I understood.

I don't understand how the results tonight implicate me. Unless you're assuming that scum are idiots and would redirect kills away from one of their scum mates as if that wouldn't turn the spotlight on them. Unless I'm missing something, isn't this the conclusion you all are reaching?


If I'm scum due to common sense, then I apologize for not appearing more town and not being more invested in the game. But I haven't really had a case to defend against myself, just fingers pointing at my slot over and over again. So I don't feel that remorseful at town losing this game with my lynch. I'm just apathetic at this point.

[Gorkington]

like, from where i stand, if this is a limited 2-target version of the role, then its a nerfed bus-driver, isnt it?

[RadiantCowbells]

Maybe scum didn't use it until they were aware of all the roles in play?

Doesn't change the fact that they could control the SK and basically function as a 2 kpn scum faction with such a role alive.
Plus it's simultaneously a vanilla cop and multiple target redirector.
that alone on a scum team makes for a broken ass scumteam. 2 investigatives plus the ability to control an outside killing role? no.

VOTE: Roshar

[Gorkington]

rosh, i have no idea who would be scum if you werent at this point.
like.
i dont understand whats going on on a fundamental level here if you somehow have a town rolePM.

[Roshar]

Right, if you're so sure, then lynch me and end the game.

[Gorkington]

:/

[RadiantCowbells]

In terms of who I would lynch, it'd be Aristo. A few things have made me question Gork (that he concluded bus driver instead of redirect before RC came in, him pointing to the fact that scum are really stupid for not lynching scum), but I wouldn't be comfortable lynching him as his argument when backed feel genuine. Call me naive.
If I was forced to come up with a second scum buddy, I'd do that after an Aristo flip and get an association there.

This did not come from town.

Right, if you're so sure, then lynch me and end the game.

above.
but it's still probably Gork/Rosh.

[Roshar]

Sick of all the finger pointing and no reasons.

Was I unmotivated? Yes.
I had no strong stances. Yes

I'm just an ambiguous slot that everyone keeps pointing at so I must be scum.

[Roshar]

oh wow, you finally found something I posted that was scummy. Too bad it was after you voted me.

[RadiantCowbells]

I voted you because I read that post in the pedit.

but yeah.

[Gorkington]

vote: roshar

give me closure please.

[Roshar]

You scum read me all through D3, so meh.

[Roshar]

If Gork is scum, you deserve the win.

Aristo's definitely in the mix, just not sure with who.

[RadiantCowbells]

UNVOTE:

I want to lynch Gork first.

[Titus]

Not voting.

There's 6 alive... so why vote today?

I get Roshar is likely scum but...

[Gorkington]

vote me then.
im not even going to be indignant when you throw the game.
i want to be done playing.

[androgybee]

I'm not voting Gorkington.

-Nahdia

[RadiantCowbells]

Actually no.

VOTE: Roshar

Here's the deal Gork.
You are going to target Titus tonight.
AB, you are to track Gorkington.

If their roles contradict, autolynch Gorkington.

[RadiantCowbells]

Actually no.

VOTE: Roshar

Here's the deal Gork.
You are going to target Titus tonight.
AB, you are to track Gorkington.

If their roles contradict, autolynch Gorkington.

AB?

[RadiantCowbells]

If AB gets nightkilled I'll figure it out in 4 way.

[RadiantCowbells]

Oh, if Roshar flips non bus driver, obviously track whoever you want.