We know from two people claiming Tracker (kuribo and pisskop) that there is more than one Tracker.
Marquis' role makes perfect sense, as it stops the main problem of putting multiple identical town roles in - it stops an inevitable and unfair counterclaim lynch (or maybe even two if town follows it up).
However, it still allows a counterclaim of sorts, since if more trackers claim than Marquis knows exist, then shit goes down.
It makes pretty much perfect sense in a game which - as has been proven - has more than one tracker.
And I assume the reason Marquis voted DNTTS for asking that is because it's pretty damn rolefishing, to go around asking how many town trackers are in the game.
First, a simple question must me asked:
@camn - do players, when lynched or killed, flip with their role PM or not? Do they flip with their role name as it is in their Role PM?
Since it doesn't matter as long as one town member is aware of how many Trackers there are, ideally we want only Marquis to know until Marquis dies, at which point everyone should hopefully know.
Ideally, we can work out a way to make that happen.
It's marquis.
???
add me on snapchat and vine and twitter and instagram : ]
Nacho has posted several times since D1, but neither of us have said much in the PT about the game. I've been directing what little time I've had elsewhere, and have been expecting nacho to be the carry over here.
Tl;dr of my thoughts:
The setup seems wonky and obviously broken if it's as it seems, and if it is then we pretty much auto-won after day 2 and our role is useless. I still think there's a possibility that PH was an idiot/not paying attention and actually submitted a track on the player the scumteam killed, since otherwise I can't imagine why anti wouldn't have mentioned a second target (who would be confirmed town). That's why I would like another night of results, and since scum NKed last night, it seems like there's no real loss in doing so provided there aren't goofy HPE rules.
If there's a full ninja or a falsely claiming tracker, then we've still auto-won with more "X went Y" results. I think it's probably Aiden; I think he stressed that performer is "conftown" for visiting nahdia as an indirect way of encouraging the idea that he's conftown for doing the same. I don't mind giving it a night, though.
We know from two people claiming Tracker (kuribo and pisskop) that there is more than one Tracker.
Marquis' role makes perfect sense, as it stops the main problem of putting multiple identical town roles in - it stops an inevitable and unfair counterclaim lynch (or maybe even two if town follows it up).
However, it still allows a counterclaim of sorts, since if more trackers claim than Marquis knows exist, then shit goes down.
It makes pretty much perfect sense in a game which - as has been proven - has more than one tracker.
And I assume the reason Marquis voted DNTTS for asking that is because it's pretty damn rolefishing, to go around asking how many town trackers are in the game.
First, a simple question must me asked:
@camn - do players, when lynched or killed, flip with their role PM or not? Do they flip with their role name as it is in their Role PM?
Since it doesn't matter as long as one town member is aware of how many Trackers there are, ideally we want only Marquis to know until Marquis dies, at which point everyone should hopefully know.
Ideally, we can work out a way to make that happen.
It's marquis.
???
Looked to me like badscum-davsto was worried marquis was going to be caught in a fakeclaim, and was willing to build an association to support him since the pressure was almost entirely off him at that point. The Davsto-Marquis interactions early game were also incredibly forced and nonsensical, so I don't see why that lynch was bad without knowing already that marquis was town.
thats the most convenient fucking action submission ive ever heard in my life
aiden can u pls provide the reason you made the choices you did ?
N1 - FB and I were both scum reading Nahdia. So, we figured she was scummy enough that, if she was town, that she wouldn't be the NK. So, either way, we thought it was a safe enough target to ensure a result
N2 - It was between Fate and Marquis, for us. I believed Marquis's claim, and figured tracking him wouldn't yield any results, so we went for Fate.
N3 - FB had been busy, and I just flat out forgot. No excuses there.