Mini 1783: GTA 2 Mafia (GaME OVAH)

[The Banterlords]

now lets

stop bantering

and play the game

lol ok

POST COMING UP FOR POLAR VORTEX!!!
~Dwlee

[The Banterlords]

VOTE: Jeanne11

idk if we already have the vote on or not but she is sucm

~KT

Why?

-Snow

Well you see~~~

I am a PR that is close to DK's claim. Oh, and for emphasis, I said

close to it

not

same as it

they

I am a PR that is close to DK's claim. Oh, and for emphasis, I said

close to it

not

same as it

Why are you saying this now?

because we were talking about lynching her?

Very well, since all you do is throw shade on me yourself, I'll stop you by claiming fully. I am a town watcher.

Under no pressure for a claim.
Decides to put pressure on DK by claiming a "Similar" role but leaves enough room for when (this is where I'm assuming DK is town) dk flips cop that jeanne can say "oh well I said close to it not the same". There was 0 reason to softclaim at all as town right there. I believe the reason they claimed is as scourge pointed out in 307 we talked about lynching her for lurking and then she fully claims 3 posts later as watcher. (That's not even that similar to a cop)

[The Banterlords]

VOTE: Jeanne11

idk if we already have the vote on or not but she is sucm

~KT

Why?

-Snow

Well you see~~~

I am a PR that is close to DK's claim. Oh, and for emphasis, I said

close to it

not

same as it

they

I am a PR that is close to DK's claim. Oh, and for emphasis, I said

close to it

not

same as it

Why are you saying this now?

because we were talking about lynching her?

Very well, since all you do is throw shade on me yourself, I'll stop you by claiming fully. I am a town watcher.

Under no pressure for a claim.
Decides to put pressure on DK by claiming a "Similar" role but leaves enough room for when (this is where I'm assuming DK is town) dk flips cop that jeanne can say "oh well I said close to it not the same". There was 0 reason to softclaim at all as town right there. I believe the reason they claimed is as scourge pointed out in 307 we talked about lynching her for lurking and then she fully claims 3 posts later as watcher. (That's not even that similar to a cop)

~Dwlee

[Dragon Knight]

Jeanne might be a scum watcher
VOTE: Jeanne

Why?

VOTE: Jeanne11

idk if we already have the vote on or not but she is sucm

~KT

Why?

-Snow

To quote Titus, why=fry

[Dragon Knight]

FoS Polar Vortex

[shos]

@mod can you also implement a clause that says they can't just prod-dodge either, regardless of whether or not they have a prod? You already have one that says they can't prodge after having a prod, why not make it both?

This is what the spirit of the rule stands for. While trying, it is much harder for me to monitor, though.
Therefore an official law about it may not be present.

However, please refer to the rule: my word is LAW. So if I deem it worthy of a prod, it is.


EDIT:
The Code Of Honor hydra has been semi-prodded. Unofficially.

[A Real Scourge]

polar vortex i don't get why you need much more of an explanation as to why jeanne is scummy? she's done no hunting, her claim was bad, she's been lurking, she only popped up after we started taking an interest in lynching her, blah blah blah.
your treatment of this wagon is really strange.

[A Real Scourge]

UNVOTE:
i think i was still voting banterlords.

[Polar Vortex]

Under no pressure for a claim.
Decides to put pressure on DK by claiming a "Similar" role but leaves enough room for when (this is where I'm assuming DK is town) dk flips cop that jeanne can say "oh well I said close to it not the same". There was 0 reason to softclaim at all as town right there. I believe the reason they claimed is as scourge pointed out in 307 we talked about lynching her for lurking and then she fully claims 3 posts later as watcher. (That's not even that similar to a cop)

Why is being under no pressure a scum sign? Where's the motivation in that, what does she win with this claim as scum? Nothing. She's cornering herself with this claim for no reason. I don't see a clear town motivation for the claim either, but it's much easier to believe and makes more sense with the rest of her play so far.

Notice how she didn't counter claim or even use her own role as a reason to push for DK's lynch. If she's not doing it with a DK lynch in mind why would she even need to leave room to defend herself upon a DK town flip. It just doesn't make any sense, we don't even know if DK is telling the truth. Besides, if she is telling the truth her ability could be as useful or even more so than DK's.

I can see her claiming as a defense, to stop further discussion of her lynch, which isn't really alignment telling but makes sense with her previous statement that she'd oppose her lynch vehemently. And as I said, it makes no sense for scum to commit themselves to a claim this early in a role madness game without being in real danger.

[Polar Vortex]

polar vortex i don't get why you need much more of an explanation as to why jeanne is scummy? she's done no hunting, her claim was bad, she's been lurking, she only popped up after we started taking an interest in lynching her, blah blah blah.
your treatment of this wagon is really strange.

I'm not asking why people think she's scummy. I'm asking specifically asking Dom why he thinks she might be watcher and why banta are sure she is scum. Because I just don't see any evidence to back up those accusations and votes.

She's done no hunting, neither have more than half of the players in this game, players who didn't claim a PR. she's been lurking, so have more than half the players in this game, players who didn't claim a PR... Get it?

We've collectively decided to give a pass to a scummier player, one who's scummy because of things he has actually done and said, who claimed after being put at L-1, which gave him an actual motive to claim. A player who claimed cop with an implicit twist, which gives him room to wiggle tomorrow. But, ok, everyone is willing to take this risk, and so are we. Now why aren't you willing to take the same risk (I'd even say, a smaller risk) with a player whose biggest faults are basically not playing and only showing up to defend herself and claim unprompted?

How am I the only one who sees the issue here?

-Snow (previous one was mine too)

[BlackStar]

Because as a member of the town, claiming for no reason on day 1 doesn't help anyone. It makes you an easy target for scum. If Jeanne really has a pr, the why would she put herself at risk so early on before she could even get a result? And it's suspicious that Jeanne only showed up after people started talking about lynching them.

[Polar Vortex]

Because as a member of the town, claiming for no reason on day 1 doesn't help anyone. It makes you an easy target for scum. If Jeanne really has a pr, the why would she put herself at risk so early on before she could even get a result? And it's suspicious that Jeanne only showed up after people started talking about lynching them.

The worst about claiming on day one is that the scum get free information. You're right that claiming makes her a target, she'd be a waste of a NK though, so the only option scum would have to get rid of her would be through lynching her.

I don't think she wanted to put herself at risk, not at lynch risk. I think if there's a reason for her to have claimed was to achieve the opposite; claim early, stop the discussion on her slot and prevent her wagon from taking off. It obviously didn't work out like that.

-Snow

[Dragon Knight]

BlackStar is 100% right and Polar is also 100% scum. Trying to defend your scumbuddy who undoubtably has a really useful role...

Lynch with fiyah!

[Polar Vortex]

[BlackStar]

[The Banterlords]

BlackStar is 100% right and Polar is also 100% scum. Trying to defend your scumbuddy who undoubtably has a really useful role...

Lynch with fiyah!

How about we lynch Jeanne today and you use your "cop" role thing to invest Polar


~KTthcreeper

[Polar Vortex]

[The Banterlords]

Ok Polar so you don't want a Jeanne lynch so what do YOU suggest we do today? I want your thought on who we should lynch.


~KTthecreeper

[Polar Vortex]

Ok Polar so you don't want a Jeanne lynch so what do YOU suggest we do today? I want your thought on who we should lynch.


~KTthecreeper

I'm still figuring. This game has stalled, it's always the same people posting. Right now I'm mostly waiting for the rest of the players to show up and post anything so I can get a read on them. Like,

Vote: Dominator.

[Dragon Knight]

BlackStar is 100% right and Polar is also 100% scum. Trying to defend your scumbuddy who undoubtably has a really useful role...

Lynch with fiyah!

How about we lynch Jeanne today and you use your "cop" role thing to invest Polar


~KTthcreeper

That's the plan kiddo.

[The Banterlords]

i feel like i had something to say but i just feel like puking the contents of my stomach out instead so oh well
~Dwlee

[Polar Vortex]

Us as Jeanne partner is the most idiotic thing I've heard in this game. She looks like a liability for any scum team. If we were scum with her, why wouldn't we just buss her ass right now?

Also for people who want to investigate us, we're ascetic.

Bearbert

[Dragon Knight]

Us as Jeanne partner is the most idiotic thing I've heard in this game. She looks like a liability for any scum team. If we were scum with her, why wouldn't we just buss her ass right now?

Also for people who want to investigate us, we're ascetic.

Bearbert

Always claim this stuff way earlier than you did.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

OK, I'm caught up.

Jeanne watches DK and that way we get at least one cop result. No point lynching either of them Today.

This should be today's lynch though;

VOTE: FA

[The Banterlords]

Us as Jeanne partner is the most idiotic thing I've heard in this game. She looks like a liability for any scum team. If we were scum with her, why wouldn't we just buss her ass right now?

Also for people who want to investigate us, we're ascetic.

Bearbert

Always claim this stuff way earlier than you did.

they did in their first post.

I can go along with that plan, bbt.
UNVOTE:
~Dwlee