Prophecy Mafia - Over

[Flameaxe]

Might as well jump on the bandwagon as well...I see no harm in it as of now.

Unvote, Vote: Kanaga

Diesimilarnamedscumdie!

Also, (this is just an idea I'm rolling off here...don't get all pissy at me for it...) due to the fact that this is an open setup, massclaiming MIGHT be an option to move day 1. I think that this should be considered for an idea to find teh scumz.

But I dunno...just a thought I'm throwing out there.

[Kanaga]

Unvote

, since the vote was random. As to defend myself: I said what I said because bubka didn't seem scum to me.

I don't want to seem OMGUS, but I don't like how CKD is playing.

unvote vote kanaga for assuming what mafia will do and clearing those already on the bandwagon.

That wasn't what I said AT ALL. I was talking about the last few people. CKD has been hounding everyone all game.

Also, look at stark. He said:

And I do think that the 7/8 person wagon is really just people waving their vote around. A sincere bandwagon of that proportion is highly unlikely right now.

What I said, phrased more safely. But then he goes on to do a vote-only post on me. Strange.

[stark]

Might as well jump on the bandwagon as well...I see no harm in it as of now.

Unvote, Vote: Kanaga

Diesimilarnamedscumdie!

Also, (this is just an idea I'm rolling off here...don't get all pissy at me for it...) due to the fact that this is an open setup, massclaiming MIGHT be an option to move day 1. I think that this should be considered for an idea to find teh scumz.

But I dunno...just a thought I'm throwing out there.

This is the setup:

1 Mafia GF
1 Mafia Doc
3 Mafia Goons
1 Jailkeeper
1 Cop,
1 Super-backup,
1 Vig
1 Miller (Miller is told that they are a townie)
1 Survivor
10 Townies.

We're going to have 15 townie claims (I really doubt that scum would fakeclaim in an open setup), which means we have a 1/3 chance of hitting scum with lynch.

Massclaim exposes all four of our powerroles.

With best odds (0.02% chance) , we take out scum in 5 nights.
Scum kills all of power roles in four nights.

In my humble opinion, I think we should keep our roles to ourselves

[Oman]

This game will not be broken by a massclaim D1. They're designed like that.

[BrianMcQueso]

Flameaxe, seriously. You do something so textbook scummy, and now you're going to get all uptight and defensive when we come at you for it. Massclaiming on Day 1 is a bad idea 98% of the time. Massclaiming does little more than give the mafia a blueprint of who to kill. This setup isn't even close to one that could be broken by massclaim.

It's like you

want

us to lynch you or something.

[Flameaxe]

I WANT to be lynched for saying ONE suggestion...in which I clearly stated was only that.

I'm pro-massclaiming (Pie's Soldiers! Huzzah!) for all open setups. I think if used correctly it can be very pro-town, and help out very nicely.

Over-react more please.

[JDodge]

Vote Count

:

Kanaga - 6 (curiouskarmadog, Tarhalindur, stark, foolinc, Oman, Flameaxe)
Lazy - 3 (xyzzy, Kakeng, Masked Jedi)
bubka - 2 (DragonsofSummer, Lowell)
Sir Tornado - 1 (UltimaAvalon)
pickemgenius - 1 (Sir Tornado)
Kakeng - 1 (rite)
curiouskarmadog - 1 (Lazy)
UltimaAvalon - 1 (SeraphicMirth)

Not voting (5): bubka, BrianMcQueso, pickemgenius, death_omen, Kanaga

11 to lynch.

Prodding Kakeng, UltimaAvalon, Masked Jedi, rite and xyzzy. In the future, please bold everything addressed to me; otherwise I might miss it.

[Lazy]

I WANT to be lynched for saying ONE suggestion...in which I clearly stated was only that.

I'm pro-massclaiming (Pie's Soldiers! Huzzah!) for all open setups. I think if used correctly it can be very pro-town, and help out very nicely.

Over-react more please.

I don't think that's overreacting, I feel the same way.

A mass roleclaim is one of the lamest things to do at this point. It isn't how mafia should be played.

[SeraphicMirth]

There are other ways to get through d1, for sure. I always like games to get as far as possible without any claiming. You are pro-massclaiming..but on d1 as well?? I mean, I can see maybe a little later on in a game possibly helping but on day 1? meh.

[Oman]

2-4 townie lynches and I'd be pro-massclaim, but not right now...definatly not right now.

[UltimaAvalon]

I'm intentionally lurking. Discuss.

Also, no no on the massclaim. Just because Pie says it always works, doesn't mean its true. Hell, Pie says Pro-town Vig should kill Night 0 if possible. Shows how full of wisdom he is.

[Kakeng]

Unvote

[Kakeng]

Sorry, pressed wrong button

Unvote

Anyway, i support mass townie role claim as we know the number of townies.

[Lazy]

Sorry, pressed wrong button

Unvote

Anyway, i support mass townie role claim as we know the number of townies.

Getting a 1/3 chance of hitting scum is worth jack shit if we have to out all of our power roles in return.

Not to even mention how mindnumbingly stupid way it is to play mafia.

"Hey, I can't figure out who's scum, let's mass roleclaim, hurr"


Everyone should vote for who they think is the scummiest person, in order to spark discussion.

Unvote

Vote Kakeng

You haven't contributed anything to the game and when you show up, you support a shitty idea that will not benefit the town.

[rite]

unvote

Sorry I haven't been around, the sheer wankery of the first few pages caused me to run for the hills for a bit there. Reading everything over, I don't see anyone scummy enough that I'd want to throw my vote on just yet.

For what it's worth, Lazy, I'd be willing to wager that Kakeng was just being stupid and not thinking that a mass townie claim would leave our power roles wide open. I was about to agree with him until I thought about it.

Also, not to nitpick, but for statistic purposes (for those of you who like that), we'd have sixteen townie role claims; don't forget that the miller thinks that they're a townie.

[DragonsofSummer]

Ultima, if I wasn't so sure you would intentionally lurk as town I'd be all over you for that...

I also disagree with a mass claim at this point.

[foolinc]

Since I haven't said so already, I find mass-claiming this early to be a very bad move.

[Tarhalindur]

Mass claim is a horrible, horrible idea in this setup as long as the Cop is alive (note that we do not have a true doc).

FoS: Flameaxe

for failing to realize this.

[UltimaAvalon]

Why is everyone FoS'ing Flameaxe? If we all hate him so much for such an arbitrary issue, we should kill him.

[Tarhalindur]

Why is everyone FoS'ing Flameaxe? If we all hate him so much for such an arbitrary issue, we should kill him.

Because I don't want to give up pressuring Kakeng just yet.

[Lazy]

Why is everyone FoS'ing Flameaxe? If we all hate him so much for such an arbitrary issue, we should kill him.

Because I don't want to give up pressuring Kakeng just yet.

Kanaga?

[Tarhalindur]

Why is everyone FoS'ing Flameaxe? If we all hate him so much for such an arbitrary issue, we should kill him.

Because I don't want to give up pressuring Kakeng just yet.

Kanaga?

Whatever.

[pickemgenius]

Anyway, i support mass townie role claim as we know the number of townies.

huh?

I don't quite follow what any mass claim in basically any D1 would do.

[Oman]

Weeeeeeell, Kakeng is scum, even supporting a massclaim after everyone said why they were DOUBLE PLUS UNGOOD!

[Flameaxe]

Why is everyone FoS'ing Flameaxe? If we all hate him so much for such an arbitrary issue, we should kill him.

Because all the scum realize how retarded the case is.