MINI 504- PEGBAM...GAME OVER!

[pickemgenius]

searching for replacements for the two prodded people

[Karen]

FTR: I don't think mafia killed orig, he had too many votes on him to be logical.

that's a possibility.

EXCEPT THIS IS A GAME OF MAFIA.

no wait... maybe he committed suicide, and mafia didn't send in a night choice. maybe they've never played before, and didn't know they could NK, in which case orig killed himself... but wait...

THIS IS A GAME OF MAFIA.

Back.

Panzer's logical investigation would be for originality. He was voting for him at the end of day 1, and thus, he would most likely be the person panzer thought to be most scummy.

wrong. A cop should investigate who he/she cannot read. I agree it was dumb of panzer to throw his investigation away like that on a lurker, who wouldn't do any damage at this point if they WERE scum.

Vote Karen

She's tried to pin orig's death on two people now, me and panzer.

let's see here:
1) i'm voting against scotmany12.
2) i defended panzer.

where did i try and "pin orig's death on two people"? here, i have to flat out question your intelligence. maybe your sanity. maybe you posted this while you thought you were on a World of Warcraft chat page.

but wait... THIS IS A GAME OF MAFIA.

i seriously think you should request a replacement for yourself. or, better idea, just "suicide" like originality. i beg of you. please... do this for the town.

thank you.

love,
karen

[scotmany12]

Karen, please explain why you chose me over panzer. Your previous reasoning was flawed, as I have shown.

[PJ.]

I don't believe it was flawed, i think you are stretching.

[scotmany12]

No, i'm not. She said that i'm scum cause I didn't investigate originality. I already explained that that would not have been a logical investigation for me. She totally misunderstood my point when I said your logical investigation is originality. I do not mean it is the same for me. Then she says you have plausible reason for your investigation? When there were many other lurkers, her included.

No, I am not stretching. If anyone is, it was her.

[scotmany12]

Oh and show me where you have been scumhunting panzer. You have done nothing this game so far except fakeclaim a cop.

[Oman]

where did i try and "pin orig's death on two people"?

how come you [Oman] NK'd him, were you so upset you couldn't lynch him during the day?

on the other hand,

if scotmany12 is scum,

and assumed the cop would make the "logical investigation,"

he would NK originality,

and render the cop's nightmove useless.

through his own logic, he has trapped himself, giving a huge scumtell,

telling us as to why originality is dead.

The bolding is mine, just for clarification.

[PJ.]

With the originality vote. I didn't have time for a reason Scot. I finished reading very close to deadline. I replaced in 2 hours to deadline.

[Flameaxe]

d3sisted replaces Morbuzaan, effective once he posts.

[scotmany12]

So, you want to answer me and show me where you have been trying to hunt scum? Because I do not see it.

[d3sisted]

Unvote

I think the better choice for town is to let both claimed cops live. Mafia knows which one of them is real, and they'll kill accordingly. It also gives both of them more chances to investigate. Not only that, they can more-or-less determine their sanity via successive investigates.

However, this means that we may have to let both of them live for more than one day. This is to shut off the possibility of mafia killing off one (who comes up cop) to throw suspicion onto the second cop for town to lynch. And yes, I am assuming that we have a 2 cop scenario as I find this most likely. If we had a doc, Originality probably wouldn't have died.

For the record, if I had to choose, I would say Panzer is more likely to be the one fake-claiming simply because scotmany12 was hinting at cop far before Panzer was.

[Oman]

Why, oh why, would a doc protect originality?

[d3sisted]

For that pseudo claiming thing he did when you attempted that gambit.

And damnit,

FoS oman

for attempting that gambit. I can only see scum rolefishing with it.

[Oman]

He was vanillia, what was he pseudo-claiming.

And I can see a bored town doing it. Personally.

[d3sisted]

That's why I kept it at an FoS and not a vote.

[pickemgenius]

Scotmany12[3](

Panzerjager,Karen,Jdodge)
Panzerjager[2](Scotmany12,distad)
Karen[1](Oman)

Not Voting: poppinpuffin,d3sisted,Kaleidoscope,AlSleet

DL: OCTOBER 14th, ~8PM

5 bands for $5 FTW!
Basement shows FTW!

IF YOU WANT SOMEBODY PRODDED/REPLACED LET ME KNOW ASAP.

[PJ.]

Honestly, desisted, Why would the cop hint cop for for no reason? Cops normally want to stay incognito. That is why I'm not considering a two cop scenario, is because the Scot come out swinging around words that insinuated he was cop. I still stand by that scot has done nothing pro-town this entire game.

I also don't see anyone protecting originality. If we're not lynching scot, we should lynch either Distad or Desisted.

Distad for jumping on bandwagons with the most momentum.

[PJ.]

and now lurking

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

We should be lynching the right cop today. I don't want to run into the risk that the mafia is going to kill a cop while the doc, if there is any, fails to pick the right one then.

[PJ.]

I'm willing to risk my life but if I die, Desisted and scotmany could very well be scum buddies.

If Scot is insane/sane cop, I'm favoring Distad as scum.

[d3sisted]

Dude. Pretty obvious why he hinted cop, because he got a negative result.

[distad]

It wasn't lurking, panzer. It was a long weekend.

I don't see any reason to not believe that we have two cops, frankly. You can say "cops wouldn't breadcrumb this early" all you want, but the fact is that it DOES happen. I think we should look elsewhere.

And d3, Oman had it partially right -- if there are two real cops, scum would likely NK one of them to get the other mislynched immediately; if there is only one real cop, it is unlikely that they would NK him, because it would be giving away one of the scum, essentially for free.

[scotmany12]

Panzer you just gave yourself out as scum. You said that if i'm insane/sane cop, you believe Distad to be scum. Well seeing as you claimed cop, and I got a guilty on you, why would you, a supposed cop, consider me as being sane. That's right, cause you're scum. My vote stays.

[d3sisted]

It wasn't lurking, panzer. It was a long weekend.

I don't see any reason to not believe that we have two cops, frankly. You can say "cops wouldn't breadcrumb this early" all you want, but the fact is that it DOES happen. I think we should look elsewhere.

And d3, Oman had it partially right -- if there are two real cops, scum would likely NK one of them to get the other mislynched immediately; if there is only one real cop, it is unlikely that they would NK him, because it would be giving away one of the scum, essentially for free.

Well there ya go. We let both of them live; if one dies, the other is most likely a cop. If neither dies, one of them is scum.

Let the wifom begin.

[Oman]

I believe I agree with scot here. That was an interesting slip. BUT I can believe that was no more than a slip, and so I'll just do a

bloody great FoS: Panzer