New York 194: Guns N' Roses Mafia! (Day 8)

[KickAssAndGiggle]

Still feeling pretty good about GR, Killthestory, Egg, SS for town. Although GR could do with pulling his head out of his ass.

Iraonavp is probably town too. And Slandaar.

Still leaning scum on Ness/Reubus slot and Jam. Starting to feel bad vibes from Creature, why are you ignoring Egg's question?

pisskop and Fraggernaut are both null despite posting plenty: I have no clue how to read either of them. SirCakez looks exactly as he did last time I played with him (Open 623), when I thought he was scum but he was actually town. Jury's out there. Performer sounds straightforward but I disagree with some of his posts (i.e. post 292, 298).

Other slots null due to lack of content.

UNVOTE: Reubus
VOTE: Creature

Feels useful.

[Drixx]

Hi KaaG. How's it hanging?

[Killthestory]

i am what you would call a dick friend

Clearly. Your avatar is of a revered Indian figure, who I believe was a Hindu, eating beef. I mean ... you're going for the trifecta there.

yes

[Kop]

Prod recieved. Will catch up shortly.

[Creature]

Creature, how many games have you played? Do you prefer being town or scum? Does being scum make you feel more nervous or confident (or if you've never been scum, which do you think would be true?.

In this site I completed one game and am playing this and 3 others.
I prefer being town because when I am lynched my play will be accepted next game.
Depends, I start nervous, go confident a little then nervous again, but it doesn't differ too much from my town play.

Also, pretty sure the size of the posts is not alignment indicative.

[Creature]

Starting to feel bad vibes from Creature, why are you ignoring Egg's question?

The only reason you're scum reading me is because I didn't answer his question soon?

[Something_Smart]

Hey, it's Drixx!
I actually really like Egg's reaction test as it produced the very awkward 415. After which Drixx has multiple fluff discussions. I'd like to see some content from him but for now he's leaning scum.

I like KAAG's reads.

[SirCakez]

umm jam is too new so I dont know if hes acting scummy or townie for him

This answer stinks. Pick one or the other.

SirCakez's last few posts have pinged me, both the one about pisskop (feels like asking for credit without blame) and the one to Ilikebugs (feels like trying to blame Ilikebugs for misinterpreting pisskop's post).

First one is understandable but the thing about Ilikebugs - what? I'm not blaming him, I'm just pointing out it wasn't serious. Since he's very new it's an understandable mistake.

Posting this from my phone

I guess for now I can accept this notion of Jam being newb town more then newb scum. I was confused on the early day wagon on them. I'm still feeling good on this pressure of ira & Robster is still weird for me.

I like Performer, Egg, & KAAG day one so far.

There's so many nulls & people who are inactive that this game has been harder than most day ones. Maybe it's the number of players in the game.

SirCakez, pisskop, Slandaar, & Something_Smart are notable nulls for me right now.

Also I feel like Something_Smart could possibly be setting up to pocket me later by how they're giving their read on me through multiple posts.

Pedit: I'll have to look at these Creatures interactions tomorrow. With that I'm off to work & won't be available till the morning.

Then who are you scumreading O.o

Agree with Irao that Ilikebugs's claim is prob legit.

Drixx replaces Mafiaturtle!

*waves*
Hi Drixx!

Because SirCakez is making a lot of short quips that don't really mean anything or represent a wider perspective.

This has been across a lot of my games recently. I've lost a lot of my motivation to really get into games, not sure why and it sucks, I still enjoy mafia :/ I'm trying to get back into it starting today though.

Drixx's joking is not a scumtell stop that. If he keeps it up after catching up then it could be.

Ok caught up
Townreads on Robster, Egg, KAAG, Slandaar
Scumreads on Jam, Creature, Irao

A lot of lurkers who need to step it up.

[Creature]

VOTE: Drixx

Two stones, one scum

[Drixx]

Hey, it's Drixx!
I actually really like Egg's reaction test as it produced the very awkward 415. After which Drixx has multiple fluff discussions. I'd like to see some content from him but for now he's leaning scum.

I like KAAG's reads.

Hey mate. It's old home week up in here. I'll have thoughts out when I have read the thread, but everyone who has ever played with me knows that I super rarely get a lot out of day one until later because of my need to be able to make assumptions I can rely on. That said, I've gotten some pretty good advice and improved a bit on day ones in the last couple months. Don't expect me to miraculously pull the whole scum team out of my ass though; that's not likely.

umm jam is too new so I dont know if hes acting scummy or townie for him

This answer stinks. Pick one or the other.

SirCakez's last few posts have pinged me, both the one about pisskop (feels like asking for credit without blame) and the one to Ilikebugs (feels like trying to blame Ilikebugs for misinterpreting pisskop's post).

First one is understandable but the thing about Ilikebugs - what? I'm not blaming him, I'm just pointing out it wasn't serious. Since he's very new it's an understandable mistake.

Posting this from my phone

I guess for now I can accept this notion of Jam being newb town more then newb scum. I was confused on the early day wagon on them. I'm still feeling good on this pressure of ira & Robster is still weird for me.

I like Performer, Egg, & KAAG day one so far.

There's so many nulls & people who are inactive that this game has been harder than most day ones. Maybe it's the number of players in the game.

SirCakez, pisskop, Slandaar, & Something_Smart are notable nulls for me right now.

Also I feel like Something_Smart could possibly be setting up to pocket me later by how they're giving their read on me through multiple posts.

Pedit: I'll have to look at these Creatures interactions tomorrow. With that I'm off to work & won't be available till the morning.

Then who are you scumreading O.o

Agree with Irao that Ilikebugs's claim is prob legit.

Drixx replaces Mafiaturtle!

*waves*
Hi Drixx!

Because SirCakez is making a lot of short quips that don't really mean anything or represent a wider perspective.

This has been across a lot of my games recently. I've lost a lot of my motivation to really get into games, not sure why and it sucks, I still enjoy mafia :/ I'm trying to get back into it starting today though.

Drixx's joking is not a scumtell stop that. If he keeps it up after catching up then it could be.

Ok caught up
Townreads on Robster, Egg, KAAG, Slandaar
Scumreads on Jam, Creature, Irao

A lot of lurkers who need to step it up.

Hey SC. Thanks for the sanity check for everyone. I've always hated the "Are you scum?" reaction test because there's no predictive element. Town doesn't universally respond one way and scum doesn't universally respond a different way. The only way it's useful is with players who know each other very well. I think the last time someone tried to throw me such a blatant lose/lose reaction test on a day one, I tried to emulate Kuribo and ended up pissing off most of the game. I also found out that I don't enjoy playing like Kuribo, LOL.

Glad to see you're trying to get the motivation back. Active motivated SirCakez is much more fun than mopey SirCakez.

[Drixx]

VOTE: Drixx

Two stones, one scum

Oh hey look. He gets called scum by SirCakez and takes the opportunity to jump on an easy wagon. No correlation though, amirite?

[Golden Robster]

VOTE: Egg

[Creature]

VOTE: Drixx

Two stones, one scum

Oh hey look. He gets called scum by SirCakez and takes the opportunity to jump on an easy wagon. No correlation though, amirite?

Since when I am forbidden from scum reading you?

[Creature]

If you notice, SirCakez is only scum reading easy mislynch targets.

[SirCakez]

I've never played with Irao or Jam, and you are pinging me constantly so yea those are my scumreads.
Why make that vote directly after my wall though?

[Creature]

Because I wasn't restricted or anything as I see.

[Creature]

If you notice, SirCakez is only scum reading easy mislynch targets.

I've never played with Irao or Jam, and you are pinging me constantly so yea those are my scumreads.

VOTE: SirCakez

[SirCakez]

Heh Creature is definitely scum.

[Creature]

Heh

Creature

SirCakez is definitely scum.

[Ilikebugs]

Okay so here are my reads so far:
Drixx I wouldn't think make himself such a target d1 if he was scum. It's been a while since I've played mafia so I can see myself as town doing what Drixx is doing in his current position.
Reubus hasn't talked at all so I'm hoping he can add something.
Killthestory started the Drixx vote which seems more scummy than town to me.
Egg I think is using player meta which can easily backfire. Also voted Drixx immediately after killthestory. However still neutral on him due to him actively asking questions.

[Kop]

Why should a VT without much to add be worried about being taken out first?

A VT shouldn't be worried about anything, they should be doing the best they can to eat a nightkill. But anyway, it still could be scum claiming an easy role.

I claimed because pisskop told me to

You shouldn't have claimed even if you were asked too. The only time you should claim is if your under pressure, or you are closed to being lynched, and you were neither.

Are you new to the game?

Heh Creature is definitely scum.

Heh

Creature

SirCakez is definitely scum.

These 2 posts aren't pleasing me. I think my vote on Creature looks like it'll be staying. If you can give me a case on why Sircakes is scum, and if I can find something within it that I can agree with, I might reconsider my vote.

[Kop]

Okay so here are my reads so far:
Drixx I wouldn't think make himself such a target d1 if he was scum. It's been a while since I've played mafia so I can see myself as town doing what Drixx is doing in his current position.
Reubus hasn't talked at all so I'm hoping he can add something.
Killthestory started the Drixx vote which seems more scummy than town to me.
Egg I think is using player meta which can easily backfire. Also voted Drixx immediately after killthestory. However still neutral on him due to him actively asking questions.

I never use meta as a concrete evidence, but can be a pointer.

[Ilikebugs]

Ya I'm new I'm still a townie after all

[Performer]

Here for about the next 30 minutes. Will be doing catching up and follow-up. Feel free to engage with me on anything.

[GuyFawkes]

Ya I'm new I'm still a townie after all

what does being new have to do with being a townie?