Mini 500 - Cult Mafia - Game Over!

[curiouskarmadog]

Mod Edit

Official Vote Count #34

Trojan Horse[3](theopor_COD, tyhess, pwayne66)
White[2](Flameaxe, Oman)
Flameaxe[2](White, vollkan)
Tarhalindur[1](curiouskarmadog)
Mastermind of Sin[1](Tarhalindur)
tyhess[1](Mastermind of Sin)


Not Voting[2](Kakeng, Trojan Horse)

I still feel good about my vote…Tar’s last 3 posts were.


09/25

Mod: I strongly support the deadline extension

10/02

Guys, this is currently the last priority on my priority list.

I should finish rereading in the next 1-2 days. More comments when that ends.

10/02

At the risk of OMGUS, after a quick readthrough I'm getting very suspicious of MoS.

I've seen MoS's play in long D1's when he's town (ongoing game). Something feels off about him here. He's attacking players, but given the way in which he's attacking players, I get the feeling that he's not really trying to hunt scum. It feels to me as if MoS is casting suspicion and trying to avoid stepping on toes by discussing theory, both of which are scummy.

I want to take a closer look at MoS's posts to find something more concrete, but I'm going to

Vote: MoS

in the meantime anyways.

This just seems like he is trying to put out there as little as possible while being “under the radar”. I also didn’t like how he had to explain to us we “are last on his priority list”. Seemingly he wants to indicate the he has a boring role here...dont knwo if I believe it.

Coupled with Dr. BS, Tar is on top my scummy list, atm

[Trojan Horse]

Man. You just had to give me another thing to think about, CKD. Tar definitely hasn't been a very helpful replacement yet. (Hmm. Perhaps Kakeng deserves a look for the same reason.) Do we want to do a lurker-lynch? I'm tempted.

Kakeng said he'd post today. I'm not hopeful that will actually happen, but I'll give him a chance.

Oh, and MoS: if you're so annoyed at having to play with 11 newbs like us, we could always put you out of your misery. (No smiley attached to this comment. I'm seriously considering voting for him... though for reasons of scumminess, of course.)

[White]

Right now i'm still waiting on Kakeng and Tar to actually add some content. They've got 5 days left. If no content is added I don't mind a Tar or Kakeng lynch but i'd definintely significantly much prefer them to be replaced.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Nevermind, you have answered this before. To be honest though, in your vast experience and expertise does the whole rubbing people noses in shit tactic usually deliver the desired result?

If you want to sell your case then sell it. If nobody's buying it might just be that you are selling a shitty product. This seems to make more sense than assuming that everybody in the game being an idiot but you...

Yes.

[vollkan]

Right now i'm still waiting on Kakeng and Tar to actually add some content. They've got 5 days left. If no content is added I don't mind a Tar or Kakeng lynch but i'd definintely significantly much prefer them to be replaced.

The only problem is the fact that lynching lurkers wastes the day in terms of information-gathering. That means that tomorrow we really have no better idea as to potential alignments. I mean, getting rid of a lurker is an advantage, but there is a significant opportunity cost.

[White]

Ahh, too true. Which is why my intended result isn't so much to lynch them but to pressure them into talking. However it's not really effective when you get people that either don't care about the game or aren't even checking the thread.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Man. You just had to give me another thing to think about, CKD. Tar definitely hasn't been a very helpful replacement yet. (Hmm. Perhaps Kakeng deserves a look for the same reason.) Do we want to do a lurker-lynch? I'm tempted.

Kakeng said he'd post today. I'm not hopeful that will actually happen, but I'll give him a chance.

Oh, and MoS: if you're so annoyed at having to play with 11 newbs like us, we could always put you out of your misery. (No smiley attached to this comment. I'm seriously considering voting for him... though for reasons of scumminess, of course. )

*fixed*

[White]

I don't see any difference other than the added smiley face. What was the point of that MoS?

[Kakeng]

Hm.. I just can't think of adding anything new to the table, so I look at the person with the largest number of votes: Trojan Horse.

On pg 28, the Doc voted for him, citing he was sittingon a fence and just following what other said.

pg 29, theo voted for TH, pointing at post 699. Not long later, tyhess votes for him. Note that theo attacks Th while defending tyhess. I have to admit that TH was acting somewhat suspicious. Later pages erases most of my suspicion of theo thought.

Trojan ssems to like smilies for some reason. It has already been said, and while I agree, I can't decide if that deserves a vote.

But all in all, Flame attitude makes me more suspicious, so

Vote:Flameaxe

[White]

Please tell me you've got more to add than that. You've got 35 pages.

[vollkan]

Hm.. I just can't think of adding anything new to the table, so I look at the person with the largest number of votes: Trojan Horse.

On pg 28, the Doc voted for him, citing he was sittingon a fence and just following what other said.

pg 29, theo voted for TH, pointing at post 699. Not long later, tyhess votes for him. Note that theo attacks Th while defending tyhess. I have to admit that TH was acting somewhat suspicious. Later pages erases most of my suspicion of theo thought.

Trojan ssems to like smilies for some reason. It has already been said, and while I agree, I can't decide if that deserves a vote.

But all in all, Flame attitude makes me more suspicious, so Vote:Flameaxe

So this is your contribution? A sketchy summary of some things relating to TH and you professing ridiculously vague suspicion of Flame and voting for it. Despite the fact that you don't actually discuss flameaxe ANYWHERE else.

This better just be a prelude to something big.

[Kakeng]

I'm doing a breakdown of the players one by one.

[vollkan]

I'm doing a breakdown of the players one by one.

And which player, if any, was your most recent post about?

[Kakeng]

Trojan Horse.

[White]

Ok, feel free to put all those posts together into one big post please.

[Trojan Horse]

Indeed. Please do, Kakeng.

And I'm not sure whether MoS's "correction" to my post gets a smile or a groan from me. I even explicity said "no smilies", and he jokingly tacks one on anyway. I guess I'm gonna get this for the rest of the game.

[Mastermind of Sin]

*shrug* The way you worded it, I read it with a smiley.

[Trojan Horse]

*bump*

I'm sure Kakeng isn't taking any exams over the weekend. Come on, Kakeng. If you do have more things to say (as you've implied you do) then say them. We're running out of time.

[Oman]

Back, reading and posting tonight.

[Oman]

I have read and have nothing to add.

[Mastermind of Sin]

You read 35 pages in an hour?

[Trojan Horse]

Obviously Oman didn't read every last line. Can't say I blame him.

You know what? I know it looks scummy to go after a lurker (lurkers are very easy targets to go after), but I feel like doing it anyway. The last thing I want is for the scummies to think that they can sit around and do nothing, and just make excuses for why they are absent, and avoid being lynched that way. Kakeng and Tar have just as much chance of being scum as anyone else, and it may well be worth getting rid of one of them.

No vote yet though. I'm giving them one final chance to show up and speak up. If they don't, it might be "lynch lynch" for them.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Kakeng, it's been like 50+ hours since you said you were doing an analysis on each player separately. Please post whatever you have so far so we can see what you think sooner. Don't wait to post it all at once.

[Trojan Horse]

Mod, prod Kakeng and Tar

before we run out of time.

[Oman]

No i didn't MoS. I read the stuff I missed while away. A page or two.