Mafia 70: Traditional - Game over!

[White]

So am I scum or am I just trying to distract the town?

[Lemming1607]

I like how I'm distracting the town but you've been posting just as much as I have the past 2 pages. Hypocritical much?

[Erg0]

I give up on this. You've gone from calling WIFOM to completely ignoring the point of my questions, so you're obviously at the cognitive dissonance stage already.

When you come down, just look for someone useful to vote.

[ZONEACE]

I give up on this. You've gone from calling WIFOM to completely ignoring the point of my questions, so you're obviously at the cognitive dissonance stage already.

When you come down, just look for someone useful to vote.

the problem erg0 is THEY are the someone useful to vote.

[White]

Care to give a case?

[Lemming1607]

I give up on this. You've gone from calling WIFOM to completely ignoring the point of my questions, so you're obviously at the cognitive dissonance stage already.

When you come down, just look for someone useful to vote.

but your point is WIFOM. That's why I'm not going to play your game

[JDodge]

WILL YOU PEOPLE STOP ARGUING ALREADY.

THIS IS POINTLESS AND IRRELEVANT TO LYNCHING WHITEY.

[White]

Lemming, what do you think of: Aimee, TS, Fonz and Ether?
Erg0, what do you think of: Zorg, Kscope, Zeppo and Flame?
Zoneace, what do you think of: Sir T, MoS, Yamahako and a special question for you: how do you think you've played this game? As good as you normally do? You've been off in this game? You've never played this badly? You don't think you've played all that bad?

[White]

Jdodge, can I hear a case against me? Do you have a case against me?

[Simenon]

Jdodge, can I hear a case against me? Do you have a case against me?

he obviously won't post one. he still thinks being useless is a good game plan as long as it gets you lynched.

thread lolz

[Lemming1607]

:iceburn:

[Lemming1607]

Aimee: lurking most of the game, huge megapost, but needs to post more. Leaning town
TS: weird vibes. I need to look at his posts more. Neutral
Fonz: I don't know why but I get scummy vibes off him. Need to look into it more.
Ether: I didn't even know Ether was playing

[Erg0]

What I think:

Zorg: Scummy, but too bold with his vote to be really embracing the noobscum ideal.

Kscope: More information required. Wagonny, possible scum.

Zeppo: Single issue candidate.

Flare: Lynch now pls.

Special bonus extended case (because I wasn't sure whether you were asking about Flare or him):

Flameaxe: I dunno. Seems fine, not much going on there. Post moar.

So why those four?

[White]

Ok, it's only 22 pages. You can sort the thread using the tabs at the bottom of the page. Can you filter out Fonz's and Ether's (not many) posts and then tell me how you feel about them? Feel free to quote them and ask questions.

[White]

Because honestly I just went to the first page, looked at who was playing and asked the currently active people to comment on other people that are in the game. Hoping to get conversation flowing in a nondistracting direction and it's always helpful to know where people are leaning and how they feel about others when they die.

[Erg0]

Ether: I didn't even know Ether was playing

Ether just posted yesterday. Plus, she agrees with me about Flare and is therefore awesome.

[Simenon]

Aimee: lurking most of the game, huge megapost, but needs to post more. Leaning town
TS: weird vibes. I need to look at his posts more. Neutral
Fonz: I don't know why but I get scummy vibes off him. Need to look into it more.
Ether: I didn't even know Ether was playing

Why those four players?

[White]

Because honestly I just went to the first page, looked at who was playing and asked the currently active people to comment on other people that are in the game. Hoping to get conversation flowing in a nondistracting direction and it's always helpful to know where people are leaning and how they feel about others when they die.

[Simenon]

Sorry, I thought you were responding to post 534

[booboodafool]

Im replacing Celtic and i'll have my review tomorrow after my test

[Ether]

How the hell can people produce this much garbage in 24 hours?

Flare is still scum. Still don't like Zeppo, Lemming, Zorg or White very much.

vote: Mastermind of Sin

Already making excuses for what he probably

knows

will turn out to be a townie lynch.

Wrong, I voted MoS on account of his being out of character. This has absolutely no bearing on my opinion of Flare's alignment. Independently of my observations on MoS, Flare's contributions seem to lean on the side of disruption, rather than contribution, so I would definitely add him to the scummy column.

...huh?

Yamahako's behavior bothers me, and while I don't really have issues with the attacks actually leveled at him, I keep associating those attacks with people I'm weary of. The votecount isn't as big on this as I'd thought. Hmm. Reread there is on my to-do list.

Feel free to quote them and ask questions.

Sweet, I love it when that happens. Do

you

have any questions or analysis for me, White?

Zorg: Scummy, but too bold with his vote to be really embracing the noobscum ideal.

I'm curious here for Zorg-centric reasons. Elaborate?

[Toaster Strudel]

Because honestly I just went to the first page, looked at who was playing and asked the currently active people to comment on other people that are in the game. Hoping to get conversation flowing in a nondistracting direction and it's always helpful to know where people are leaning and how they feel about others when they die.

It's a manner of play whereby you incite others to possibly compromise themselves (which is good if you catch scum) or bad if YOU are scum. Also, you incite others to compromise themselves, while avoiding to compromise yourself.

Do I make sense or am I as clear as mud?

[JDodge]

Jdodge, can I hear a case against me? Do you have a case against me?

No to the first, yes to the second

[Toaster Strudel]

Jdodge, can I hear a case against me? Do you have a case against me?

No to the first, yes to the second

Intriguing response to day the least.

[Erg0]

Zorg: Scummy, but too bold with his vote to be really embracing the noobscum ideal.

I'm curious here for Zorg-centric reasons. Elaborate?

Actually, I may have to retract that statement. I did a skim-through on Zorg yesterday for my own reference, and had the impression that he was being less cautious than I would expect from noobscum. Looking again just now I can see that I was probably mistaken, as he was 6th on the ZONEACE wagon and his vote for MoS was made amongst much equivocation. The only vote of his that was slightly bold was his vote on Celtic, but that came in the face of the big wagon on Flameaxe. I also note that he FoSed TS early and then followed her vote onto MoS, which is inconsistent. Upgrade Zorg back to scummy.

TS just blew my mind.