In post 759, Yarrrrgami wrote:
1. I can't really tell if he newbtelling bad town or if he is actually scum. he has pinged in a lot of places but ugh
By scum do you mean anti-town? If so, can he be Jester? Also, see my answer below!
In post 759, Yarrrrgami wrote:
2. if aronis was a jester I feel like he wld have been lynched by now. it isn't hard and there is actually a textbook formula that works every time.
Since I've never played in a game with Jester before, I know nothing about that "textbook formula". Can you explain it or would it help only the anti-town players?
One of my biggest problems is that we have
two
Jester candidates. It's very unlikely that both Snowman and Aronis are Jesters, so at least one of them is impersonating one. If so, there's a scum-PR which fits perfectly for that one. This may be resolved by Day3, but what if it's too late?
In post 759, Yarrrrgami wrote:
3. I don't feel like your questions are particularly very good nor do they seem like they are coming from a game solving place. just like your question to me about who was posting right now that you are somehow managing to tie to your original point to random.
your questions look like fillers and it looks like you are trying to look busy cos I have not seen any useful conclusions after you ask them and they have been answered. and yes I gave you a very direct response to your obtuse question/observation whatever the fuck you call it earlier so stop trying to throw shade.
it looks like you are trying to construct a narrative rather than trying to figure the game out. the problem that I am having is that I have seen you do this as both alignments.
A part of my logic is not a secret at all. There are 4 town and 5 anti-town players out there. I try to decide which one of you belongs to which category. Finding the 4 townies is just as good as finding all the anti-towns. (Normally, it wouldn't work but in this Setup it doesn't look a bad idea.)
Here's Randomidget, for example. I remember putting him on the town list but it was pointed out by FAQ (who's on my townlist) that I could be wrong. Indeed, I ruled out him as Mafia (see my earlier posts) but not as Third-party.
The goal of my questions was is to see how "involved" answers I get. His
735 was very empty and it lacked any effort of scumhunting. No reasoning about Druuge (his
740 is very little). No opinion about Esp. (his answer in the same post was actually terrible:
"A lot of people have just been putting espe as scum/nullscum since I voted shos."
– I can see no connection between those events. Also, voting for Shos is bad.) He said he'd check your posts, and that never happened.
________
Randomidget, I'm not only talking about you here, I'm also talking TO you. What can you tell me about those things above?
________
The other part behind my logic is hidden, on the other hand. I think I have a quite close guess about the PR-distribution. Also, I have a dilemma what to do next. (As for the former sentence, I think you too have a picture in your heads, and you may have realized the second sentence by now.) But, revealing these things would mean more loss than gain for the town. That may look as if I were throwing shade.
Can you follow me?
In post 760, FA_Q2 wrote:Normally he would have been lynched. There is a real possibility that such an action is anti-town though. I fear that we may be seriously lacking killing roles though and that might be an issue dealing with jesters...
Or our Killing PRs are dumbs.
In post 761, FA_Q2 wrote:With the way that snowman has been tunneling shos in an uncharacteristic manner from any play previously in this game I am beginning to suspect that he is a lyncher.
His Day1 doesn't fit that picture. But, even if I'm wrong about this, he'll never be able to get Shos lynched. So we needn't worry.
In post 763, shos wrote:Is there any role that profits from killing the jester? Third party? Scum? Anyone? As it is like that, any L-1 vote is effectively a hammer because aronis is practically compromised.
As far as I know only the Jester him/herself.
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
