MINI 504- PEGBAM...GAME OVER!

[Oman]

That line sucks.

[Karen]

Also, wouldn't the logical investigation, panzer, be originality? I mean, you were voting for him at the end of day 1. And no, I am not treating you like a treated jdodge. Jdodge was a joke, you are not. I got a guilty on you panzer, and my investigation actually makes sense.

if this is the "logical investigation," why did scotmany12 (cop claim) NOT investigate originality?

on the other hand, if scotmany12 is scum, and assumed the cop would make the "logical investigation," he would NK originality, and render the cop's nightmove useless.

through his own logic, he has trapped himself, giving a huge scumtell, telling us as to why originality is dead. thus, his counter-claim is trying to distract us from the faulty logic (from above, you are calling it illogical) of how he "investigated" panzer.

panzer's "investigation" of poppin was not necessarily the best choice, but at least he has plausible reasoning (e.g. lurking) for it.

vote: scotmany12.

[PJ.]

That is good posting.

[Oman]

unvote

Wow, Karen that is some good logic.

I'll think on this.

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

Well, this is interesting. This needs some thought.

Unvote

[Oman]

FTR: I don't think mafia killed orig, he had too many votes on him to be logical.

[scotmany12]

Karen, that is not true at all. I get it is my fault for how i worded it. Panzer's logical investigation would be for originality. He was voting for him at the end of day 1, and thus, he would most likely be the person panzer thought to be most scummy.

Now I investigated panzer. That is the logical investigation for me as I found him to be the most scummy. I was voting for him at the end of day 1 because of what chron was doing. I had my reasons for voting for chron, and that is basically why I investigated panzer.

Now If panzer investigated poppin for lurking, why did he choose her over the rest of the lurkers? When you think about it, his reasoning is not that plausible because there were more then one person lurking at the end of day 1.

[PJ.]

Well, simply i chose her over other because I am friends with Poppin, good friends. Plus, scumchat jokes live on. "Poppin is always scum" I tested the theory. That why I chose her.

I didn't think orig was scummy, well any less scummy then sammich. I didn't understand the sammich lynch really when i read through. Seemed like mafia drove that lynch almost singly handedly and used the deadline to lynch him.

[scotmany12]

So you voted for someone who you didn't consider scummy, or at least the most scummiest?

[PJ.]

I did consider him scummy, don't get me wrong. I just think lurking is more deserving of an investigation then stupidity.

[Oman]

Sorry, unavaliable next 48hrs, Australian weekend. sorry

[pickemgenius]

~ 9 Days till Deadline.


Giving Morb&Poppin 2 days to post before replacement searching starts.

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

I'm inclined to return my vote to Panzer if he doesn't present a good case on why he should live.

[PJ.]

I should live because I'm the real cop, and I think that's a damn good reason. And on top of that I have actually been trying to make a difference in this game, unlike scot who has been blindly calling people scum(i.e me and Jdog). Look, I have at least been, in my short time in this game, trying to make some what of an attempt to catch scum. Scotmany is scum, thats the only thing in this paragraph that matters. Scot is scum.

[Oman]

Back.

Panzer's logical investigation would be for originality. He was voting for him at the end of day 1, and thus, he would most likely be the person panzer thought to be most scummy.

wrong. A cop should investigate who he/she cannot read. I agree it was dumb of panzer to throw his investigation away like that on a lurker, who wouldn't do any damage at this point if they WERE scum.

Vote Karen

She's tried to pin orig's death on two people now, me and panzer.

[scotmany12]

Panzer I haven't been blindly calling you scum. I had my reasons for that. You obviously don't understand that I found chronX the most scummiest at the end of the day, which is why I investigated you. When I got a guilty on you, that was basically the nail in the coffin. Oh and how have you been trying to make a game a difference? At least how much more of this have you be doing than me? YOU DID NOTHING DAY 1 PANZER. You replaced in and placed a vote on originality with no reasoning at all. I don't see this attempt to catch scum panzer.

Oh and oman, I do not think karen is the lynch, as we have two claimed cops. You should probably pick one of me or panzer.

[JDodge]

Oh and oman, I do not think karen is the lynch, as we have two claimed cops. You should probably pick one of me or panzer.

You're missing the possibility of 2 cops with varying sanities, which makes me more hesitant to vote you; I think we can get more info from letting you live another night.

Also, Karen isn't the lynch. Distad is.

[Oman]

Actually Scot, leaving Panzer alive is a good thing. There is currently doubt. If you are NKed, there will be no doubt. Thus panzerscum would not be in a good spot if he NKed you.

Vice Versa as well.

[scotmany12]

I disagree with both you and jdodge, oman. Both me and panzer should not survive the day. One of us is scum, so you guys have to decide which one to believe. And jdodge, I doubt the two cop thing. Yes its possible, but not plausible. And since I have a guilty result, I am not going to be hesitant with trying to get panzer lynched. I am not going to doubt my sanity, I am going to believe that I am sane until proven otherwise.

[Oman]

But if we leave you alive, scum will not NK you to protect panzer. Thus you get many more nights of investigations. If they do NK you, we kill panzer (or vice versa if panzer is a cop) and move on.

If panzer is lynched scum we lose a cop (scot) to NK. If panzer is lynched cop we lose a cop (panzer) and possibly an insane cop (scot) to the next day.

[scotmany12]

I was kinda leaning towards there being a doc Oman. And I do not think scum would keep me alive anyways.

[Oman]

well...yes. But IF there is two cops, there will be no doc.

[scotmany12]

1 cop and 1 doc is much more believable than two cops with different sanities.

[JDodge]

Fine then, you want a lynch, you got it.

Unvote, vote: Scot

Diescumdie

[scotmany12]

I'm interested into why you believe panzer over me.