Mini 500 - Cult Mafia - Game Over!

[Guardian]

Official Vote Count #32

Trojan Horse[3](theopor_COD, tyhess, pwayne66)
White[2](Flameaxe, Oman)
Flameaxe[2](White, vollkan)
Tarhalindur[2](Mastermind of Sin, curiouskarmadog)
tyhess[1](Tarhalindur)


Not Voting[2](Kakeng, Trojan Horse)

[Tarhalindur]

At the risk of OMGUS, after a quick readthrough I'm getting very suspicious of MoS.

I've seen MoS's play in long D1's when he's town (ongoing game). Something feels off about him here. He's attacking players, but given the way in which he's attacking players, I get the feeling that he's not really trying to hunt scum. It feels to me as if MoS is casting suspicion and trying to avoid stepping on toes by discussing theory, both of which are scummy.

I want to take a closer look at MoS's posts to find something more concrete, but I'm going to

Vote: MoS

in the meantime anyways.

[Mastermind of Sin]

And it doesn't mean anything to you that:

a) I used a different strategy in this game (at least I can't remember any long D1's where I acted scummy to draw out scum)
b) I have spent the majority of this game defending myself, giving me little room to attack
c) This game has gone in circles and come out with no one that can really be argued well as scum

[White]

I don't really mind a or c but b? I mean come on. There's no reason you can't pick apart someone. What about when me and Flame were going at it for those few pages? You had plenty of time. Saying you've been so busy defending yourself that you couldn't hunt scum is a lie. Stop lying MoS.

[tyhess]

All he was trying to do there was set a trap and the first person to call him on that (for not attacking) is deffiently scum just using the easy way out (end sarcasm)

[White]

I didn't understand much more than that there were words in that post but I didn't really comprehend it.

[tyhess]

hahaha.....well I was trying to point out the fact to MoS of how stupid it was to try to set his little trap and call anyone who "felt for it" scum. I was saying that he would say that if anyone called him out for getting a chance to attack someone and not doing so that they were defeinelty scum and trying to get an easy lynch.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I don't really mind a or c but b? I mean come on. There's no reason you can't pick apart someone. What about when me and Flame were going at it for those few pages? You had plenty of time. Saying you've been so busy defending yourself that you couldn't hunt scum is a lie. Stop lying MoS.

I wasn't paying much attention to the game back then. I was lurking in about half my games back then. I was talking about since I've actually become active again.

[Mastermind of Sin]

hahaha.....well I was trying to point out the fact to MoS of how stupid it was to try to set his little trap and call anyone who "felt for it" scum. I was saying that he would say that if anyone called him out for getting a chance to attack someone and not doing so that they were defeinelty scum and trying to get an easy lynch.

Your attempt at humor/sarcasm is full of fail. I didn't call everyone scum, and I didn't call anyone "definitely" scum. If anything, you're the one who is saying I am definitely scum, rather than the other way around. I merely said that I was very certain that there was *a* scum among those who attacked me. That doesn't make them all scum, and I'm not at all sure which one it is. Stop putting words in my mouth, please. If you keep making things up about me I might have to think you're scum trying to make me look bad, eh? Town don't make shit up, you shouldn't either.

[Trojan Horse]

Saying you've been so busy defending yourself that you couldn't hunt scum is a lie. Stop lying MoS.

Well, I wasn't really hunting scum when I was being attacked, either. Then again, I guess I wasn't doing much better when I WASN'T being attacked.

Anyway, I'm more concerned about MoS's lower than usual level of scumhunting

before

he was attacked (as I've said before); what he said

while

he was attacked didn't seem scummy to me.

[Trojan Horse]

Whoa, MoS posts twice while I'm posting. Lemme quickly look over what he said...

[Trojan Horse]

Okay. I'm also confused by tyhess's comments. Definitely don't think MoS was setting a "trap" there.

Careful, tyhess. I've been attacked big time (and possibly deservedly so) for making jokes, and the same could happen to you. Then again, if you really are scum, feel free to look as scummy as you want

[tyhess]

hahaha.....well I was trying to point out the fact to MoS of how stupid it was to try to set his little trap and call anyone who "felt for it" scum. I was saying that he would say that if anyone called him out for getting a chance to attack someone and not doing so that they were defeinelty scum and trying to get an easy lynch.

Your attempt at humor/sarcasm is full of fail. I didn't call everyone scum, and I didn't call anyone "definitely" scum. If anything, you're the one who is saying I am definitely scum, rather than the other way around. I merely said that I was very certain that there was *a* scum among those who attacked me. That doesn't make them all scum, and I'm not at all sure which one it is. Stop putting words in my mouth, please. If you keep making things up about me I might have to think you're scum trying to make me look bad, eh? Town don't make shit up, you shouldn't either.

You said that you were "very certain" there was someone scum on your "bandwagon", and that that was the point of you acting scummish-to try to trap scum. And yeah, in a 12 player game with 2 scum and a cultish, chances are that 1 out of the 5 are not protown. The "trap" didn't help out at all. I was merely suggesting that you might be trying the tactic again, and yet again showing you have faulty (at times) strategy.

[pwayne66]

am i alone in not wanting to rehash this?

[tyhess]

its something to talk about before kak and tar finish rereading.....unless of cours tar is done tlaknig after his one post......

[pwayne66]

That's fine,

I feel you brother...

...I've been down that dark alley...

...I can appreciate its allure...

[White]

Pwayne, you're not alone.

Ok, my own tentative deadline is for the 10th. I think it'd be best if we all start putting people on the chopping block and getting defences by then. That'll give us 2-4 days (I forget what the deadline is) to figure out what we're going to do and get organized. We can't just sit around and wait here for lurkers that evidently aren't even checking the thread.

Who else is in favor of cracking down around the 10th?

[Trojan Horse]

I'm with you, White. Anyway, if I'm still clueless by then, two more days won't help me any.

[Flameaxe]

/sign White's motion. This will give us two days extra just in case something big happens and a lynch just won't work on the 10th.

[tyhess]

Yeah, I agree, 10th it is.

[vollkan]

Ok, my own tentative deadline is for the 10th. I think it'd be best if we all start putting people on the chopping block and getting defences by then. That'll give us 2-4 days (I forget what the deadline is) to figure out what we're going to do and get organized. We can't just sit around and wait here for lurkers that evidently aren't even checking the thread.

Who else is in favor of cracking down around the 10th?

I agree. It's a real nuisance where deadlines simply roll over and things get rushed so this is good.

[Mastermind of Sin]

hahaha.....well I was trying to point out the fact to MoS of how stupid it was to try to set his little trap and call anyone who "felt for it" scum. I was saying that he would say that if anyone called him out for getting a chance to attack someone and not doing so that they were defeinelty scum and trying to get an easy lynch.

Your attempt at humor/sarcasm is full of fail. I didn't call everyone scum, and I didn't call anyone "definitely" scum. If anything, you're the one who is saying I am definitely scum, rather than the other way around. I merely said that I was very certain that there was *a* scum among those who attacked me. That doesn't make them all scum, and I'm not at all sure which one it is. Stop putting words in my mouth, please. If you keep making things up about me I might have to think you're scum trying to make me look bad, eh? Town don't make shit up, you shouldn't either.

You said that you were "very certain" there was someone scum on your "bandwagon", and that that was the point of you acting scummish-to try to trap scum. And yeah, in a 12 player game with 2 scum and a cultish, chances are that 1 out of the 5 are not protown. The "trap" didn't help out at all. I was merely suggesting that you might be trying the tactic again, and yet again showing you have faulty (at times) strategy.

No. Just, no. If I had a daykill I would kill you right now just for sheer stupidity, and I don't give a fuck if saying this makes me look "scummy". 4 < 5, therefore, I have already improved your chances of finding scum by narrowing it down to my wagon. By focusing on those four people (not ignoring the rest of the people, mind), you can determine which one of them is most likely to be scum and lynch them. This is NOT a faulty strategy, and I'm starting to think that you might have an alterior motive for trying to debunk my original plan.

Unvote, Vote: tyhess

This is as close to a daykill as I can get.

P.S. - I didn't do anything scummy this time around, so it's not possible for me to have been repeating my tactic from before. Secondly, now that I've revealed my tactic, it's not going to work again. I'm not stupid, but maybe you are.

[Oman]

put me down for the 10th. I'd comment, but thats the only interesting thing this page bar mos' change in avatar.

[tyhess]

Alterior motive? Maybe thinking that your scum? And what does 4<5 mean anyways?? And what about the people not voting for you? You said we shouldn't ignore them but if we focus on just them from now until the deadlien that's what we'd be doing. Should we give them a free pass because they didn't fall for the "trap"?


And your tactic never worked, so it can't work agian.......

[Flameaxe]

By focusing on those four people (not ignoring the rest of the people, mind)

*cough*Answer*cough*