Mini 1768: Detective Conan Mafia (Game Over: Town Wins)

[Phoenix Wright]

I'd still like you to elaborate on that scurvy accusation. It's a bit hard for me to explain whatever it is you saw if I don't know what it is.

Ye've held very few positions, one of which be that armor-pirate be town. Ye stated this position without addressin' or makin' any inferences about what that meant about the alignment of other pirates, even though that be the obvious non-scurvyminded direction to be takin' that (especially since soren is looking pretty scurvy-like). Ye later defend the pudding pirate.

The other position ye held was the scourge vote, which ye backed out of all prompt-like when forced to elaborate on it.

The barn vote be itself fine, but the justification is silly. Scurvy dogs do not make grand plans about making the honest pirates get all disputin'-like, and I don't see how you would honestly think that. "Rubbing people the wrong way" has very little scurvy motivation in itself.

[Phoenix Wright]

I agree that not Mafia and tails need to explain their votes more though

[Radical Rat]

Alright then, Yarrrrgami's vote goes into the somewhat reasonable pile.

[Tails]

Sonic's vote on Soren is opportunistic, and he's overjustifying his being on the wagon.

[Radical Rat]

Opportunistic how? Because it wasn't the first vote?

And the "overjustification" is just me trying to keep my thought process clear.

[Not_Mafia]

Gotta scum fast

[Radical Rat]

Gotta scum fast

I'll interpret that as your "vote randomly" thing.

I hope that works out for you.

[Tails]

Soren was an easy vote to push, and you used easy and stale reasoning to push it. Moreover, you forced your arguments in order to justify why you were voting there.

[Phoenix Wright]

but Soren's defense of it has just been 'he looked like scum' over and over

What would be a TOWN RESPONSE!!?!

Waiting for a claim when we already have someone literally waiting to hammer? Letting the day run its course so we can have full discussion? Literally anything other than a quickhammer?

I learned not to hammer prematurely in my very first Mafia game. The only time it even remotely makes sense is as scum.

It's still an Anti-Town move and should be treated as such. At least until we get a decent explanation.

If you excuse everything scummy because "Town might maybe also do that sometimes" then how do you propose we find scum, hm?

Tails, what about this seems stale and forced? Also, you do real is that he's not even voting Soren anymore, right?

[Phoenix Wright]

*realize

[Soren]

I'll admit that the hammer was bad because I didn't give him time to come to the thread and claim. I'm not sure ARS is expecting more from me, I gave my reason already, I didn't have any scum reads, it was the most likely lynch to go through that day and I didn't think he looked town, so I hammered.

[Soren]

I may have missed your point so link me your post if you already explained it but I'm not seeing the evaluation to draw the conclusion that the hammer was scum motivated.
I want you to consider my quickhammer to come from town, and then consider my quickhammer to come from scum.
Then tell me why the action is more likely to come from scum than town.

[KainTepes]

UNVOTE:

[A Real Scourge]

I'll admit that the hammer was bad because I didn't give him time to come to the thread and claim. I'm not sure ARS is expecting more from me, I gave my reason already, I didn't have any scum reads, it was the most likely lynch to go through that day and I didn't think he looked town, so I hammered.

this is what i was looking for. i asked you why you did it, and you responded defensively and didn't say anything about it being a quickhammer and you not giving him time to claim.
UNVOTE:

I may have missed your point so link me your post if you already explained it but I'm not seeing the evaluation to draw the conclusion that the hammer was scum motivated.
I want you to consider my quickhammer to come from town, and then consider my quickhammer to come from scum.
Then tell me why the action is more likely to come from scum than town.

i explained it twice, i'll link it if ya really want but you can ISO me if you're curious.
the hammer by itself is hard to analyze for scum or town motivation, but it was bad so i pressured you on it to see what would come of it. it's only now that you've responded in a way that didn't make you look like scum to me, hence the unvote. (that, and i'm more interested in Sonic)
Not_Mafia was defending you by saying that the hammer wouldn't have come from scum, and i explained how their

could

be scum motivation, as a rebuttal to his argument that the action was actually towny because scum wouldn't do it.
VOTE: Radical Rat

what's your read on me from all this, Soren? and your reads on the other people who were on your wagon?

[Radical Rat]

That puts me at... L-2? Or is Nick also voting for me and I should get a claim out?

[Phoenix Wright]

I'm not voting you

[Firebringer]

Get the rat!
Is what I say.

[Radical Rat]

Oh, I forgot FireBringer.

Okay, so I'm L-1 which means time to claim.....

Yumi Miyamoto, Town Roleblocker.
I blocked Not_Mafia last night, as Yarrrrgami can probably confirm, unless there's a second, scummier Roleblocker in our midst, which is what I was trying to figure out earlier toDay.

[Firebringer]

UNVOTE:

[Yarrrrgami]

Oh, I forgot FireBringer.

Okay, so I'm L-1 which means time to claim.....

Yumi Miyamoto, Town Roleblocker.
I blocked Not_Mafia last night, as Yarrrrgami can probably confirm, unless there's a second, scummier Roleblocker in our midst, which is what I was trying to figure out earlier toDay.

I be confirming that the claimin-to-be-non-scurvy pirate was blocked.

Anything else ye want to be claiming?

[Radical Rat]

Anything else I want to be claiming? No, I think that covers it.

[Yarrrrgami]

Ye have a strange sort o' roleblockin' power. There be more to claim.

[Radical Rat]

I'm afraid not. Just a Roleblocker.

Did something else happen to Not_Mafia?

[Yarrrrgami]

Can ye be paraphrasin' what the captain scrawled to ye about your deckhand-duty disruptin' ability?

[Radical Rat]

Yeah, it says during nighttime I can PM who I want to block.

Nothing else but the usual win when all mafia are defeated thing.