Mini 1768: Detective Conan Mafia (Game Over: Town Wins)

[Phoenix Wright]

What's with the not Mafia votes?

[KainTepes]

HE STOLE MY AVATAR.....

[Phoenix Wright]

HE STOLE MY AVATAR.....

You stole his. I don't know how you could forget that not once, but twice...

[Frozen Angel]

He is a pure troll omg

[Frozen Angel]

I will catchup with day 2 soon.

sorry for lack of activity

[KainTepes]

I WAS JOKING, IT WAS SUPPOSED TO BE FUNNY!!!!

[Frozen Angel]

hahahahahahaha

look I'm laughing!

hahahahahahahaha

[KainTepes]

thanks

[Soren]

can we talk about Soren's hammering Barn without a claim? we would have unvoted if he'd claimed CONAN the ROLECOP. :/

If he flipped vanilla townie would you have the same view on me right now?
Because his role has nothing to do with how he played in the game.

i probably wouldn't be as annoyed about it, i would still be on your case about hammering without a claim.
that's just proper course, it doesn't matter what their play is like, you ask for a claim before hammering. why didn't you? i made my intent to hammer very clear so that Barn would know he needed to claim, but you decided to hammer anyways, before Barn even got back.

I hammered because his slot didn't look town.

[KainTepes]

that is terribe, you should at least wait for him to claim....

VOTE: SOREN

[Radical Rat]

VOTE: Soren

[Phoenix Wright]

can we talk about Soren's hammering Barn without a claim? we would have unvoted if he'd claimed CONAN the ROLECOP. :/

If he flipped vanilla townie would you have the same view on me right now?
Because his role has nothing to do with how he played in the game.

i probably wouldn't be as annoyed about it, i would still be on your case about hammering without a claim.
that's just proper course, it doesn't matter what their play is like, you ask for a claim before hammering. why didn't you? i made my intent to hammer very clear so that Barn would know he needed to claim, but you decided to hammer anyways, before Barn even got back.

I hammered because his slot didn't look town.

You know who hammers people without giving them a chance to claim or defend themselves? Scum

VOTE: soren

[Not_Mafia]

Town does that too

[Phoenix Wright]

Oh, wait. It was Not Mafia who hammered. UNVOTE: VOTE: not Mafia

[Not_Mafia]

False

[Phoenix Wright]

You were the last one to vote him before the mod said he was lynched.

[Phoenix Wright]

Never mind. Kain and you voted for him multiple times when you were already voting him so I got confused. Yeah, it was Soren UNVOTE:

[A Real Scourge]

no, it was definitely soren who hammered. right?

Soren, you don't even acknowledge that what you did was wrong! you just defend it! a player getting run up to L-1 ALWAYS looks like scum.. that's why they're there. you always get a claim.

VOTE: Soren

With 11 players alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.

and Kaiin, yeah it's true that town hammers without a claim.. but Soren's defense of it has just been 'he looked like scum' over and over, while not responding to what i've actually been saying or saying why lynching him without a claim was a good option.

[Yarrrrgami]

Who else be appearin' scurvy-like to you, furry-seduction pirate?

[Not_Mafia]

and Kaiin, yeah it's true that town hammers without a claim.. but Soren's defense of it has just been 'he looked like scum' over and over, while not responding to what i've actually been saying or saying why lynching him without a claim was a good option.

I'm not Kain

[A Real Scourge]

right, you weren't yelling. in my defense you guys have literally the exact same avatar. can you contribute something useful now?

Yarrrgami, i really don't like Not_Mafia and Sonic is giving me some weird vibes.
i'm kinda more suspicious of FA then i was yesterday, but it's still a townread. Phoenix is town, and Kain could honestly go either way, i have absolutely no idea. everything else is the same as what i've said.
i have my eye on you as well, i think you'll be the most difficult for me to read because your play is really pro-town. also i want to know how you feel about Soren after his post and the bunch of votes on him. (they all happened in a row, which is a bit sus, but they were all in response to the same post of Soren's so it's hard to tell. i've had wagons build on me for one post.

[Not_Mafia]

but Soren's defense of it has just been 'he looked like scum' over and over

What would be a TOWN RESPONSE!!?!

[Radical Rat]

but Soren's defense of it has just been 'he looked like scum' over and over

What would be a TOWN RESPONSE!!?!

Waiting for a claim when we already have someone literally waiting to hammer? Letting the day run its course so we can have full discussion? Literally anything other than a quickhammer?

I learned not to hammer prematurely in my very first Mafia game. The only time it even remotely makes sense is as scum.

[Not_Mafia]

Yet town still quickhammer

[Radical Rat]

It's still an Anti-Town move and should be treated as such. At least until we get a decent explanation.

If you excuse everything scummy because "Town might maybe also do that sometimes" then how do you propose we find scum, hm?