Mini 500 - Cult Mafia - Game Over!

[Guardian]

Official Vote Count #31

Trojan Horse[2](theopor_COD, tyhess)
White[2](Flameaxe, Oman)
Flameaxe[2](White, vollkan)
tyhess[1](Tarhalindur)
Tarhalindur[1](Mastermind of Sin)

Not Voting[4](curiouskarmadog, pwayne66, Kakeng, Trojan Horse)

[White]

Ok....uh....deadline on Oct 12 and the largest bandwagon has...2 votes. In-credible.

In an attempt to help consentrate our efforts, I guess I wouldn't mind a TH lynch or a Kekeng lynch. I think we would learn a lot from a MoS lynch but I don't think i'm ready to lynch him yet as he's shown some attitude and interest. I would personally prefer a Flameaxe lynch though.

[Flameaxe]

I bet you would.

[White]

Care to add your thoughts? Who you would prefer for a lynch today? Perhaps...why you prefer them? Who you think we'd get a lot of info from if they were lynched and who you could be talked into compromising and lynching because you're currently very suspicious of them already?

[tyhess]

I think tar and kak posting their thoughts will help out the game tremendously....But at this point, Trojan Horse is still my most scummish like, but I would not think twice about lynching MoS-he's been acting scum like imo most of the game.....

[Oman]

I would only go for a Trojan Horse, White, or Tyhess lynch, kar is not nearly as scummy as you're making him out to be (Then again, White isn't as scummy as the other two on my list).

[tyhess]

Oman-why am I and Trojan more scummy than White? Why is kar not suspiscious as were making him? Why not MoS (I think you had a vote for him at one point)?

[Flameaxe]

@White:

Tyhess, Troj, White, Kageng, CKD, MoS, Pwayne, Ouman, Tar, Vollkan. In order.

Tyhess: Constant bandwagon hopping and MoS attacking; not a whole lot of posting either.
Troj: Doesn't have his own opinion on people; easily pressured into voting (and unvoting) recently.
White: See my post a few pages ago (27).
Kageng: Replaced AC (lurked in plain sight early on, vanished later on), still waiting for the rest of that analysis...before the deadline would be just peachy.
CKD: Under the radar most of today, in my opinion. Hasn't really come under any pressure yet.
MoS: His "trap" did make him look scummy, but I'm finding myself believing that "it's a trap!" (Admiral Ackbar!)
Pwayne: Seemed fairly townie early on, not sure what to make of his recent absence.
Ouman: Overall seems fairly townie to me.
Tar: Haven't heard anything from him yet, lynching him before we do would be just plain dumb.
Vollkan: Same deal as Ouman.

[Oman]

I took my vote off MoS and called him town a while ago, though I'm not 100% sure on that.

The others have cases scattered through the game. Go look for it. I'm lazy.

[White]

White: See my post a few pages ago (27).

I love your post, thank you again for posting and helping out.

I do recall addressing your post. Could this time you tell me what points in my defence you didn't like or weren't adequate?

[curiouskarmadog]

my current top two are:

I do find it interesting that everyone was jumping on the "I want a deadline extension just to look town" but no one is bringing anything to the table.

2.) Oman, just havent liked his comments most of the game. It almost feels like everytime he posts, my scumdar pings. really no case though, more of a hunch...

1.) Tar/Dr. BS, I thought BS's play up front was scummy, and gave him the benefit of the doubt...however that was the only thing he brought to the table, then disappeared. Only posts, Tar has had since he has been here was to jump on an easy target and to request a deadline extension, which he has not used at all...

Vote Tar

...why are you hanging so low? Why did you want an extension if you werent going to ask questions, push a case, do..well anything?

I think tyhess and kageng are newbies...not sure whether they are scum or not, but they are worth keeping and eye on..

pwayne, was one of those that wanted an extension, but hasnt put anything out there..(still waiting).

[Trojan Horse]

Tar had limited access for a few days (or so he claimed in the V/LA thread). But he's back now, and posting in his other games. I assume he just needs to be prodded.

Mod, prod Tar

Mod Edit: done.

If the prod doesn't do the trick, then I'm willing to vote for him. But I'll wait until the mod has had a chance to track him down.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Seems like my dice roll put me in the right place

[Tarhalindur]

Guys, this is currently the last priority on my priority list.

I should finish rereading in the next 1-2 days. More comments when that ends.

[Kakeng]

I will have to be off until oct 5th because of an important exam. this is the onl chance I have of logging on the com, so sorry.

[pwayne66]

My 4 most scummy- TH, tyhess, MoS, Flameaxe,

and in no particular order-

Mastermind of Sin- My thoughts are documented at length.

Oman- I haven't changed my position here either. At one point I said that I felt he a lackadaisical approach to the game, and White said he felt he took the game too serious. He posts alot of one liners and responds when asked to (which is more than I can say for most of the people here...) but hasn't seemed too keen on initiating conversation.

Kakeng (r. ac1983fan)- jury's out. Seems to be trying to reread (30+ pages...)

vollkan- initially scummy by association to MoS, IMO. If I were to be honest, I'm seeing nothing bad on him for now.

Tarhalindur (r. Dr. Blackstrike)- yup...

curiouskarmadog- rightfully calls me out for lurking after the Extension request. Does appear to me to be flying under the radar.

tyhess- Early bandwagoning. but his playstyle seems to be improving. Too little too late?

Trojan Horse- wishy washy. Vollkan said this "If I put a smiley face there it can't be held against me" I think this is spot on.

Flameaxe- I can understand not liking white, his aggressive gameplay or his demanding style. Its the overall lack of contribution that bothers me, not just your responses to white.

White (r. Rump-Wat)- overly-aggressive and at times distracting. Seems pro-town despite this because of his inquisitiveness and his insistence that we all answer all the question asked of us by everybody.

theopor_COD- I hate to say it, but after 30+ pages, I still don't have much of read on him. I'll go back and see what else I am able to come up with.

Vote:Trojan Horse

[Trojan Horse]

Well pwayne, at least your #2 and #3 are the same as my #1 and #2.

You've got until Wednesday night, Tar. Then talk, or else!

Not sure how to react to Kakeng's latest post. Had he been in the game from the start- not a replacement- I wouldn't think anything of it. RL struck, big deal. But this is the guy that replaced acfan. I can't help but wonder about that. Then again, at least Kakeng has given us a reasonable reason for absence; can't say the same about acfan.

[White]

I'm in an ongoing game with Kakeng and I can verify that he has been completely absent from that game as well. I highly doubt he's lurking on purpose.

[pwayne66]

whoa... It's no wonder I am having trouble keeping my games from bleeding together. White, theo and Kakeng are all in another game with me. I thought that I was going retarded because I swore somebody would say something that they didn't and then I would find it later...

[tyhess]

tar amd kak-neither posts for like 2 days and then they make back to back? Coincidence? I think not.....


Ok all kidding aside (^^^^and I wasn't being serious), I honeslty don't know how much more we can get done until they post there comments. We have beaten each other to death for like a month, and nothing serious has happened in the last couple of days (except for oman completely ignoring my question)....I think 2 more opinons/set of attacks will be what opens the game up...We need to figure something out within the next week or so though.....

[vollkan]

Ok all kidding aside (^^^^and I wasn't being serious), I honeslty don't know how much more we can get done until they post there comments. We have beaten each other to death for like a month, and nothing serious has happened in the last couple of days (except for oman completely ignoring my question)....I think 2 more opinons/set of attacks will be what opens the game up...We need to figure something out within the next week or so though.....

I agree with this. We've all had our views for a while now, so I think we need Tar and Kak to sort of add a new perspective.

[White]

whoa... It's no wonder I am having trouble keeping my games from bleeding together. White, theo and Kakeng are all in another game with me.

Isn't it fun? I think i'm in 3-4 games with Theo atm.

[Oman]

I don't know how much trouble I'm going to get in for this, but it needs be said:

Are we going to lynch soon or wait for deadline? I simply ask because D1 has been bled pretty dry and the lack of info means we're not going many places.

[White]

I think it'll turn into a trojan lynch if Tar and Kak don't speak up but we're waiting for them.

[tyhess]

I think we should set our own deadline of about the 11th just to make sure that we don't go on a whim and end up with a no lynch....like we're all going to vote for trojan, white says something scumlike on the 12th, and then we have 1/2 the votes for trojan, and the other half for white....