(1765) Star Wars: The Force Awakens [D5]

[camn]

Also... You wanna leave claimed scum alive..and if he doesn't shoot like you tell him to, then you Lynch me for it? Leaving the scum alive another night? Knowing that he might just get busdriven away from me? That is not a good strategy, IMO.

Also, I understand you think things...but to me, in the game of mafia, "confirmed" generally means flips. Not just what you allegedly think.
Or in dead normals, a players stated results AFTER they die and flip.
You saying "confirmed" over and over doesn't make it true.

[TheTrollie]

There are 5 (5) scum and apparently only 1 (1) scum faction.

I'm in no rush to lynch 3ps that can likely win with town.

If this is your reaction though, bye.

That literally answers zero parts of my question.

Why ask for my claim if you're trying to tell us you knew it anyway? That doesn't help shit and you know it.

I don't know your claim

... but why would it matter to town-you ?

Because you might be third party and not scum!

But this heavily implies that you're not.

It is confirmed to me.

[TheTrollie]

oops, forget those quotes, those must have been left over from the long post i did before

[TheTrollie]

I know my plan, which is to leave both guilty claims alone for the night is sorta crazy, but it is I believe the best strategy. given the number of anti-town factions and win-cons in this game.

[camn]

I see some of the sense in it, except that RC is town.
Also, the idea of lining up a Lynch on me if Aero shoots wrong is crazy.
If we do that instead of just lynching him...and we consider he is actually mafia, then he gets 2 free kills, plus a mislynch on me...instead of just lynching claimed scum. That's crazy-pants.
Even if you imagine I am scum, that's 2 townies dead for no reason.

If we are going to leash Aero...we need to lynch AERO if he shoots wrong! But we shouldn't.

[TheTrollie]

not answering this stupid fucking discussion

[RadiantCowbells]

lol.

bad trollie.

[TheLoneWolf]

No idea what trollkes post is about but if that's how things have devolved I think this day is ready to end with an Aero lynch

[TheTrollie]

an aero lynch is out of the question.

Here is lynch order

(1) RC
(2) Camn
(3) Aero

That is all

[Aeronaut]

Wait what? I'm confused about why you'd lynch RC over your

claimed guilty

[Venmar]

We should still lynch Aero first. He's just going to shoot me and town will lose another player.

[Aeronaut]

I probably wouldn't, actually.

[Aeronaut]

idk. I'll shoot whoever Gork/RC tell me, because everyone else is scum or stupid

[Extrapolated Eagle]

Wait what? I'm confused about why you'd lynch RC over your

claimed guilty

Because RC might be lyncher. I need to think about this though, Uve been skeptical of RC scum.

[Aeronaut]

Actually yea.

tbh I haven't been paying as much attention since I claimed, but I think Trollie is probably a lyncher the more I think about it.

[Aeronaut]

RC... i dunno. I also sort of started blocking him out because he was pretty much one-note.

[Venmar]

Lyncher is such a stupid role, I hope Reckful did not it in this game.

For the record, Reckful did say that this game is not bastard, Lyncher is a role that is considered bastard by quite a few players.

And why is RC possibly being a lyncher matter? It's unlikely and if he actually is we still kill a non-town as his target is probably non town anyways?

[Venmar]

Like, the guy leaves the game if he wins. It's counter-productive to waste a lynch on him if we believe his lynchee to be non-town

[Aeronaut]

Some lynchers win the game if they lynch someone

[Aeronaut]

or give their team some sort of reward? idk

[Aeronaut]

that might make the most sense with this flavour, like a lyncher on a scum team giving that team some reward

[Gorkington]

ay reck.
would a traditional lyncher be considered bastard by your standards?

also, aero, i doubt reck would put in a gamestealing non-SK third party, especially not a lyncher that could win on d1 and basically ruin the entire game.

[RadiantCowbells]

Wait what? I'm confused about why you'd lynch RC over your

claimed guilty

Because RC might be lyncher. I need to think about this though, Uve been skeptical of RC scum.

My 'target' literally claimed scum. What are you saying?

[Aeronaut]

Yea, I'm saying the second one is more likely

Pedit @Cheetington

[Aeronaut]

Wait what? I'm confused about why you'd lynch RC over your

claimed guilty

Because RC might be lyncher. I need to think about this though, Uve been skeptical of RC scum.

My 'target' literally claimed scum. What are you saying?

well i don't know why that makes any difference whatsoever