Mini 500 - Cult Mafia - Game Over!

[Guardian]

Official Vote Count #25

tyhess[3](Flameaxe, Mastermind of Sin, Tarhalindur)
ac1983fan[1](theopor_COD)
theopor_COD[1](vollkan)
White[1](Oman)
Tarhalindur[1](tyhess)


Not Voting[5](curiouskarmadog, pwayne66, Trojan Horse, White, Kakeng)

[Oman]

Unvote Vote Flameaxe

You're doing little for the game, and my white vote is doing nothing where it is.

[Flameaxe]

My schedule apologizes to you Oman. My post was a fucking joke I posted at work right before I left.

I don't have a lot of time for this 're-read' as I have not been home very often. Maybe I take longer than you to read, deal with it.

[Oman]

Baited breath!

[Flameaxe]

To make this easier on me, and you for that matter, have anything in particular you would like me to really read in-depth and comment on in the last ~10 pages?

[Oman]

Probably why you feel tyhess is the most scummy when its been MoS, White, Pwayne, and Vollkan going at it. Do you think ANY of them are scum?

[vollkan]

To make this easier on me, and you for that matter, have anything in particular you would like me to really read in-depth and comment on in the last ~10 pages?

Don't you have ANY proactive interest in this game?

I mean, you should be looking through things yourself trying to hunt for scum. Rather than just be directed to things.

[Kakeng]

A very brief summary of what i seen from up to page six:

Theo comes under fire for voting for pwayne66 as he had protected blackstrike and seemingly changing his stance. He also unvoted under pressure. FoS: theo

Blackstrike either made some errors in judgement or is scummy, from his funny idea that lying town helps town.

Flameaxe seems to have a bandwagon.

Thats all I remember at the time of this post.

Any queries?

[Oman]

I wouldn't mind your opinions on said issues.

You're right on what happened, but beyond one FoS theres no other input.

Then again, its only pg 6

[Kakeng]

Here are pages 7 to 12:

acfan's first post(i skipped pages 1 to 3). He pops in and votes for tyhess, citing that his was acting scummy without citing examples. Lol. I did replace him, but this makes him look scummy. If i did not know better, I would have voted for him.

Tyhess talks quite a bit about cultist. He also seems to change his vote when the winds change, eg. very often, and usually at the bandwagoned. He is also very defensive. FoS Tyhess.

vollkan gives me a currently neutral read on him. He did defend MoS on page 10. I'm just noting this down to see if anything comes out of this.

MoS seems to only look at selected points about people and answer to them. Also, he does not jump on bandwagons.

Omen seems to be trying to find reasons to vote for Mos by using a logic such as not being on bandwagons is scummy. Either that, or he is grasping at straws to find something between Mos, flame and tyhess. Minor FoS

Blackstrike seems to have made bad leaps in logic in deciding that lynching townies is good, but I am being a broken tape recorder, so Minor FoS.

White replaces in. Nothing much about him.

So...any questions?

[Mastermind of Sin]

My meta was a small meta, nothing more. The people who did not ask for an extension are not scum because they didn't ask for an extension. They just are very slightly more likely to be scum. The fact that they later asked for it is a null tell. I'm not going to use that against them, it would be stupid.

@White: sorry about that, I must've missed where you asked.

[vollkan]

[quote="MoS]
My meta was a small meta, nothing more. The people who did not ask for an extension are not scum because they didn't ask for an extension. They just are very slightly more likely to be scum. The fact that they later asked for it is a null tell. I'm not going to use that against them, it would be stupid.
[/quote]

I can see why you would deem it a minor tell, but I am not going to count it as a scumtell at all. Firstly, it doesn't necessarily demonstrate anything about the player that didn't ask (as in, I can envisage a town player just not thinking to ask) and, secondly, scum can easily exploit this sort of thing if people allow it to take hold.

[Flameaxe]

To make this easier on me, and you for that matter, have anything in particular you would like me to really read in-depth and comment on in the last ~10 pages?

Don't you have ANY proactive interest in this game?

I mean, you should be looking through things yourself trying to hunt for scum. Rather than just be directed to things.

I never said I wasn't.

[curiouskarmadog]

you are not being proactive...you are being reactive...you said this.

To make this easier on me, and you for that matter, have anything in particular you would like me to really read in-depth and comment on in the last ~10 pages?

Vollkan (and I assume all of us) want you to go through the game on your and provide feedback, not just ask people to ask to find information.

[curiouskarmadog]

f-ing proofrreading...edit...

Vollkan (and I assume all of us) want you to go through the game on your own and provide feedback, not just ask people to ask you to find information.

[Flameaxe]

To make this easier on me, and you for that matter, have anything in particular you would like me to really read in-depth and comment on in the last ~10 pages?

Don't you have ANY proactive interest in this game?

I mean, you should be looking through things yourself trying to hunt for scum. Rather than just be directed to things.

I never said I wasn't.

Where did I say "I am only going to comment and read what people tell me to read"? Please, point this out for me, because I am clearly incapable of doing so.

[curiouskarmadog]

you are missing the point...you are not being proactive...you are being reactive, omg, look I am not going to have this silly conversation with you (more so than want I have already done)..

read through the game yourself and scum hunt, why are you asking other's to point you in a direction?

[vollkan]

Where did I say "I am only going to comment and read what people tell me to read"? Please, point this out for me, because I am clearly incapable of doing so.

You said:

I don't have a lot of time for this 're-read' as I have not been home very often. Maybe I take longer than you to read, deal with it.

and

To make this easier on me, and you for that matter, have anything in particular you would like me to really read in-depth and comment on in the last ~10 pages?

That looks to me like you are saying that you aren't going to do a re-read yourself and that you want to just be directed to things.

No, you did not explicitly say "I am not going to read things for myself. Please just point me to stuff", but it is implied nonetheless.

[curiouskarmadog]

want=what

promise I wont hit that "submit" button till I read my post over at least once

[Flameaxe]

you are missing the point...you are not being proactive...you are being reactive, omg, look I am not going to have this silly conversation with you (more so than want I have already done)..

read through the game yourself and scum hunt, why are you asking other's to point you in a direction?

Just so happens I've already finished my read, the WHOLE read.

(_|_)<= Kiss it.

[curiouskarmadog]

(blink blink)

ok...and?

[vollkan]

Just so happens I've already finished my read, the WHOLE read.

(_|_)<= Kiss it.

Oh dear, you've read the thread; whatever will we do....?

[theopor_COD]

My opinion of ac1983/replacement hasn't changed. I still think AC's post back yonder and subsequent dissapearance is the biggest scum beacon out there, his replacement seems to be working through giving everyone a minor fos but I don't really see the same zest as when say White replaced in or compare it to Tar's introduction. Tar came in straight away slung a vote on . . . which to me indicates he's not bothered about attraction. Kakeng seems overly cautious mind maybe I should let him finish his read-through.

Trojan Horse is another guy who's slowly pricking my senses, reading his posts a lot of them seem to be fence sitting, he'll vote someone and then unvote. No real hardcore feelings almost as if he's in the know and is happy to play along with whatever's going down.

[Guardian]

5) Have fun & respect each other (and me) .

I only have five rules for this game. Be sure you've read all of them .

[curiouskarmadog]

5) Have fun & respect each other (and me) .

I only have five rules for this game. Be sure you've read all of them .

it could be a possiblity that flameaxe felt his butt was a prize that only a select few my lay there lips on..thus is has paid me a great compliment.

if not, he is an ass hat.