I'm not trying to lynch you, I'm having a conversation with you. I'm not even voting you. I haven't made a case against you. All I posted was a tiny worry that you might be setting me up for something and you went ballistic because...I expressed town paranoia. ok.
It's not about "because they might be wrong later". It's about "if I say
hey, Phantom, if you write all your posts in green I will townread you but if you write them in red then I will scumread you
and then Phantom starts posting in green, how do I know that he's posting in green because he's town and not because I told him I would give him a cookie if he did it?
It's not that I
can't
substantiate my read on Phantom, it's that I don't want to. If he's wagonned and my read on him strengthens to a point that I care about derailing the wagon then I'll do so in a compelling manner.
I have an early read on him. It's either right or it's not. If it's not, the less I say about why I'm reading him, the soooner I'll realise it and course correct. If it is right, the less I say about it, the stronger it will become and then I'll reach a point of certainty and explain what i'm doing to the rest of the class. Why are you so impatient? Why do you care?
In post 137, Mad King Ashnard wrote:
Are you reading the thread? I literally just answered that when Wisdom asked me, in 82. Then in 85, I said that I was willing to vote Talah but I was tempted to votepark sakura until she changed her avatar. She said she wasn't going to and I don't have a read on sakura yet so I switched to Talah.
WHY.
WHY.
WHY.
WHY.
WHY.
WHY.
WHY.
IF YOU CLICK THE LINKS YOU WILL FIND THE ANSWER BECAUSE I EXPLAINED IT. Read post
82.
PEDIT AND IN THAT QUOTE THAT YOU ARE QUOTING I WAS CLEARLY TALKING ABOUT IN THAT GAME BASED ON THE THREAD TEMPERATURE IN THAT GAME.
why would the thread temperature of that game carry over to this one?
I never said that it's a thread temperature thing at all.
Please continue to insert words into my mouth about my stances on things.
That's right, you specifically ignored that I was talking about the thread temperature in that game and quoted it as if I were saying I had a vendetta against you that I would use in future games.
Also, there WERE a few people spouting scumreads on me when you started; namely Antihero and PC (although I'm not sure PC legit scumread me or was just voting)
I'm not even voting you. I am reasonably confident that if your slot is town I will be able to townread your hydra partner eventually. You seem to think that means that I'm going to lynch you after I talk to him, in spite of my having experience with him.
pedit: RC, you asked me about the talah vote, not the sakura vote. and i explained the talah vote and you keep saying i didn't.
In post 82, Scatterplot wrote:mostly sheeping hiplop. I felt it was weird the way that talah acknowledges that wisdom is probably reaction testing sakura but then needs an explanation RIGHT NOW before sakura even has time to respond to wisdom's vote. If he thought the rvs naked vote was for reactions, which is a reasonable assumption, and he thought the purpose was to get reactions from sakura, then why was he getting in the way of that?
i have dinner on the stove.
--P
So my problem with talah is that talah got in the way of sakura and wisdom. and my problem with you is that you're getting in the way of me and phantom by being impatient and demanding answers NOW NOW NOW when I will explain my reads when i'm ready. I'm not going to lynch anybody based on unexplained reads, I'm not going to derail a wagon with unexplained reads, but i'm not going to explain reads that are still in progress.
KT I don't understand it either why RC is bringing last game into this especially when I barely remember Miller's Hollow because of how sick I was for the entire duration of the game. It had a 90 page day 1 and I was too sick to read the thread and then I died on night 1 and that was game over town wins because the setup was 2:11 and all I felt when it was over was relieved that I didn't have to catch up on it after all. I'm not salty about that game at all. Good riddance to it.
pedit: actually yeah can we just drop this and not clog up the thread and come back to each other if we need to later on because there are other slots in this game too.
pedit: if this post doesn't clear it up then I don't know what to tell you.
--P