In post 846, Rylai and Lina wrote: this is kind of trying to make a false dilemma which I will note as really scummy weird comments.
No, it's not a false dilemma. It's a real dilemma. We are going to lynch someone today.
I mean, this is like the most basic mafia theory there is. In any game of mafia, if you are under attack and you don't want to be lynched today, either you have to convince the town that you're not as scummy as the town thinks you are, or else you have to convince the town that someone else is scummier then you are. Those are really the only two options.
There was a great quote MeMe said about this way back in like 2003 or something but I can't find it now.
So, tell me; how is "we are going to lynch someone today; if you don't want it to be you, then lay out a case for who you think it should be" scummy or weird?
3 - That role thing is only 1 part of the case you read my that case at all!?
I've read all of your posts, but like I said, you kind of jump all over the place and it's hard to follow you. Especially since you voted Fulm, and then unvoted him, and then re-voted him based on his role, I was assuming that his role is the only thing you're currently suspecting him for.
But ok. If you think Fulm is scum, then could you lay out your whole case against him clearly in one place? A TL:Dr version with just some bullet points is fine, or you could post it longer, or you could post more of your hydra chat. However you want to do it.
and yeah for one second think yourself why should town have such a role?! its so damn weird ...
This is my understanding:
-On adventures, the party may find items
-It sounds like certain kinds of items can only be used by certain people.
-It sounds like Fulm has a role that can, specifically, use hammers to gain abilities. Other people may have roles that can use other types of items.
-From what Fulm was saying, it sounds like even if he doesn't go on an adventure, people can still give items to him. So I guess after an adventure the people who went on the advanture can give items away if they choose to, presumably in order to give certain items to people who can use them.
I don't see how that makes Fulm scum. If anything, it's plausible that both scum and town have roles like that in this game.
I want us to win just for Yos' inevitable rant alone. -CrashTextDummie