433: Dry, bland, generic mafia: Game Over

[Pie_is_good]

=(

I tried, SSF, I tried

The preceding statement is not applicable if I am, in fact, wrong.

[Pie_is_good]

The preceding post is not applicable because I am, in fact, never wrong.

[creampuffeater]

rwar!!!! Yes, Pie is never wrong.

[somestrangeflea]

Bah!

Go

TOWN

!
Have fun...

[Off the Mark]

Told ya. Our hope lies in the hands of the SK.

[Off the Mark]

SK please take out Gorckat - you can't be left alone with scum if you hope to win.

[gorckat]

Not "pete or gorckat"? I thought he was scum, too, given the way he and I were following each other?

[Off the Mark]

Hell I don't care. Gorck, Pete, Dasq, take your pick. I just think you've acted scummy most frequently, so you're the easiest choice.

[gorckat]

Isn't Dasq the smart one you want to keep alive in case he's town?

[Dasquian]

Of course, there's no chance that if ssf is mafia, he's still lying, is there? [/sarcasm] Anyway, not much to say now that isn't just a "I hope we got it right" truism. We get to find out soon enough anyway

[Off the Mark]

Isn't Dasq the smart one you want to keep alive in case he's town?

You sound like you're mocking me. Stop.

[Off the Mark]

Of course, there's no chance that if ssf is mafia, he's still lying, is there? [/sarcasm]

Doubtful. With a hidden text box? No motivation there.

So Gorck, how do you feel about ssf most likely being a townie after all? Your analysis of how you see things NOW should be entertaining, at the very least.

[gorckat]

Isn't Dasq the smart one you want to keep alive in case he's town?

You sound like you're mocking me. Stop.

Hardly mocking. Pointing out more hypocrisy.

You're the one that said Dasq should be kept around in case he's town. IIRC, you'd go after him if I and/or pete were scum. Now you're offering him up to the SK.

So Gorck, how do you feel about ssf most likely being a townie after all? Your analysis of how you see things NOW should be entertaining, at the very least.

How I see things depends on who goes down tonight. If I was way off on my groups, then it'll probably show in the morning's body count. Your reversal and phantom connection between me and pete still has you looking good in my eyes.

[Off the Mark]

So you're saying that despite my reversal on SSF, if he shows up town, you STILL think I am "looking good" as scum? Unbelievable.

[Off the Mark]

Hardly mocking. Pointing out more hypocrisy.

You're the one that said Dasq should be kept around in case he's town. IIRC, you'd go after him if I and/or pete were scum. Now you're offering him up to the SK.

I said that pages ago, and it was never something I was adamant about, it was just a "I prefer Gorckat or Pete over Dasq because of ..." type comment. You are misrepresenting me by saying I "wanted to keep Dasq around." That is BS. I am now more confident than I was then that Dasq is scum, after some of our more recent interactions.

So Mr. SK, I don't care who you kill, as long as it's one of those 3.

The very fact that Gorckat continues to go after me, EVEN IF SSF IS TOWN, is horribly condemning. Any reasonable townie would have me very low on their suspicion list given what happened Day 2, assuming SSF is town.

[gorckat]

Maybe. I have no idea how flea's and any dead people's roles will skew me.

[Off the Mark]

That's not what I asked you. Assuming ssf is town, how would that affect your suspicions? Answer the question.

[gorckat]

Looks like I closed my browser before I submitted my answer yesterday.

I admit I could be wrong. I have not previously because there is no connection between me and pete or Dasq. It is

far

easier for me to see you as scum given your insistence that there is.

I truly believed flea was scum (assuming he's not, since we still don't have the role reveal). I truly believed you were bussing string and only backed off because flea contributed a little bit.

If you two are both town, does that make me an idiot? Perhaps. Scum? Nope.

[Off the Mark]

You're still not answering my question. That's OK, I didn't expect you to. Here's the question, rephrased one more time:

If ssf does indeed come up town (which he will) WHO DO YOU THINK IS SCUM?

[gorckat]

Depends on who dies.

Are you asking so you can kill them and lynch me tomorrow?

[Off the Mark]

Good grief! How hard is it to answer the fricking question!!! Surely you will have some thoughts in your head after ssf's role reveal and before the morning scene. I'll ask it again:

After SSF comes up town, who will you suspect? If you MUST have a morning scene before you can begin thinking, then pretend no one dies overnight.

[Off the Mark]

The reason I'm asking is obvious. I think your answers are revealing YOU as scum, hopefully giving the SK more reason to kill you tonight. Your repeated avoidance of the question is already speaking volumes.

[gorckat]

And why, exactly, would no one die? It's completely irrational to assume no one is going to die when 3 people died last night. Speculation like that is worse than none, imho.

You continuing to ask the SK to kill me hurts the town and helps the scum. Assuming you've convinced the SK to kill me, the scum can go off and kill someone else and, presumably, win on the spot.

[Off the Mark]

OK that's FIVE times you have refused to answer the question. I'm done trying to squeeze milk out of this turnip. Hopefully it is as obvious to the SK as it is to me that you are scum at this point.

[Dasquian]

This is pretty retarded. No doubt I'm providing yet more ammo for OTM to convince himself that I'm gorckat's scum-partner, but...

What the hell? If gorckat is a townie, then when ssf's alignment is revealed he'll either go "yay" or "doh", and readjust his suspicions. Then he'll readjust them again when more stiffs show up at daybreak, and

then

and only then will he have a chance to talk about what he's thinking, if he's even still alive. Same as the rest of us.

Talking about what you might be thinking overnight before the other deaths are revealed only help the mafia/SK understand what members of the town are thinking, and hence how to best target their kills for maximum manipulation the following day. I see that you are trying to get gorckat to slip up and say something suspicious, but, goddamn, save it for tomorrow. You're like the world's angriest small-yappy-type dog; you never stop barking.

Roll on day 3; even twilights drag in this game