Open 39: Crush Nightless - Game Over! before 484

[Sammich]

Well, here are my read notes:
JDodge: I think he's lyncher now. Hasn't done much but yell at people and broadcast suspicions without explanations. Could be teamscum with d3sisted, considering the bandwagon they pressed on me right now.

d3sisted: Seems actually townish now. Maybe teamscum with JDodge. Also, how the hell do you OMGUS on someone else's behalf? Could actually be my lyncher, seeing the late push for a lynch on me.

Guardian: Seems the towniest of all right now. I'm a little confused on the "I think a Jdodge lynch today would be great."

Kerplunk: Meh. Sorta in the grey area. I don't see why he put the "over defensive" tag on JDodge. Overdefensiveness doesn't really register as a scumtell to me, no matter how jerky JDodge acts and how deep down I want to write his death scene in this game. >_>;

Crub: Can we get a prod on him please?

[d3sisted]

Meh.
Kerplunk's lifted his vote on me.
I wasn't nervous of Kerplunk's vote at all.
Personally I got worried when you and JDodge began bandwagoning against me on an easy case.
You also forgot about my vote of JDodge before the no lynch vote.

Post 136: Vote nolynch.
Post 143: OMGUS vote JDodge.

Thanks for proving my point.

Well, here are my read notes:
JDodge: I think he's lyncher now. Hasn't done much but yell at people and broadcast suspicions without explanations. Could be teamscum with d3sisted, considering the bandwagon they pressed on me right now.

d3sisted: Seems actually townish now. Maybe teamscum with JDodge. Also, how the hell do you OMGUS on someone else's behalf? Could actually be my lyncher, seeing the late push for a lynch on me.

Guardian: Seems the towniest of all right now. I'm a little confused on the "I think a Jdodge lynch today would be great."

Kerplunk: Meh. Sorta in the grey area. I don't see why he put the "over defensive" tag on JDodge. Overdefensiveness doesn't really register as a scumtell to me, no matter how jerky JDodge acts and how deep down I want to write his death scene in this game. >_>;

Crub: Can we get a prod on him please?

Show me where JDodge bandwagoned you, please. And as far as yelling at people and broadcasting suspicions goes, you're the only one he's yelled at (deservedly too), and he looks pretty adamant in his Kerplunk/d3sisted theory.

I don't get what you're saying about me being townie, but in a scumteam with JDodge. And let's get this straight now before anyone else decides to misoncstrue, the OMGUS on JDodge's behalf was a joke, I have my own reasons for voting Sammich, as I outlined in previous posts.

Again, you say JDodge is teamscum with me and you want to write his deathscene, yet you're confused when Guardian wants him lynched?

[Sammich]

Again, you say JDodge is teamscum with me and you want to write his deathscene, yet you're confused when Guardian wants him lynched?

Yes.

[JDodge]

Mod

: PROD CRUB PLEASE

LURKERCRUB = BAD

[Crub]

I'm here I'm just wondering why we haven't lynched the lyncher yet?

[JDodge]

Then why are you voting for Kerplunk?

[Crub]

Because he's the lyncher.

[JDodge]

Because he's the lyncher.

Of whom, might I ask?

[Crub]

Because he's the lyncher.

Of whom, might I ask?

Schis/Sammich

[Guardian]

Again, you say JDodge is teamscum with me and you want to write his deathscene, yet you're confused when Guardian wants him lynched?

Yes.

Why?


I can see Kerplunk-scum, though not Kerplunk lyncher...

I don't like how he unvoted Jdodge, frankly. Jdodge needs 2 more votes.

[Sammich]

Why?

Meh.

I am not OK with you having only one primary suspicion -- only one player whose alignment you have put significant thought into.

What's wrong with JDodge only having one suspicion?
I mean, yeah, I hate that it's me, but if he supremely believes I'm scum and has it out for me, then let him run on it.
This may be me just because I did cause both d3sisted and JDodge suspicious of me, but hey, what can you do?

[Guardian]

Why?

Meh.

That really isn't good enough. What is wrong with me advocating JDodge's lynch?

I am not OK with you having only one primary suspicion -- only one player whose alignment you have put significant thought into.

What's wrong with JDodge only having one suspicion?

There are 3 scum in this 6 player game. Having only 1 suspect amidst 5 players of whom 3 are anti-town makes little sense to me, and is indicative of a scum perspective. That combined with Jdodge's strong desire to find the lyncher and not to find scum makes him look quite suspicious to me.

[JDodge]

Why?

Meh.

That really isn't good enough. What is wrong with me advocating JDodge's lynch?

Obviously he's a lyncher looking for the scum. Or scum looking for the lyncher.

[Sammich]

There are 3 scum in this 6 player game. Having only 1 suspect amidst 5 players of whom 3 are anti-town makes little sense to me, and is indicative of a scum perspective. That combined with Jdodge's strong desire to find the lyncher and not to find scum makes him look quite suspicious to me.

I know that tunnel vision sucks.
But since lyncher lynching target= Instant Lose for everyone else, I could see why anyone-scum or not- would want to find it as priority number one.
That's the reason why JDodge and I have pretty much gone tit-for-tat in this whole game. Or just me, if he doesn't agree with my reasoning.

Post 143: OMGUS vote JDodge.

Meanwhile, on this case I never labeled the vote as OMGUS.

[Guardian]

Why?

Meh.

That really isn't good enough. What is wrong with me advocating JDodge's lynch?

respond.

[d3sisted]

There are 3 scum in this 6 player game. Having only 1 suspect amidst 5 players of whom 3 are anti-town makes little sense to me, and is indicative of a scum perspective. That combined with Jdodge's strong desire to find the lyncher and not to find scum makes him look quite suspicious to me.

I know that tunnel vision sucks.
But since lyncher lynching target= Instant Lose for everyone else, I could see why anyone-scum or not- would want to find it as priority number one.
That's the reason why JDodge and I have pretty much gone tit-for-tat in this whole game. Or just me, if he doesn't agree with my reasoning.

Post 143: OMGUS vote JDodge.

Meanwhile, on this case I never labeled the vote as OMGUS.

OMGUS is not necessarily voluntary.

[Sammich]

Why?

Meh.

That really isn't good enough. What is wrong with me advocating JDodge's lynch?

respond.

Nothing.
I just don't get the basis of voting on that, but whatever.

OMGUS is not necessarily voluntary.

Oh well. I didn't vote it as OMGUS, but if you find it that way, fine.

[Kerplunk]

I am sorry, I have no clue anymore. If I ever had any.

I am paranoid about Guardian. But I would like to see a vote count for I am lazy.

[Crub]

Unofficial Vote Count :
Kerplunk (2) : JDodge, Crub
JDodge (2) : Sammich, Guardian
Sammich (1) : d3sisted
Not Voting (1) : kerplunk
4 to lynch

My thoughts ...
Kerplunk = Lyncher
Sammich = Lynchee
Scum 2 out of these 3 in order of likeliness:
JDodge,Guardian,d3sisted

[Guardian]

I can def see Kerplunk lyncher Jdodge d3sisted scum; I think Crub might be among the scum, but other than that his analysis seems pretty on.

Crub -- do you think Kerplunk is likely to be scum? Why or why not?

[Zindaras]

Vote Count

JDodge

- 2 (Sammich, Guardian)

Kerplunk

- 2 (JDodge, Crub)

Sammich

- 1 (d3sisted)

Not Voting

- 1 (Kerplunk)

6 alive, 4 to lynch.

[Sammich]

My thoughts ...
Kerplunk = Lyncher
Sammich = Lynchee
Scum 2 out of these 3 in order of likeliness:
JDodge,Guardian,d3sisted

I don't see Kerplunk exactly as my lynchee...
I could see maybe d3sisted or JDodge, but not really Kerplunk. Even though his "I have no clue who's scum and who's not" claim is getting tiring, because it's basically replaying the whole point of the game.
I think Guardian is a legitimate town in relations to Kerplunk being paranoid about him.
All in all I don't think Kerplunk being lyncher being for real.

I don't like how he unvoted Jdodge, frankly. Jdodge needs 2 more votes.

Though Kerplunk seems weird in unvoting JDodge and then saying he doesn't know who scum is. If you put a vote on someone, you really should think they are scum/lyncher/other evil entity, I think.

[d3sisted]

Back, kinda disappointed to see so little go on in 3 days. Keeping my vote on Sammich b/c me thinks he is scum.

I am sorry, I have no clue anymore. If I ever had any.

I am paranoid about Guardian. But I would like to see a vote count for I am lazy.

FOS Kerplunk

Seems to me like you just want us to think you have no target, something I can see a lyncher doing.

[Sammich]

Back, kinda disappointed to see so little go on in 3 days. Keeping my vote on Sammich b/c me thinks he is scum.

I'd award you the "94950595904954390530th person to think I'm scum" award, but oh well.

[d3sisted]

Back, kinda disappointed to see so little go on in 3 days. Keeping my vote on Sammich b/c me thinks he is scum.

I'd award you the "94950595904954390530th person to think I'm scum" award, but oh well.

... Ok ...
So what exactly are you trying to achieve?