Mini Normal 1719 - Flavorless Fun! [Game Over!]

[Aj The Epic]

This was answered yesterday. If you aren't going to read my short iso, I'm not going to reiterate.

[Keyser Söze]

Because I'm unaware of 41 other pages? I don't know, common sense dictates what I read on page eight may not be the current game state on day 3.

'Common sense' dictates you at least acknowledge the VC?
It may be unfair to talk retrospectively - but your read on Meanmelter was the #1 priority.

[Dwlee99]

Read 1135 and 1138 keyse

[Keyser Söze]

Read 1135 and 1138 keyse

Ok, going to look at the Meanmelter wagon later.

[Dwlee99]

The only experience I have with VCA was jn Justified Season 2 mini where titus replaced in and by using VCA confirmed my scum buddy as town which led to a town loss. Do they work most of the time?

[A Simple Plan]

Vote Count 4.3

[1]

Garmr - mykonian [L-3]

Not Voting -

Dierfire, Dwlee99, AJ The Epic, Keyser Söze, herrcombs, Garmr

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline - (expired on 2015-11-21 21:00:00)

[Garmr]

OK with 7 people alive if I take out me and the mason I have 40% chance of lynching scum today now if I factor my reads that will either rise or drop

[Dwlee99]

And why does that matter?

[Garmr]

I'm trying to figure the best move

[Dierfire]

I wonder why Keyser doesn't find me suspicious.

[Dierfire]

VOTE: AJ

Suddenly, now, he's responding to things in real time before finishing reading the rest of the thread?

[herrcombs]

I am waiting with bated breath for AJ to finish his reread and actually answer the question why he kept his vote on meanmelter when he replaced in, despite not having seen anything scummy from him or even knowing who he was.

And before you ask, or tell me all snippy-like to read your iso, no I do not think that 1243 was in any way a sufficient response to my questions.

Happy cakeday, though!

[mykonian]

I wonder why Keyser doesn't find me suspicious.

you are not alone in this.

[Dwlee99]

I agree that Ajs mean vote was really odd. I dont see why they would just vote for the popular wagon.

[mykonian]

shurg, it was an ok wagon. Mean could have been scum imo, we misread him.

I do not understand the continious reluctance to lynch garmr.

[Dierfire]

I do not understand the continious reluctance to lynch garmr.

Lalendra flipped Town, so we assume that she wasn't lying when she said that she attempted to protect BBT. The Mafia either had a way to stop her action or a way to overpower her protection. The former makes little sense in a design that only has one Town role with an activated ability; the latter makes more sense in a design that has a Town BP than it does in one that does not have a Town BP.

[mykonian]

So you are betting your whole game not on reads you could have formed over the course of days, but on a role "theory" which is much less of a theory and more of a gamble that scum do not have a roleblocker.

Sure, we can lynch you as well, if garmr really is that difficult.

Actually. Why not follow that with a vote. You've been in my blindspot for ages.

vote dier

[Dierfire]

1. Do you disagree with the theory?

2. I was reading Garmr as Town well before Lalendra or BBT flipped. Were you under the impression that the only basis for this was his claimed role?

[Dwlee99]

Not to mention you can't roleblock a mason. That vote is so awful, myko.
VOTE: Myko

[Aj The Epic]

I agree that Ajs mean vote was really odd. I dont see why they would just vote for the popular wagon.

I didn't vote. I'll finish catching up here by the end of this week, but I don't have time for a lot of reading right now.

[mykonian]

Not to mention you can't roleblock a mason. That vote is so awful, myko.
VOTE: Myko

that one is worse.

give me a reason why dier is town?

[Garmr]

Not to mention you can't roleblock a mason. That vote is so awful, myko.
VOTE: Myko

that one is worse.

give me a reason why dier is town?

What's a reason that deir might be scum? This is the first time in the whole game you voted someone that's not me before the rush at the end of day.

[Garmr]

I'm not including rvs

[mykonian]

What's a reason that deir might be scum?

it's small things all the time, but mostly he's one of the guys I can't figure out a clear reason for any read. I can tell soze is town, dwlee, there's a way to tell hier's allignment though I've been unable to do so. Herr's probably town but either way has made clear statements. I know nothing about dier. Haven't all game. He's "meh", from start to finish.

So he's been solidly in my blind spot and lets be fair, scum often sit there.


And that argument, as said there, it's just silly. You don't throw away 50 pages of reads to argue about what the setup might be. That's beyond outguessing the mod and into discussion theory without having to argue people. So the post is scummy, I don't know about dier otherwise, it's as good a vote as any.

[Dwlee99]

So PoE, myko?