I kind of agreed with you on first glance but after some introspection I decided that Mala-scum wouldn't play in such an easy to jump on way, if that makes any sense. She'd be trying to fit in better IMO.
In post 224, Malakittens wrote:Molla's probably town along with FB and Spiffeh is likely scum but then again that's pretty transparent eh?
Spiffeh?
In post 226, Firebringer wrote: In post 224, Malakittens wrote:Molla's probably town along with FB and Spiffeh is likely scum but then again that's pretty transparent eh?
Wait how is spiffeh scum?
I would like to hear this.
Ninja'd
Can you point out where you got gut pings?
In post 230, Kid A wrote:Have you changed your mind about this? Seems like yiu have two people in your scumpool but voted neither.
My scumpool doesn't have either an FB or a Nosferatu in it anymore. FB primarily because I went and reread the thread and taking into account Molla's point about SC2 players not taking RVS seriously and the fact he's been pretty fucking town since. Nosferatu's posting got a lot better too.
Wagons tend to do that when the person being wagoned starts obvtowning.
In post 232, talah wrote:Given that I don't like the ABR / ika options and Firebringer might be town given the main drivers are no longer voting him, I'm happy with this in principle and for a couple of other reasons.
VOTE: Syryana
...so you vote one of the drivers? Also is there any particular reason you have to be on a wagon? This also seems like rather a lot of justification for voting me.
In post 232, talah wrote:---
@Syr
Why did you unvote FB when he was at L-2? There was no risk there as long as nobody else voted him. Your unvote was pointless imo.
He was technically at L-1 when I unvoted, primarily because Ika is a lolhammer.
Also because there was no danger in unvoting him. Is my "pointless unvote" why you're scumreading me?
In post 232, talah wrote:@Molla
While I appreciate your abrasiveness and it comes across as scumhunting, I'm a bit concerned that you've come to independent sorta-conculsions that both FB and Nosferatu are town after having proposed them as scum/scum (
83), then scum/sk (
146) and now town/town (
183)?
It has a feeling of knowing that both are town and having trouble suspending your own disbelief and remaining convincing when confronted directly by your targets.
Also you're happy with ika, Ranger and Kid A now, who seem like pretty easy targets? I'm at least leaning town on ika.
In post 197, BBmolla wrote:UNVOTE:
VOTE: ABR
Elaborate on Syr scumread tho, make me see it.
In post 208, BBmolla wrote:ABR and me never tend to see things eye to eye, but I don't think it's indicative of alignment for him, we just read things different.
How is this a train of thought when you're saying ABR seems scummy and then stating something you know about him tending to not see eye to eye with you meta-wise? And you also claim to not be reaction testing?
I'm having a lot of trouble following your play here.
You leave my mason buddy the fuck alone.
In post 232, talah wrote:@Mala
Please explain, I'm not seeing it.
Your vote seems kind of useless just sitting there on gut.
Goign back to your response to me about voting off the FB wagon, how do you expect to get information from Day 1 if there aren't significant wagons to look back at later? Personal preferences aside, this is a different format from what most of us are used to and there's not a lot of time to chill and do nothing.
We need to be deciding on a lynch right now don't you think?
This part makes me squint really really fucking hard. You seem a lot more interested in being on a lynch wagon than you do in actually finding scum.
In post 239, Ranger wrote:Syryana wrote:Totes down for an Ika lynch
Why? I actually really liked the natural feeling of his posting.
Because I don't know Ika well enough to know whether his posting is alignment indicative, but I know him more than well enough to policy lynch the fuck out of him given an opportunity.
In post 252, talah wrote: In post 249, Ranger wrote:talah wrote:So... you had no reasons of your own?
Nice misrep.
I said Syryana said it better than I could. Not that I didn't have reasons of my own.
Syryana just stole every possible reason I could have listed before I could post any of my own. My early posting should have made it quite clear I saw the same things he did. If you'd like, I could go through the posting and do my own wording, but it will end up just being an inferior rehash of what Syryana so thoroughly did the first time.
Generally town are able to just reference their memory and state what they were thinking.
At the time you had wagoned FB because wagons (ok good, fine), and then stated that you were now scumreading FB.
I want to know what you were thinking at that time and I don't really care what Syryana said because obviously he went into some detail, and you didn't.
So again - you had no reason of your own to scumread Firebringer?
If that question's too hard for you, how are you reading Firebringer now?
Line 1 is total bullshit.
Line 2 is pointless.
Line 3 he's answered already. Also if you don't buy that he has no reason outside of what I already posted, why are you voting me instead of him since according to you detail is a good thing?
Line 4: Let me spell it out for you. H-E W-A-S H-I-V-E-M-I-N-D-I-N-G W-I-T-H M-E A-N-D M-O-L-L-A.
In post 264, Huntress wrote:@ Syryana:
Thanks for the elaboration in
106. The problem I have with it though is that it seems to me you are taking each of Firebringer's posts and finding a reason for it to be scummy, which is scummy in itself.
I have a question for you: Do you think Nosferatu misunderstood what Firebringer meant about a possible scum on the wagon in his reply to Spiffeh (
61)?
Vote: Syryana
No I'm not. Where am I doing this?
Re Nos: I don't think so, and I have no idea what the point of that question is.
In post 267, Nosferatu wrote: In post 266, Huntress wrote: In post 146, BBmolla wrote:I want you to be scum, I'm gonna ride this out for now but I'll switch to Nos if it happens. Maybe he's SK and you're Mafia.
Why might Nos be SK rather than town, or mafia to Fb town? Or even in different scumgroups come to that? To say SK seems oddly specific.
I'm 99.98% sure that he just thought we both weren't town but we couldn't be on the same scumteam. Since, I don't know, he literally said we couldn't be on the same team in his next post.
UNVOTE: Malakittens
VOTE: Huntress
I love you; I don't love your vote.
Pedit: Agreed, Mala
