Open 28 - Quack Mafia. OVER! But who won? before 466

[Hjallti]

Hjallti's last post was 7 days ago....

you are right to send a prod. I just got it. Will be back on monday 3th for more play.

[d3sisted]

Nice job, tar and jordan. Thanks for the input.

If you're not committed enough to at least pretend like you're part of the game, why don't you just ask for replacements. Seriously.

Don't confuse a lack of content with a lack of interest.

Err yeah. First line was sarcasm.

[JDodge]

Nice job, tar and jordan. Thanks for the input.

If you're not committed enough to at least pretend like you're part of the game, why don't you just ask for replacements. Seriously.

Don't confuse a lack of content with a lack of interest.

Err yeah. First line was sarcasm.

And I was addressing the second one.

[Aimee]

I'm back now. Sorting things out as we speak.

[Aimee]

Vote Count

d3sisted - 4 (JordanA24, Stewie, curiouskarmadog, Roach)
curiouskarmadog - 2 (scmp, Tarhalindur)
Battle Mage - 1 (~N9V~)
Tarhalindur – 1 (JDodge)

Not Voting - 2 (Mert, Hjallti, d3sisted)

With 11 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

I'm talking with Thesp about prods and things. Hopefully people will respond to their prods, or I can start searching for replacements tomorrow.

[curiouskarmadog]

welcome back, thanks Thesp for your help!

[Aimee]

Honary Hitchhiker replaces scmp.

[d3sisted]

Welcome HH, and welcome back, Aimee. My name doesn't seem to be in that vote count there.

Mod Note: Oops

[Aimee]

Mert hasn't picked up his prod that Thesp sent him. I am now searching for a replacement.

[Aimee]

And quickly, somestrangeflea replaces Mert!

[somestrangeflea]

Reading the thread...

...

..?

[curiouskarmadog]

Vote Count

d3sisted - 4 (JordanA24, Stewie, curiouskarmadog, Roach)
curiouskarmadog - 2 (scmp, Tarhalindur)
Battle Mage - 1 (~N9V~)
Tarhalindur – 1 (JDodge)

Not Voting - 2 (Mert, Hjallti, d3sisted)

With 11 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

I'm talking with Thesp about prods and things. Hopefully people will respond to their prods, or I can start searching for replacements tomorrow.

any word on scmp and N9V?

[Aimee]

any word on scmp and N9V?

HonaryHitchhiker has replaced scmp. N9V has been given 48 hours to respond in thread, or he will be replaced.

[curiouskarmadog]

any word on scmp and N9V?

HonaryHitchhiker has replaced scmp. N9V has been given 48 hours to respond in thread, or he will be replaced.

sorry you did post that...with all of the new replacements..got confused.

[Honary Hitchhiker]

Let me do a re-read and I'll get back to everyone on thoughts.

[curiouskarmadog]

Let me do a re-read and I'll get back to everyone on thoughts.

thanks for joining.

[Tarhalindur]

I still think that the ckd lynch is optimal.

I need to think things over and decide whether a Quack is a good or bad thing for the town.

[curiouskarmadog]

I still think that the ckd lynch is optimal.

I need to think things over and decide whether a Quack is a good or bad thing for the town.

post confuses me...what are you thinking over?

[Tarhalindur]

I still think that the ckd lynch is optimal.

I need to think things over and decide whether a Quack is a good or bad thing for the town.

post confuses me...what are you thinking over?

I'm thinking over whether d3sisted is an acceptable lynch or a terrible lynch. (D3sisted replaced Dral, who we know is either Quack or Mafia.)

[somestrangeflea]

Pages 1-6

Post 17 - Dral self votes, under the impression that a Quack is an inherently Anti-Town role. Why he thinks this, I'm not too sure. The only logicial explanation I can see is that he thought Doctors must make a choice each night, which seems fair enough...

Post 42 - Hjalti votes BM, because he doesn't buy that BM didn't know Quacks can't kill Mafia. To me, this seems like an easy mistake to make...

Post 73 - CKD votes Indy. It is, essentially, a lurkervote, but more deserved, since Indy's post (#72) seemed to say "Don't mind me, I'm confused. Kthxbye".

Post 101 & 102 - JDodge and BM express suspicion on theopor's post 100. TBH, I think 100 isn't particularly scummy, just misinformed.

Currently, I'm not seeing too much which is particularly scummy. There have been many mistakes regarding the setup though, which have hindered the Town's progress quite a bit.

Status of Protection Claims:
CKD -> No-one
Dral -> FeRnAnDo
BM, JDodge, Jordan -> Mert
Amelia -> JDodge
Theopor -> Jordan
Me, Indy -> CKD

What this means: Dral, if not scum, is a Quack.

Apologies for the delay. Settling into school has kept me somewhat busy, which really sucks when we're deadlined, but c'est la vie...

[Hjallti]

I'm thinking over whether d3sisted is an acceptable lynch or a terrible lynch. (D3sisted replaced Dral, who we know is either Quack or Mafia.)

Hard choice. If he is scum it is a good lynch. If he is quack killing him would give us one less chance of getting nightkill by a quack, but that is also the case if D3sisted just doesn't protect.

[Honary Hitchhiker]

First of all:

Unvote:CKD

(I don't know what's up with my predecessors vote "because he is curious" lol)

Second of all

Vote:D3sisted

for his case against CKD on how it showed many flaws and was supported on one beam (Which was the whole not protecting N0 and so forth on the protecting at night matter) Whether or not he is Quack or Scum is uncertain(since Dral claimed on protecting Fernado this could be a ploy however)

I found Mert actually Protown in my eyes because he was determined and supported theorys with alot of proof and evidence. Battle Mage and Indy I found quite scummy for their irrelevant contribution to the discussion. I'm not sure of Amelia Li(replaced by ~N9V~) since she hasn't posted much but she seems to have the doctor role. JDodge pushing agaisnt the Indy case nonstop pesters me as he dosen't share any other thoughts . Jordan looks pretty protown in my eyes as well. I find KCD overly defensive with the D3sisted attacks but seems protown as well since he has contributed alot to the discussion. Stewie and Hjallti seem pretty neatural in my eyes alot I don't have alot to go on.

[Aimee]

Vote Count

d3sisted - 5 (JordanA24, Stewie, curiouskarmadog, Roach, HonaryHitchhiker)
curiouskarmadog - 2 (scmp, Tarhalindur)
Battle Mage - 1 (~N9V~)
Tarhalindur – 1 (JDodge)

Not Voting - 2 (Mert, Hjallti, d3sisted)

With 11 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

Now getting a replacement for N9V.

[curiouskarmadog]

Vote Count

d3sisted - 5 (JordanA24, Stewie, curiouskarmadog, Roach, HonaryHitchhiker)
curiouskarmadog - 1 (Tarhalindur)
Battle Mage - 1 (~N9V~)
Tarhalindur – 1 (JDodge)

Not Voting - 2 (Mert, Hjallti, d3sisted)

With 11 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

Now getting a replacement for N9V.

MoD fixed your mistakes

...removed scmp's vote

[Aimee]

Thanks!

Also, Vel-Rahn Koon replaces N9V.