Open 37 - Crush Nightless (Game Over) before 477

[pickemgenius]

well im stumped.

im convinced im town (obv obv)

so I have no use in hammering anyone right now...

gimme like 10 minutes.

[distad]

Nice. I got it right.

Given the vote history, I think the worst we can do is tie, now. If I'm BM's target, he played it very well. I still think that PE is his target, but his vote on me makes sense. He knows my vote is out there and that PE still has to vote. Voting for you even if you are his target is stupid, because you certainly would not vote for yourself, with the reasoning that a tie is better than a loss.

Think about this, PE. It makes sense. If I were the lyncher, I wouldn't have shown ANY inclination toward my target the whole game until we got to Day 3. On the other hand, BM has already voted for you on a day when EVERYONE else voted for only scum.

[distad]

But, somehow, if you feel that I'm the lyncher, please give me a chance to respond to any argument before you vote. I'll be around consistently over the next 15-30 minutes.

[pickemgenius]

Ill just say that either one of you could be the lyncher and big ups if I chose wrong.

Distad ive been kissing your ass all game, and you've eaten it up. Also as soon as BM mentioned you, you quickly voted him. =/

BM your vote has been on me throughout the game, so I dont see how it would make sense to vote distad today if you were the lyncher.

Vote: Distad

gg either way.

[distad]

Crap.

Man...

I was town.

[distad]

Man... I said WAIT. Look at the WHOLE day 3. I've been on him the WHOLE day.

Crap.

[distad]

Of course it made sense for him to vote me! He KNOWS you won't vote for yourself!!!

GUH!

[distad]

I started in 139, the FIRST post of D3.

[distad]

<sigh>

It's either a good tie, BM, or a great win.

[pickemgenius]

well gg bm

[Battle Mage]

lol i have a game we can play. Guess who my target was.

[Battle Mage]

Tbh, i'm genuinely surprised that Pickem trusted me on that. Distad has a habit of reading me well when i am scum, and again, i felt you were almost certain to trust him.
There again, i can see the logic for your vote. I played a tricky game, and all things considered, i'm fairly happy with the result.
I'll let the mod reveal my role.

BM

[JDodge]

Ze Final Vote Count

:

distad (2) - (Battle Mage, pickemgenius)
Battle Mage (1) - (distad)

You decide after a long day's deliberation that distad should hang. He was a

townie

. But who was it that was trying to lynch him?

...


The answer is nobody. Pickemgenius was the

target

, and Battle Mage was the

lyncher

. Since a lynch can no longer be achieved, Battle Mage has failed to lynch his target. Town wins.

[Battle Mage]

WOAH WOAH WOAH. Hang on a second there. You told me that if the non-target dies, NOBODY WINS. The town fail to meet their win condition of eliminating all threats, the mafia are dead, and i fail to get Pickem lynched. So everyone loses. Or at least, thats what you told me via pm.
You arent seriously telling me now that i blew the game over wrong information!?

[Battle Mage]

WOAH WOAH WOAH. Hang on a second there. You told me that if the non-target dies, NOBODY WINS. The town fail to meet their win condition of eliminating all threats, the mafia are dead, and i fail to get Pickem lynched. So everyone loses. Or at least, thats what you told me via pm.
You arent seriously telling me now that i blew the game over wrong information!?

EBWOP: Crap, i read your pm wrong. Sorry about that.
Ah well, i was never going to be able to lynch Pickem anyway. But i was kinda hoping for at least a tie by getting Distad killed.
Still, i think, aside from my actual win condition, i played pretty well lol.
Really enjoyed the setup too.

Good Game.

BM

[pickemgenius]

Pickemgenius was the

target

ORLY?

[Battle Mage]

Pickemgenius was the

target

ORLY?

YA RLY!

[distad]

It was a good set up... and despite the final conclusion, I don't consider it a win on our part. Your vote for me was good. You couldn't vote for PE without making it SUPER obvious, and like I said earlier, he wouldn't vote for himself.

So, well done.

[MeMe]

last post