Mini 466 - Game Over

[Jester]

Jester, why are you convinced that Numeronean7 is town?

100% convinced? No. Call it 90% convinced. I've been getting a town vibe from Numenorean most of the game. His only scum-tell in the game was his participation in the Nano and ryan lynches, and he's been doing his best to help the town track down scum. He was the first person to voice suspicions about Lowell and was the first person to point out that Lowell's participation in this game didn't track with his participation in other games.

However, the thing I find most compelling is that while the AmeliaLi band-wagon was going on, Lowell had a vote against you. And so did Numenorean. And nobody else. I find it really hard to believe that two scum would, all by themselves and so early in the game, both vote for the same person. Lowell and Numenorean were also the first two people to vote for ryan in his eventual lynch, and I find it hard to believe that two scum would do that, either.

So yeah, I'm reasonably convinced he's a townie.

Why do you think he's scum, klopyrev? And what do you think about SPAG?

[klopyrev]

I think Numeronean7 is scum for the same reasons that I think Sir Tornado is scum. As for SPAG: I see that he's been very suspicious for most of the game, but I never put him on my scum list. He is the 3rd most suspicious person here. I'm pretty convinced that Jester, AmeliaLi and myself are town. That leaves Sir Tornado, Numeronean7 and SPAG. I think Sir Tornado is the most suspicious, followed by Numeronean7, followed by SPAG. If you can point out to me in which post Numeronean7 accused Lowell, I will change that order. As for now, since we don't agree on Numeronean7, I'm going to take my vote off him.

Unvote

[klopyrev]

Although, since you're convinced of Numeronean7's innocence and that I'm telling the truth, I feel that you must have information that we don't all have.

[Kison]

~~Day Four : Vote Count~~

Code: Select all

SPAG           (2) : Jester, AmeliaLi

Not Voting     (4) : Numenorean7, Sir Tornado, SPAG, klopyrev

With

6

alive, it takes

4

to lynch.

[Jester]

If you can point out to me in which post Numeronean7 accused Lowell, I will change that order.

Earliest example, his 128.

[klopyrev]

Wow... That really does make him look very town. Fair enough. I agree with you on Numeronean7. He's off my scum list. With only Sir Tornado and SPAG remaining:

Vote SPAG

[klopyrev]

I have a suspicion about who's going to be the last to vote for SPAG, if SPAG turns out to be mafia, I'll voice whether that suspicion comes true.

[Numenorean7]

1) I believe SPAG is more likely to be scum than klopyrev. I didn't believe his claim at first, but there are a lot of easier claims he could have made. I don't see why he would claim two-shot vig unless it is true. I think the claim is likely genuine.
2) I don't think we're going to get anyone lynched other than SPAG, since AmeliaLi and Jester have made it clear that their votes are not moving, and klopy is now voting him.
3) If SPAG is town, I think that the scum would have finished him off during the long interval in which he had two votes. If one or both of those voting are scum, this argument doesn't work, but I think SPAG-scum is a lot more likely than Jester-scum or AmeliaLi-scum.

Vote: SPAG

And that's a hammer.

[Kison]

~~Day Four : Final Vote Count~~

Code: Select all

SPAG           (4) : Jester, AmeliaLi, klopyrev, Numenorean7

Not Voting     (2) : Sir Tornado, SPAG

6

alive,

4

to lynch.

And so, SPAG is drug out back and hung from the tree, just as the others were. A quick raid of his house leads you to conclude that...

SPAG, Vanilla Townie, has been lynched during Day Four.

It is now Night Four.

Night Choices!

[Kison]

Everyone once again awoke the following morning and met at the typical location. Surprisingly, however, none of those who had departed at the end of the previous day failed to show up.

It is now Day Five.

With

5

alive, it takes

3

to lynch.

~~Updated List of Living Players~~

1) AmeliaLi
2) Jester
3) Sir Tornado
4) Numenorean7
5) klopyrev

[Numenorean7]

It seems we do have an RB, and he hit scum last night. I think a claim would be in order.

[Sir Tornado]

Claim:

I am the RB. I blocked AmeliaLi last night.

Night actions:

Night 1: Block ryan
Night 2: Block Lowell
Night 3: Block Numenorean7
Night 4: Block AmeliaLi

I think AmeliaLi and Klopyrev are our final scum.

I do not believe Klopyrev's claim really. I did not role block him at all on Nights 2 or 3.

[Sir Tornado]

Vote: AmeliaLi

[Jester]

I am the town's role-blocker. I blocked Sir Tornado last night. I thought we must have two more scum, but if blocking ST prevented a night-kill, we must only have one. In addition, I blocked klopyrev on nights one, two, and three. His totally insane play prompted me to block him, and I kept it up after he said he was bored with the game. I figured he was a power-role, and as I said, I figured he was the SK. That's why when he role-claimed Vigilante, I believed him.

I'm sorry about what happened with SPAG, but I was sure he was another mafia. The idea of having only two mafia in a twelve person game never even occurred to me.

But the fact that we apparently only have one mafia left makes Sir Tornado's claim a lie. If AmeliaLi and klopyrev were both mafia, a) we still would have had a dead body last night, and b) the game would already be over. (a) is true because blocking one mafia out of two does not prevent the kill (I checked this with Kison when I was given this role). (b) is true because after klopyrev killed someone, we would have had two mafia and two townies, thus ending the game with a mafia win.

I can believe Sir Tornado is

a

role-blocker... specifically, the mafia role-blocker. But he's not the town-allied role-blocker. That's me.

vote: Sir Tornado

[Numenorean7]

Two Mafia against a Cop, a Doc, a 2-shot vig, and a RB? Seriously?

[Numenorean7]

Here's what I figure:

If ST is telling the truth, AmeliaLi is scum.
Klopyrev could be her partner, fakeclaiming vig.
Jester could be her partner, Mafia RB, who blocked klopyrev.

If Jester is telling the truth, ST is scum alone.
And the game was severely imbalanced in favor of the town.

I'm at a loss. I want to hear what AmeliaLi and Klopyrev have to say.

[Jester]

Yeah, the only other thing I can think of is that the mafia believed klopyrev's role-claim and decided against NKing someone to try to get me to out myself. But if there are two mafia left, they didn't have to do that. When I blocked ST, the other would have made the NK and won the game, unless I'm missing something.

Only two mafia doesn't make any sense to me either, unless ST

is

a mafia role-blocker and Kison thought that would balance out having so many pro-town roles.

But sure, I'm willing to wait to hear from AmeliaLi and klopyrev.

[klopyrev]

Lol... Great idea blocking me all the time. If you didn't, we'd have Sir Tornado dead already. Anyway, I have no idea how the hell it's possible the game is not over. This is a relief, because I thought killing SPAG was the final screw-up. I seriously doubt we only have 2 mafia. It doesn't make any sense. Anyway, whatever the case, I suggest we kill Sir Tornado right now as I already suggested during the last day.

Vote Sir Tornado

[Numenorean7]

So you're suggesting Jester is lying

and

Sir Tornado is scum?

[klopyrev]

Huh? When did I suggest Jester is lying?

[Sir Tornado]

Thanks a lot Jester... you did exactly what I expected you to do.

Unvote

Vote: Sir T

[Sir Tornado]

And, yes, that's a self hammer.

[Sir Tornado]

And, in case anyone is wondering, the mafia sent in kills every night along with the name of a person to make the kills. You had to block that person to block the kills. I made the kill last night, Jester blocked me, we had no death today.

[Sir Tornado]

I meant to add this in my last post (this, and the last 3 posts should have been ONE single post).

If I were my scum partner, I would NOT make any kills tonight.

[Kison]

~~Day Five : Final Vote Count~~

Code: Select all

Sir Tornado   (3) : Jester, klopyrev, Sir Tornado

Not Voting    (2) : AmeliaLi, Numenorean7

5

alive,

3

to lynch.

Without any warning, Sir Tornado ran towards the tree with the noose already ready, jumped, and landed his neck around the rope. He appeared to die instantaniously. The four of you rush to his home, kicking the door down in anticipation, and discover yet another Mafia ID Card. You'd think he'd have learned to have rid himself of that after what happened to Lowell!

Sir Tornado, Mafia Member, has been lynched during Day Five.

It is now Night Five.

Night actions!