Mini 478- Simenon's Too Much Scum: Game Over

[The Fonz]

I'd actually like for The Fonz to check in. I don't like his lurking, and as he's the only other person who doesn't have a vote on ac1983fan, I'm curious what he thinks.

I'm kinda in a bind here. I think acfan stands out as the obviously most scummy player in the game, but I don't feel ready to drop the hammer. The only thing that's changed since I last posted is that JDodge doesn't seem as scummy as Al did. I normally hate this argument, but there is literally nothing else i can say at this point.

[Simenon]

Vote Count

Acfan (3)- Jordan, Jdodge, SirWario
SirWario (1)- acfan

Deadline- August 17th

With six alive, it’s four to lynch.

[Rishi]

I'm not 100% comfortable dropping the hammer either. Per the rules, if no one receives a majority by deadline, then we go into night with No Lynch. I think, when the serial killer is out there, that's bad. So I'll likely drop the hammer before deadline.

I think we can still give it a couple more days to see if anything develops.

[The Fonz]

The thing is, how do we 'let things develop?' The only way something interesting happens is, well, if someone says something. I suppose the onus is on acfan now.

[JordanA24]

To be honest, if we've got as much evidence against someone as we have, just waiting to see if anything else will develop will is pointless because no-one will bother speaking up.

FOS: Rishi

If acfan turns up Mafia, I think Rishi is his buddy.

[SirWario]

The way I see it is that acfan has an opportunity to vindicate himself if he simply explains his vote with sufficient evidence. This is his only chance to redeem himself. If he doesn't defend himself properly, then he's going to be the next lynch.

[ac1983fan]

unvote:Sirwario vote:rishi

reason number 1:

In hindsight, we should have asked for a replacement.

To be honest, this is one of the scummiest excuses in the book, apologising for scummy behaviour and hoping others forget about it. I also found your quick hammer suspicious. But I have to agree with you, he was exceedingly scummy and to be honest, a rather bad player. I don't think it's vote worthy, especially considering how we could be, depending on the SK's choice, in a lylo situation. But, I'll

FOS: Rishi

Jordan basically spelled it out.
Reason number 2:

Keep in mind we do have a 50% shot of hitting some kind of scum right now. If someone seems scummy, they probably are. I don't see ac1983fan as Mafia, but he could be the SK.

how could someone tell the diference.
reason number three:

So, if the hammer is going to drop on ac1983fan, it is up to either me or The Fonz. I haven't decided if ac1983fan is just a really bad player or if he is a scummy player, or both.

But I don't like how he doesn't respond to anything or give any explanation for his votes or actions. I'd rather give him another chance to explain himself before I drop the hammer. I think his lynch can still be prevented, since The Fonz is quasi-lurking in this game anyway.

could be scum trying to get ready to hammer me without looking to scummy if he hammers and I show up town. "Oh, i gave him a chance..." espacially after he hammered yesterday...

that's it...

[Rishi]

Well, the reason I thought you might the SK rather than the Mafia is that you were not involved in the mislynch and you seemed to be trying to fly under the radar.

But voting for the one person who was somewhat defending you? What an idiotic move.

Vote: ac1983fan

[ac1983fan]

Well, the reason I thought you might the SK rather than the Mafia is that you were not involved in the mislynch and you seemed to be trying to fly under the radar.

But voting for the one person who was somewhat defending you? What an idiotic move.

Vote: ac1983fan

you weren't defending me.
bah go scum

[SirWario]

One scum down!

[creampuffeater]

I am going to give simenon a day to post flavor/ a deathscene of his choosing, if he has no access, I will do it.

[Simenon]

End-of-Day Vote Count

Acfan (4)- Jordan, Jdodge, SirWario, Rishi
Rishi (1)- acfan

After a day of bitter arguing following an dismaying first day, you lead acfan to his death. Then he dies. How anticlimactic.

But despite the less than dramatic lynch, you have reason to rejoice. Acfan, mafia, is lynched day two.

It is now night two. Send choices to me, unless I later ask you to send them to creampuffeater.

[Simenon]

Jordan dies. He was a townie.

It is now day three. With four alive, it's three to lynch.

The town must lynch the serial killer, or they lose.

[JordanA24]

Bah, go town!

[Rishi]

So, if this isn't obvious to everyone, we have two townies, a serial killer and a Mafia. We must lynch the serial killer or the SK wins.

[Simenon]

Do I really need to prod all of you?

[SirWario]

The way I see it is that Fonz is scum. Jdodge was pretty set on acfan scum, a likely scumbuddy would not attack his partner this vehemently. Acfan voted Rishi and then Rishi layed the hammer down. I'm pretty sure they would not be scum together. Fonz chose to shy away from the lynch because he saw his scumbuddy on the chopping block.

But we can't lynch Fonz because then SK wins. This does narrow down our options for finding SK though.

[The Fonz]

The way i see it is that Wario is wrong. Seriously, I was on acfan all day yesterday. I was quite happy to hammer, only Rishi did it before I could. Acfan made a big deal of attacking me and Rishi for our quicklynch yesterday, which makes me think Rishi is definitely not his buddy. However, of course, that actually makes it

more

likely he should be lynched today. Bah. Gonna do a re-read, and try to work out what an SK tell might look.

[SirWario]

I'm kinda in a bind here. I think acfan stands out as the obviously most scummy player in the game, but I don't feel ready to drop the hammer.

Fonz, this doesn't seem quite happy to hammer. Also, could you display some of the instances where you were "on" acfan.

[Rishi]

I don't think we can ignore JDodge. JDodge has seemed to be better than AlSleet, but you have to admit that AlSleet did not look great.

[The Fonz]

Wario- as you can see, Ac1983fan was my Number one suspect for the whole of yesterday:

I hate using the 'well it was a random vote and i didn't think anyone would hammer' argument. I agree it was bigtime asscovering, and I disagree that town has the same motivation to do it that scum does- after all, scum know the lynchee isn't scum.

Same reason I don't like acfan's post at the start of this page.

Still here, still want an answer outta ac. Top suspects as of now: Al and acfan. Kinda pissed that the one person i was convinced is town is the one who died overnight, but that's to be expected i 'spose.

I'd actually like for The Fonz to check in. I don't like his lurking, and as he's the only other person who doesn't have a vote on ac1983fan, I'm curious what he thinks.

I'm kinda in a bind here. I think acfan stands out as the obviously most scummy player in the game, but I don't feel ready to drop the hammer. The only thing that's changed since I last posted is that JDodge doesn't seem as scummy as Al did. I normally hate this argument, but there is literally nothing else i can say at this point.

[Simenon]

Prodding Jdodge

[JDodge]

I am sick. Will be back soon.

[SirWario]

Wario- as you can see, Ac1983fan was my Number one suspect for the whole of yesterday:

I hate using the 'well it was a random vote and i didn't think anyone would hammer' argument. I agree it was bigtime asscovering, and I disagree that town has the same motivation to do it that scum does- after all, scum know the lynchee isn't scum.

Same reason I don't like acfan's post at the start of this page.

Still here, still want an answer outta ac. Top suspects as of now: Al and acfan. Kinda pissed that the one person i was convinced is town is the one who died overnight, but that's to be expected i 'spose.

I'd actually like for The Fonz to check in. I don't like his lurking, and as he's the only other person who doesn't have a vote on ac1983fan, I'm curious what he thinks.

I'm kinda in a bind here. I think acfan stands out as the obviously most scummy player in the game, but I don't feel ready to drop the hammer. The only thing that's changed since I last posted is that JDodge doesn't seem as scummy as Al did. I normally hate this argument, but there is literally nothing else i can say at this point.

I agree with the twilight posting part, but besides that all I see you saying about acfan is that you think he is the most scummy. Any scumbuddies can distance themselves from each other by saying that your partner is your top suspect. But you never even FOSed him or voted him.

It doesn't even matter if I think that you're scum because i'm not going to vote you today. If you're town, and I think that you're scum, it shouldn't be a problm today. It just narrows down my suspects for SK. The only other scum I see possible is Rishi, though that is less feasible.

One more thing, if you're not scum, who do you think is?

[Simenon]

Vote Count

No votes yet.

With four alive, it's three to lynch.