Open 27- Bird C9 (Game over!) before 466

[Albert B. Rampage]

For me it would be one of my top two choices. Aimee has yet to take her warning vote off me before deadline hits, though. I hope she does.

[spectrumvoid]

Major attitude change: After a reread, because I've been inactive, I have now decided that I don't think ryan is scummy. I also do not think that TCS is scummy. As such, I will be voting tarha tomorrow.


(I have really bad internet connection because of school, I'll figure out a way tomorrow, post from library or something. If it gets really bad, I'll ask for replacement.)

[Albert B. Rampage]

^

Scummy as hell.

[ryan]

I'm confused how a re-read with some new suspects and new possibilities=scummy?

[Albert B. Rampage]

No explanation whatsoever.

[ryan]

I don't think anyone is claiming that Spec has played this game very well.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Spec probably has a reason to think so, yet she is withholding that information. That's why I think she is scummy.

[ryan]

Seemed like a rather abrupt post and since I'm in a few more this wasn't totally unexpected.

[Aimee]

unvote

, but I still have my eye on you, ABR.

I could deal with a Tar lynch as well actually, so may vote soon.

(Please note I am in Nice in France so have quite limited access at this point.)

[Cephrir]

Tarhalindur 2 (The Central Scrutinizer, ryan)

The Central Scrutinizer 1 (Albert B. Rampage)
ryan 1 (FeRnAnDo)

Not Voting 3 (spectrumvoid, Tarhalindur, Aimee)

Deadline pushed back to Wednesday due to discussion. If this continues I will move it back to next Saturday, which is the absolute final deadline.

[ryan]

A week from tomorrow is a fair deadline Cephrir, thanks for giving the extension

[Tarhalindur]

I'm back from vacation.

After thinking it over during my limited access, I've decided that, given the way my role works in this game (IMO, my role claim is more valuable than my actual role), I need to claim D1 - and given the deadline, now is a good time for that claim.

I have one of the two roles in the game where I believe that it's acceptable to breadcrumb, and as such I breadcrumbed my role earlier in this game. Observe:

Let's see...

Aimee:

Aimee is slow to get rolling early on, waffles between Barmacral and me (extremely wishy-washy), asks for comments from others, asks for prod on SV/ brings up SV's V/LA status, still wants other people's thoughts, posts her thoughts on other players (very non-committal about everyone else in the game - Aimee throws out FoS's and IGMEOY's like candy, but doesn't actually vote anyone). In particular, Aimee's comments about EB seem very hypocritical:

However, the fact [EB] seems to take two sides to every player is quite concerning - seemingly like he didn't want to step on any toes.

"Pot, this is Kettle. You're black."

Aimee, you're being WAY too noncommittal here. I want a Top 2 Scum List from you. NOW.

Quick Read:

: Scummy, but not as scummy as SV (see below) and Barmacral.

SpectrumVoid:

Spectrum has very little content due to RL issues. That said, what little comment she does have is starting to get concerning to me - she finds several things "odd" but doesn't find anything "scummy", she seems to be stepping in and trying to befriend newbies (I've looked over a number of completed games where experienced scum tried to befriend newbies in order to influence the newbies' votes). There's also this little gem of a comment:

...but my verdict is not scummy for that scum-tell for now

Uh, whiskey tango foxtrot much? That looks like a direct contradiction to me. (I should have spotted it earlier, but I've had limited access for the last couple of days.)

Quick Read:

Hi, scum. Die, scum. Unless I'm very much mistaken, you have committed direct contradiction, an offense for which the appropriate penalty is

extermination

by lynching. Unvote, Vote: SpectrumVoid

Enlightened Bystander:

random votes, comments on lack of discussion/notes limited access, offers reasoning on everyone/states that he doesn't really find anyone scummy yet, offers opinions about what to do re: lurkers, offers a Top 2 Scum List with decent reasoning.

Quick Read:

Town. I can't find anything wrong with what EB's posted so far. Barring a major change in his play, he should not be

exterminated

today.

Note: After rereading Fernando's posts, I noticed something that makes me absolutely, 100% sure that he is not the play for today. I am NOT going to be specific here.

So, why would I use "exterminate" instead of "lynch"? Why, because "EXTERMINATE!" is the catchphrase of the Daleks of Doctor Who fame. And who is the main character of Doctor Who? Why, the

Doctor

, of course!

[Albert B. Rampage]

Unvote him for the love of god.

[ryan]

Unvote

JEEZ man! I'm not sure if that was the smartest thing to do (how about putting up a decent argument against somebody else?) Anyway, I'll go back to my original scum candidate

Vote: FeRnAnDo

[ryan]

Tar: With you not voting right now I'll ask, who are your top suspects at the moment?

[Tarhalindur]

Unvote

JEEZ man! I'm not sure if that was the smartest thing to do (how about putting up a decent argument against somebody else?) Anyway, I'll go back to my original scum candidate

Vote: FeRnAnDo

If he was your original scum candidate, then why were you voting for me instead of him in the first place?

Unvote, Vote: ryan

[ryan]

Unvote

JEEZ man! I'm not sure if that was the smartest thing to do (how about putting up a decent argument against somebody else?) Anyway, I'll go back to my original scum candidate

Vote: FeRnAnDo

If he was your original scum candidate, then why were you voting for me instead of him in the first place?

Unvote, Vote: ryan

Because I felt the evidence was better on you, but with a claim like the one you made and me not wanting to lynch a doc I went back to my first candidate. There are multiple scum you realize?

[Albert B. Rampage]

Unvote, vote Spectrumvoid

I really don't like how she 180 degree'd with no explanation. I think she's our best bet.

[ryan]

Unvote, vote Spectrumvoid

I really don't like how she 180 degree'd with no explanation. I think she's our best bet.

And Aimee?

[FeRnAnDo]

Ryan wrote:

You're right it was a misunderstanding, I was saying you were ducking a vote and mistyped and said you were ducking a post.

You mistyped in FOUR different posts? 110, 117, 121 and 126?

that's really odd, please explain us that rationally... don't blame alcohol or something else.

[ryan]

Ryan wrote:

You're right it was a misunderstanding, I was saying you were ducking a vote and mistyped and said you were ducking a post.

You mistyped in FOUR different posts? 110, 117, 121 and 126?

that's really odd, please explain us that rationally... don't blame alcohol or something else.

Obviously if I didn't get the point up until currently I would have kept using the same early post that I was wrong with. Now we have alot of new information, are we going to continue to live in the past or move forward? I made a mistake reading your post (obviously) and I used the same reasoning up until I figured out my mistake.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Unvote, vote Spectrumvoid

I really don't like how she 180 degree'd with no explanation. I think she's our best bet.

And Aimee?

Aimee's okay. My list is at SV, TCS, ryan, from scummiest to least.

[Cephrir]

ryan 2 (FeRnAnDo, Tarhalindur)

FeRnAnDo 1 (ryan)
Tarhalindur 1 (The Central Scrutinizer)
spectrumvoid 1 (Albert B. Rampage)

Not Voting 2 (spectrumvoid, Aimee)

4 to lynch, deadline moved back to Saturday. This one is not retractable.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

unvote, vote: ABR

because I don't like his scumlist (not just my inclusion in it).

[Aimee]

I agree with TCS. Albert is a better lynch than SV at this point.

vote: Albert B. Rampage

Please note I won`t be back for the deadline.