Open 28 - Quack Mafia. OVER! But who won? before 466

[~N9V~]

FOrgot to do this.

Vote BM

[Battle Mage]

FOrgot to do this.

Vote BM

odd that this comes after you put CKD top of your LoS. Plus, you are getting me confused with another guy on site (Black Mage). PLUS, placing a BW vote before you have read the whole game is pretty dumb.

BM

[~N9V~]

Sorry BM, I keep mixing up your name with a name in a game I play

[JordanA24]

I'm still here, nothing has really convinced me to change my vote. Though, I'm quite out of touch with this game, so I'm off for a reread, after which I shall post my other 2 top suspects.

[curiouskarmadog]

Here's my list of three.

curiouskarmadog: Posted alot of crap within the first few pages, the main one being he freaked out becuase people put a third vote on someone. THis isn't a nwewbie game, threevotes doesn't do shit. Also claimed to have not protected some one, which I don't buy.

Black Mage: Cannot be too certain withhis game style, and again, at the begginin, he really stood out to my as BM Scummy, not BMTown. First thing, was how he attacked someone becuase they wanted to put together a planfor the town. People blamed this onthat he's never been in a quack mafia game before, bt that doesn't mean anything. Quack Mafia or not, attacking people who sho pro-town potential is a scumtell.

theoper_COD: Threw his vote around quit abit, and was attacking players who also appeared pro-town, supposidly for a reaction.

*Note, this is onyl after reading the first 8 pages. Will try to read the rest today or tommorow.

your thoughts on Piggy and Mert?

[Battle Mage]

N9V- i played a newbie game with Black Mage too. very confusing lol.

[JordanA24]

2.

Mert

: For a number of reasons, firstly for the links with Piggy, who is my Number 1 suspect. A few pages back, he said we should lynch BM, then Piggy if BM turns up town, then does this:

Don't worry BM, I wanted to see how she responded to the suggestion rather than actually planning to do it.

Right now, I still want to lynch CKD mostly.

WTF? That was just for response reasons? Why did you do that? BM and Piggy weren't that connected, Piggy was voting BM, and? So was I, why didn't you do that to, say, JDodge and Indy, or BM and Stewie? I think you were trying to do that to say "Look, I'm focusing on Piggy now, I'm saying we should lynch him", let me ask you this, If people started agreeing with you and started voting BM, would you have said that it was just for reactions?

Another reason for you being my Number 2 suspect is that I think CKD is protown, both you and Dral (while he was around) were heavily against him, and I think CKD has been a reasonably useful member of the town. I also think Hjallti made some excellent points against you as well.

3.

ControlledBurn

: While he was around, I feel he was actively lurking, the majority of his posts where completely contentless.

I also hate this post:

The problem with a mass claim this early is it gives the scum a sure list of who is a doc and who's a quack, and can start trying to eliminate the normal doc's each night.

One of the most crucial weapons the town has to lynch scum is information, in this game, that sort of information is absolutely vital. Saying we shouldn't take advantage of it because the scum might be able to work out who the actual docs are is very weak (and poor) reasoning.

[Hjallti]

At last some posts...
Hopefully Piggy and Vampaneze get back as well

[JordanA24]

Vampaneze?

[Hjallti]

Oops: EBWOPASNMM* I was confusing with another game, where we are waiting for Vampaneze. I only meant Ms. Piggy

*(Edit by way of post after some noticed my mistake)

[Stewie]

Ms Piggy hasn't posted on the site since Aug 29

[JordanA24]

Ms Piggy hasn't posted on the site since Aug 29

I didn't know you had a crystal ball.

[curiouskarmadog]

great progress! (of sorts)..

still waiting for N9V's response to my question.

Mod since we are might be starting to move again, A vote count could be in order.

[curiouskarmadog]

Here's my list of three.

curiouskarmadog: Posted alot of crap within the first few pages, the main one being he freaked out becuase people put a third vote on someone. THis isn't a nwewbie game, threevotes doesn't do shit. Also claimed to have not protected some one, which I don't buy.

also this is a ridiculous post…my “main load of crap” was “I freaked out” when Indy placed a 3rd vote on someone for no reason on the 1st page? Lets review my crap filled post where I freaked out.

Whadido... I mean

Vote: Battlemage

vote indy

for placing the 3rd vote on someone on the first page.

Yep, I really freaked out. Any reason you are trying to blow this post out of proportion?

still requesting your thoughts on these two.

[Stewie]

Ms Piggy hasn't posted on the site since Aug 29

I didn't know you had a crystal ball.

?

[JordanA24]

Ms Piggy hasn't posted on the site since Aug 29

I didn't know you had a crystal ball.

?

I think you meant July 29th.

[Stewie]

Oh, yeah.

[Hjallti]

Ms. Piggy was prodded Aug 2nd (post 340), I think she should be replaced.

Mert was asked more than once to give his view on the alledged connection with Ms/ Piggy. He still didn't answer, but dodged the question;

I'm usually not in the business of thinking of possible partnerships on Day One, but there is something noteworthy about Ms Piggy / BM though. Needs further investigation once we know one of their alignments, definitely.

Therefor I

confirm

my

vote:Mert

[curiouskarmadog]

MOD (whichever of the three are currently watching this game)

We are in serious need of prods and/or replacements!

[Mert]

Mert was asked more than once to give his view on the alledged connection with Ms/ Piggy. He still didn't answer, but dodged the question;

Well, if one were so inclined to be pedantic, one could point out that you did not, in fact, ask a direct question of me, but merely made statements in the hope I would respond.

However, I'm not going to argue semantics. Frankly the last time you posted "linking" me and Ms Piggy together, I answered the points I felt needed answering. If there is something specific you'd like me to address, please post a specific question in your next post. All I currently have from you is faulty logic that appears that you have decided that Ms Piggy and I are connected and then have gone back through the game looking for ways to back that up, rather than reaching the conclusion naturally.

[Thesp]

Vote Count

Mert - 3 (Indy, Hjallti, curiouskarmadog)

Ms Piggy - 2 (JordanA24, Stewie)
Battle Mage - 1 (Ms Piggy, ~N9V~)
Stewie – 1 (Battle Mage)
Indy – 1 (JDodge)

Not Voting - 2 (ControlledBurn, Mert)

6 to lynch.

I am hunting 2-4 replacements. If you're watching and interested, please PM me. Thanks!

[Thesp]

d3sisted replaces Ms Piggy, effective immediately.

[d3sisted]

I need something clarified:
Imagine Doc1 targets Quack1, and Mafia targets Quack1. Quack1 lives because of Doc1's protection, right? Great.

But what if another quack, Quack2 targets Doc1? Is Doc1's protect still valid, or does it depend on who sends their choice in first?

[d3sisted]

Oh, btw, same thing above applying to a quack.
If Quack1 targets Doc1, but Mafia targets Quack1, does Quack1 suddenly lose his abilities? Who dies?

[JDodge]

Bleh, I need a re-read; I'll get back to you sometime tomorrow or Thursday.