Open 28 - Quack Mafia. OVER! But who won? before 466

[Hjallti]

I want everyone to give either a top3 list of scum of everyone with reasons in own words, or two really important open questions for other players, to kick this game.
if you fail to this I will ask a prod and will consider it a scumtell. you may refuse with a good reasons and another proposition to kick this game!

[Battle Mage]

1. Ms Piggy- reels off a load of WIFOM why i might be scum. It could just be genuine ignorance, or it could be simple scumminess. Then she goes away and lurks for ages.

2. Stewie- seemed to support Piggy's comments, and when Piggy started to lurk, he requested that she return with more crap. Regardless of Piggy's affiliation, i could see Stewie as scum (either setting off two townies against the other, or scum blatantly defending a buddy)
Then makes the common scum response of saying "I was supporting Piggy, so you should vote for her, and not me". I'm not buying it one bit.

3. Curiouskarmadog- merely for his claim of no choice sent in. Not in the same realms of scumminess as the other two, but would be my next choice for a lynch.

BM

[curiouskarmadog]

Mert and Piggy, I have stated numerous times why..

I do not have a third at this time.

[Stewie]

1. Piggy: votes for BM giving no reasons other than "those already stated by others" (paraphrase)." When asked to elaborate in her own words, she doesn't, so one can only assume that she has no reason to vote for BM. There's also Dral's behaviour to consider.
2. BM: after I ask Piggy to explain herself, he somehow concludes that I support Piggy (which is not true) and votes me. It seems as if he is reluctant to vote for Piggy, and votes for me despite the fact that I do not agree with Piggy's "logic" (she didn't really give a reason of her own, or pointed out other people's reasons). He also keeps ignoring me when I say that I do not agree with Piggy's logic, that I don't know what led him to this conclusion, and that I actually want Piggy to to explain herself (I am voting for her, after all, so what would lead him to believe I agree with her?). There's other things too, like when Dral posted to say he had nothing to post, and BM agreed, also with no content.

3. curioskarmadog: he's on my list because I need three people for the list and not two. I don't really think he's suspicious, but I'm keeping my eye on him due to the fact that he did not protect night one. If the question was "who do you find suspicious?" with no specific number of people, he would not be on this list. I wouldn't lynch him on what we have so far, however.

[curiouskarmadog]

Aimee can you please

prod Mert

as it has been over 7 days since he has post...

doing a little metagaming, he is active in many other games, but I start putting on the pressure here and he stops posting...

anyone else find that interesting?

[curiouskarmadog]

also it looks like we need replacements for n9V, controlledburn, and piggy..

[curiouskarmadog]

jesus, and Indy as well...

[Hjallti]

Sad that people volunteer to replace and need prodding/replacement themselfs a week later....

[~N9V~]

I said I won't beable t opost untill today. I have work you know. I'll reread today andget a post up today or tomomrow.

And on a side note, it looks like your not fully reading the thread ckd, or you would've seen that, as your the only one bitching about it.

[Patrick]

Hi guys. Aimee is on holiday and may have restricted access, so I will be helping out as necessary here. I have everyone's roles.

Mert has been prodded.

[Battle Mage]

jesus, and Indy as well...

huh?
don't replace Jesus. He's the guy who invited me to join this game!

[curiouskarmadog]

I said I won't beable t opost untill today. I have work you know. I'll reread today andget a post up today or tomomrow.

And on a side note, it looks like your not fully reading the thread ckd, or you would've seen that, as your the only one bitching about it.

I have read the thread, you siad something about finding a replacement for you if needed...its needed..unless you are going to start posting

[curiouskarmadog]

Hi guys. Aimee is on holiday and may have restricted access, so I will be helping out as necessary here. I have everyone's roles.

Mert has been prodded.

we also need some replacements or more prodding!

[~N9V~]

Uhh no, I said it was up to her to find a replacement if SHE thought it neccisary, which she obviosly didn't.

[curiouskarmadog]

Uhh no, I said it was up to her to find a replacement if SHE thought it neccisary, which she obviosly didn't.

well apparent she is on holiday for we DO need several other replacements..

but you are back now, so no worries

[curiouskarmadog]

Hi guys. Aimee is on holiday and may have restricted access, so I will be helping out as necessary here. I have everyone's roles.

Mert has been prodded.

MOD

I think we need replacements for controlledburn and Indy..

and a prod for Piggy

if it hasnt been done already

[curiouskarmadog]

Jordan will need a prod

to I think

[Hjallti]

I'm still waiting for the promised summary by ~N9V~ who also till has to answer a question from another game: Where does this name stand for?

[Aimee]

Hi guys! I`m sunning in France at the moment, but whilst I`m away, Thesp will be taking over mainly; I may pop in fo a vote count now and then but my access is very restricted.

[Thesp]

I'll prod all players by tomorrow, and start replacing by Monday. (Alternatively, send me a PM now that says you're paying attention to save me from prodding you. ) Thanks!

[curiouskarmadog]

here and waiting for the rest

[Mert]

I'm usually not in the business of thinking of possible partnerships on Day One, but there is something noteworthy about Ms Piggy / BM though. Needs further investigation once we know one of their alignments, definitely.

I still vastly favour a CKD lynch today. The problem is, this game has rather stalled (and I am aware that I am as much a part of that problem as many other people) and I would rather everyone weighs in before we lynch anybody... even CKD. For that reason,

Unvote

for now.

[~N9V~]

I'm still waiting for the promised summary by ~N9V~ who also till has to answer a question from another game: Where does this name stand for?

Huh, what game was this. And I'm rereading now.

[~N9V~]

Here's my list of three.

curiouskarmadog: Posted alot of crap within the first few pages, the main one being he freaked out becuase people put a third vote on someone. THis isn't a nwewbie game, threevotes doesn't do shit. Also claimed to have not protected some one, which I don't buy.

Black Mage: Cannot be too certain withhis game style, and again, at the begginin, he really stood out to my as BM Scummy, not BMTown. First thing, was how he attacked someone becuase they wanted to put together a planfor the town. People blamed this onthat he's never been in a quack mafia game before, bt that doesn't mean anything. Quack Mafia or not, attacking people who sho pro-town potential is a scumtell.

theoper_COD: Threw his vote around quit abit, and was attacking players who also appeared pro-town, supposidly for a reaction.

*Note, this is onyl after reading the first 8 pages. Will try to read the rest today or tommorow.

[Stewie]

I'm here, also waiting. Voting for Piggy, but I would just as easily vote for BM instead.