MrBuddyLee : 2 (Glork, Patrick)
Not voting: MrBuddyLee Mgm
...he is starting with the assumption that Patrick is scum, concluding that this statement was a bus attempt, then using it as evidence against Patrick.MBL wrote:Busing D5:Patrick wrote:Currently if I had to have a stand alone top suspect, it's probably CES.
...is misleading at best.MBL wrote:Patrick was late to the CDB wagon and afterwards cleared Thesp of a tie to CDB and suggested ties between Mgm and Zindy and CDB.
The case against MBL makes sense.Mgm wrote:Because his case against Patrick makes sense.
His actions do suggest that.Mgm wrote:Do you want to bet the outcome of the game on it?
MBL couldn't get a mislynch, but if Patrick is the scumbag, lynching MBL is the most logical choice for him and the easiest to achieve too.Glork wrote:Need I remind you of your own words, MGM, that if MBLscum couldn't get a guaranteed mislynch, he needed a no-lynch? And that voting Glork would surely achieve that no-lynch?
This is one of those things I don't like about him. If Patrick is not scum, picking MBL is about the only sane thing he could do and he is still acting like it is a guess.Glork wrote:Oh, also Patrick's "Well, it's almost deadline, so I'm going to vote MBL and hope he gets lynched,but I still want Glork to explain why he thinks I'm protown" comment also gives me good feelings.
The hell? You're critisising me for not being certain that MBL is scum? Need I remind you that you started today saying Glork was the most likely scum, and that you recently posted...Mgm wrote: This is one of those things I don't like about him. If Patrick is not scum, picking MBL is about the only sane thing he could do and he is still acting like it is a guess.
Indicating that you're not entirely sure yourself. So how is picking MBL "the only sane thing to do"?Mgm wrote:The only thing I still want to do is investigate Fritzler's posts which could only lead to Glork looking more guilty.
You don't seem to doubt it, so with me confirmed and YOU sure about it, MBL is the only sane choice FOR YOU.Indicating that you're not entirely sure yourself. So how is picking MBL "the only sane thing to do"?
This is clearly incorrect. Scum could nightkill you, in which case there is not one less suspect. No lynch gives scum the chance to take whatever endgame suits them best.Mgm wrote:The difference is that when I'm not sure I don't throw away the game. We have another chance and if we no lynch now, there'll be at least one less suspect tomorrow.
Go read those "old" arguments and act on them.Glork wrote:Elaborate, then. Tell me whyyouthink that Patrick is scum, rather than citing old arguments that MBL has made.
PHAIL. Do not apply this blindly without looking at the specific situation. The strategy you've given is only if you have no confirmed innocents. There may be other reasons for no lynching (cops and docs alive etc) but none of that applies here.Mgm wrote:Besides, with 4 players and 1 standard mafia it's the best strategy to no lynch.
Text book example.