Mini 427 - Clue Mafia 2 - GAME OVER

[Battle Mage]

Alko is being far too logical and reasonable here.

IGMEOY

with reference to BT's question about my play as Cop, i generally end up claiming early. when i am town, i often get forced to claim early, because people assume me acting differently means that i am scum.

[al_kohaulec]

Alko is being far too logical and reasonable here.

IGMEOY

Ok, I have to ask, cause I can't tell. Is this part serious?

[BillyTwilight]

"I would have expected more out of you Alko. "

I haven't read everything you've posted yet, but two things I'd like to say:

1.) I was away for a week, so I need to refresh what I think in this game, and I've had my focus elsewhere. Yes this is a bad reason, but it's true. When I posted, I tried to focus towards players that have been under the radar or that I had little to no notes on, and found virtually no posts to dissect, so I had little to say. I haven't bothered yet to move on to the players that we've been discussing or have discussed more thoroughly before.
2.) With players like BM, you need to look at him from a different perspective, and it becomes more difficult. While at Thespival, LyingBrian came and when he played FTF mafia, he appeared incredibly scummy, but was town. I watched his play, learned that his playstyle frequently threw up scummy flags, but I also found out how different his play and reactions were from normal players. BM is much the same way. After trying to analyze how he played and how his reactions differed, I became better at telling protown LB versus scum LB, and I think we need to work with BM much the same way. It's a difficult process to implement, and more difficult to explain, but I hope you see what I'm trying to say.

Alko, I meant no offense and I was wrong to boot. I was being dumb.

[al_kohaulec]

But you are posting and contributing, which is much more than half the players . I still wanted to say what I said in point 2 though.

[Battle Mage]

Alko is being far too logical and reasonable here.

IGMEOY

Ok, I have to ask, cause I can't tell. Is this part serious?

Partially. of course, it falls neatly into 'Too Townie' Fallacy, so i'm not putting too much emphasis on it, but i am a little bit wary when, whilst townie BillyT is acting irrationally, and paranoid, you are acting in stark contrast. Luckily i'm so grateful for the injection of logical reasoning into the game, i'm not especially worried atm. However my gut instinct tells me that you are too cool about this.

[Mastermind of Sin]

*bump*

Please don't make me deadline this.

[chaotic_diablo]

Read a few pages back.

I don't really understand the significance of this soup thing.

Depending on what your role is, you might be more or less than willing to try something unknown. Pitching the soup might imply that you have a power role while eating it might mean your role is sucky. dahen's post 204 pretty much outlines it. When I look back, it actually makes MBL more suspicious.

So who would have eaten the soup and who would have pitched it, and why?

This could possibly be rolefishing. I think al_ko asked a similiar question?

[al_kohaulec]

I did ask a similar question, and forgot that MBL had asked. I didn't think about how power roles would factor in.

[BillyTwilight]

Haven't had a chance to reread... but I finished HP7, so my spare time is now back. Will try to post by tomorrow something constructive.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Vote Count

MrBuddyLee - (Cogito Ergo Sum, Battle Mage)
Cogito Ergo Sum - (Jack, Ectomancer)
DragonsofSummer - (al_kohaulec)

I will prod anyone who has not posted in a week or more.

[Mastermind of Sin]

The following have been prodded:

Have not posted in 1 month or more (they have 4 days to pick up their prod or I will search for a replacement):

Ancalagon
Cogito Ergo Sum
Dahen

Have not posted in over a week (they have 7 days to pick up their prod):

DragonsofSummer
Ectomancer
Jack
MrBuddyLee

7/11 players not posting is unacceptable.

[al_kohaulec]

:/ I was just about to vote Ancalagon, but having not posted in over two months... I really don't think he's here... Can we skip the four days? Puh-leaze...

Hmmm... I hate this kind of metagaming, but the no kill could be due to inactive mafia...

Unvote, Vote: Ancalagon

Somebody replace to defend yourself!

[Mastermind of Sin]

Ancalagon's last post on the site was in June, as well as dahen's. Their prod time has been reduced to this weekend, basically whenever I find time to start looking for replacements on Sunday/Monday.

[Mastermind of Sin]

dahen has notified me that he will be active again by monday, which is preferable to having to find a replacement.

[MrBuddyLee]

vote: Dragons of Summer

I trust Battle Mage and Twilight for now--working by process of elimination to find scum. I don't really see a ton of scummy protection of the "cop" yesterday to go on either.

[DragonsofSummer]

vote: Dragons of Summer

I trust Battle Mage and Twilight for now--working by process of elimination to find scum. I don't really see a ton of scummy protection of the "cop" yesterday to go on either.

Wait... WHAT?! This is totally bs... you fos'd me in the first place because I siad I trusted BM, and now you are voting me with absolutely no reasoning behind it. I'm starting to think BM is right about you being scum, though his reasoning was wrong.

Also I'd still love for you to address the thing I asked you to in post 240.

Vote MBL

[Jack]

I guess I'll just bandwagon

unvote,vote:mbl

[Mastermind of Sin]

I am searching for a replacement for Ancalagon/CES.

[Ectomancer]

Like I said, Im following Jack.

unvote, vote MBL

[BillyTwilight]

Whoa, whoa, whoa. That puts MBL at -1. Any of you guys give anything resembling a good reason to have MBL that close to a lynch?

[chaotic_diablo]

vote Ectomancer

[DragonsofSummer]

I gave my reasons for my vote. He is being completely contrary to what he said earlier in his vote for me, and he is refusing to give any reasons for his vote against me though I've asked him for them repeatedly. Over all I just have a bad feeling about him and until he gives me a reason not to believe he is scum I feel comfortable with my vote on him.

[Battle Mage]

i'm ok with an MBL hammer. BT is likely to be his buddy.

[BillyTwilight]

i'm ok with an MBL hammer. BT is likely to be his buddy.

Well, so much for your investigation on me being innocent, huh?

[al_kohaulec]

I don't have my notes with me, but I think this is the one game I thought MBL to be town. Please don't quicklynch him.

BM, please explain yourself, you look incredibly scummy in your actions.