Open 29 - C9+2 (~GAME OVER~) before 470

[somestrangeflea]

I would be okay with a Rishi-Crub-Guardian-somestrangeflea order. I don't mind going first. Why is Guardian so reluctant to go early?

I am town. I know that when I claim, I will not be lying. It is in the town's best interests for me to go last.

It doesn't matter how you word it, you can't use "I'm Townie" as a reason that you should claim last, simply because everyone else can use that reasoning as well!

[Mert]

Votecount

YogurtBandit

(1)

Crub

Not Voting

(4):

Rishi, YogurtBandit, Guardian, Somestrangeflea

Three votes will end the day.

[Rishi]

Are we agreed to the Rishi-Crub-Guardian-somestrangeflea order then?

[somestrangeflea]

Sounds good.

[YogurtBandit]

Wait. Hmm. I just now noticed Guardian about the Ill claim last thing.

Make that,

Guardian-Rishi-Crub-Ssf.

I think of the 1st two are scum. so we'll see.

[Rishi]

Wait. Hmm. I just now noticed Guardian about the Ill claim last thing.

Make that,

Guardian-Rishi-Crub-Ssf.

I think of the 1st two are scum. so we'll see.

You suspected Guardian and Crub before. What's changed?

[Guardian]

I would be okay with a Rishi-Crub-Guardian-somestrangeflea order. I don't mind going first. Why is Guardian so reluctant to go early?

I am town. I know that when I claim, I will not be lying. It is in the town's best interests for me to go last.

It doesn't matter how you word it, you can't use "I'm Townie" as a reason that you should claim last, simply because everyone else can use that reasoning as well!

You

and

Crub agreed with my ordering, and that was my original and only reason. Why the change in opinion?


I am still waiting on YB for meaningful content...

[YogurtBandit]

Wait. Hmm. I just now noticed Guardian about the Ill claim last thing.

Make that,

Guardian-Rishi-Crub-Ssf.

I think of the 1st two are scum. so we'll see.

You suspected Guardian and Crub before. What's changed?

Welll, I changed, but I still think Guardian is scummy. I wont vote yet though. You are kind of "Emanating" a "Too Townie" Glow from me.. But some say that is bad logic.

[somestrangeflea]

I would be okay with a Rishi-Crub-Guardian-somestrangeflea order. I don't mind going first. Why is Guardian so reluctant to go early?

I am town. I know that when I claim, I will not be lying. It is in the town's best interests for me to go last.

It doesn't matter how you word it, you can't use "I'm Townie" as a reason that you should claim last, simply because everyone else can use that reasoning as well!

You

and

Crub agreed with my ordering, and that was my original and only reason. Why the change in opinion?


I am still waiting on YB for meaningful content...

I don't mind the ordering, it doesn't seem too bad to me. I just don't like your reasoning behind it.

[Guardian]

YB -- too townie

is

bad logic. If you find me scummy, that's fine. But if you find me scummy because I am looking "too townie"... then you aren't finding me scummy, you are finding me townlike. Also, those posts with quotes that you promised us...?


SSF, et. al -- I am fine with going third, as at least two of you prefer it. The point is the ordering is supposed to be reflective of who the town finds suspicious. I find myself least suspicious, so I wanted to go last. However, you disagree, so I will go third.


Rishi, you are up, claim cop with result on someone alive, or not cop with result on someone alive. Then Crub, then me, then SSF.

[Rishi]

SSF, et. al -- I am fine with going third, as at least two of you prefer it. The point is the ordering is supposed to be reflective of who the town finds suspicious. I find myself least suspicious, so I wanted to go last. However, you disagree, so I will go third.

Wow. that's horrible logic. EVERYONE finds themselves the least suspicious. Like we're going to take your word for it...

Rishi, you are up, claim cop with result on someone alive, or not cop with result on someone alive. Then Crub, then me, then SSF.

Are we fully claiming, or just Cop and Not Cop?

Doesn't matter. I'm just a vanilla townie. Crub, you're next.

[somestrangeflea]

Pretty much yeah, we have 2 possible claims:

• Vanilla Townie
• Cop with result on any living player

Crub, you're up.

[Rishi]

Pretty much yeah, we have 2 possible claims:

• Vanilla Townie
• Cop with result on any living player

Crub, you're up.

Well, a doctor is possible in this setup. If someone is a doctor, should they not claim it?

[somestrangeflea]

Yeah, but it was decided... somewhere that they shouldn't.

[somestrangeflea]

Clicky!

[Rishi]

Ah.. okay.

EBWOP: I claim that I am not the cop.

[YogurtBandit]

I mewant RIshi was acting Too Townie Guardian, not you.l

[Guardian]

I'm not saying that YogurtBandit isn't suspicious, but I really think that the last Mafia has to be somestrangeflea or YogurtBandit and we have two chances to lynch.

I just re-read the thread, and I get the same feeling. You guys have no assurance that I am town other than my play, but I know I am town -- and so I

know

that someone bussed their scum-partner day one.

I re-read the game, and HH FoSing SSF seems kind of forced now to me -- SSF FoS'd him back too, and did not vote until later. If YB is not scum, either SSF, Rishi, or Crub bussed HH day one.

Crub I don't think did it, because his vote was on from so early and for so long, it just seems unlikely.

Rishi, I think is also unlikely to have been busing - he hammered. His play has also been townlike.

SSF, one the other hand, didn't want to get on, and then got on for weak reasons to make HH lynch -1. Also, as Rishi noted, seemed like he was trying to slow the game down to not lynch his partner... Eh, maybe I am reading that wrong though.

Really, I think YB is very very much most likely to be the play today, and if he is not scum whoever is left alive will have a tough choice tomorrow.


YB, I am getting impatient. You have until Tuesday evening to make the quote filled posts and cases you have promised us, or you will be getting my vote. I repeat, if you are town, and fail to defend yourself, you are doing us all a great disservice...


Crub -- claim, cop with result or not cop with result.

[Crub]

I am not a cop with a result. Flea you're up

Sorry about my absence the past few days I'm too much of a Harry Potter nerd.

[Guardian]

I am also not a cop with a result. I wanted to go last so no one could lie before me, as they'd have to wonder if I was a cop. Oh well.

Flea, you're last.


Crub, no problem, I can definitely understand that .

[somestrangeflea]

I am not cop with a result.

[/claim]

Ah Harry Potter! =D

[Guardian]

I didn't want to say this until we went through with it, but I had a nagging suspicion that this was going to result in there being no cop. After all that, lol!

Anyways, well done guys on the claiming... YB, you have some 'splaining to do.

[Rishi]

I really had a feeling there was no cop. If someone had claimed cop, I would have suspected a fake claim. I actually wouldn't be surprised if we didn't have a doctor either. I think we might have gotten the all-vanilla setup. Of course, it's hard to say. Scum haven't been hitting the most obvious target and so it could have been tough for the doctor to predict.

[Crub]

So YB is this post with quotes coming soon?

[Rishi]

Well, Guardian gave YogurtBandit an ultimatum to post a thoughtful, intelligent post by Tuesday evening, or YogurtBandit gets his vote. That seems fair to me.