Mokina wrote:No matter who the cop is, they should take into account the possibility of sanity issues. CES's reasoning makes a lot of sense, admittedly. Pointing it out would be very protown if he wasn't expecting a roleclaim.
Except he is. He wants the entire thread to know the cop's identity, and that's a rather scummy motive.
FoS: CES
Thanks for outing yourself as kilmenator's partner.
Why the frick would CES want the
whole thread
to know the cop's identity?
Wouldn't that key in the doctor to who the cop is? That, it seems to me, would be
bad
for scum. Now, I am in no way suggesting the cop should out themselves or drop hints or anything at this point (for all we know, the scum have a roleblocker, see prior argument re: directing the vig). Yet it seems the manner in which CES did it is decidedly
not
more likely to come from scum than town - note that he asked only one person, and even gave them an out and said they didn't have to answer. (Besides, scum hunt for cops at night with their buddies, not during the day, as they
don't
want the town to know who the cop is.) This attack is weak, opportunistic, and merely posing as scum-hunting. (I also thought the sanity-issues line was a pre-emptive attack on a power role, which is also scummy.)
Unvote: kilmenator, Vote: Mokina.
I'd vote kilmenator to avoid a no-lynch, but I'm more certain of Mokina.
I am 1000% against a CES lynch today.