Mini 414-Anime Mafia | GAME OVAH!

[Skruffs]

Yama, I've been at odds with you through most of the game - as you probably are aware. Most of my real suspicion of you - and everyone - is from the responses to Mert's and Zu Faul's claims yesterday. That is a gold mine.

A shanba/SV/Yamahako endgame. This will be awesome to watch.

[Yamahako]

Yama, I've been at odds with you through most of the game - as you probably are aware. Most of my real suspicion of you - and everyone - is from the responses to Mert's and Zu Faul's claims yesterday. That is a gold mine.

A shanba/SV/Yamahako endgame. This will be awesome to watch.

You've been suspicious to me the whole game too, I think its our play styles :-/ I was looking forward to building a case against you until Mert told us the innocent investigation. I even misread his statement at first because I was so sure you were scum :-/ "He's an innocent investigation immune townie" heh

I'll vote ZF after Shanba you and SV say its ok to continue.

PS:

Mod

If mert is insane - I hate you.

[Skruffs]

I wish town the best of luck for tomorrow!
Here is the game, right before Thrawn mis-claimed.
I would suggest everyone read up and look at each other with all their logical abilities.

[zu_Faul]

Don't lynch me, I'm doc! That's what UT hinted at Day 1, but it was hard to claim doc, when the Doc was lynched, and I couldn't even claim repalcement as the replacement was killed night 1.

[Yamahako]

Don't lynch me, I'm doc! That's what UT hinted at Day 1, but it was hard to claim doc, when the Doc was lynched, and I couldn't even claim repalcement as the replacement was killed night 1.

oh, in that case we should all just not vote you to day...

So, we ready to lynch ZF? or do people still want to weigh in today before night?

[Shanba]

I'm ready for what tomorrow may bring. Although, I probably won't be here >.< (see my sig, and I'm really sorry IH).

[Skruffs]

I'm ready. SV?

[spectrumvoid]

I'm fine.

Bye scum!

[Yamahako]

Vote ZF

OK

[Skruffs]

MUAHAHA TOWN LOSES!

[Shanba]

My heart skipped a beat, before I remembered it wasn't possible because I wasn't scum with you.

Bastard.

[zu_Faul]

I really am Doc.

[Skruffs]

Shanba?
Who are you scum with?

[IH]

Zu faul looks around, growling slightly, backed into a corner.

He reaches into his belt..... and pulls out a small orb, half red and half white.

"Go pikachu, I choose y-"

Which is as far as he got, as I then promptly dispatched of him.

Zu Faul-Pokemon, Mafia Doc

Has been killed.

NIGHT 4 HITS NOW!

[IH]

You are all jerked awake in the middle of the night to the sound of a loud guitar noise. Obviously a fight is occuring once more. The riffs continue in an increasing crescendo, up and up and up, and right as the music begins to hit it's climax, it is suddenly cut short.

You head over to inspect it in the morning, and there is

Spectrumvoid-FLCL, Townie

lying in a pool of blood, her guitar laying beside her, a bandage on her forehead

DAY 5 IS GO!

With 3 alive it is 2 to lynch!

[Skruffs]

Gah.
This is completely unexpected.
And.. awkward.

[Shanba]

That is a bizarre nk.

Geh. I hate you both. One of you is scum. I'm really stuck as to which one. SV nk makes no sense, for either of you. Skruffs still being alive is what throws me, I mean, this should be an easy choice, but I'm hardwired to distrust easy choices when they're presented so nicely in front of me.

All the circumstantial evidence points to Yama. I mean, in a setup with a mafia doc and a mafia rber, how likely is a gf too? It says something that this is a difficult choice for me. Or perhaps I'm just being OMGUSsy with regards to Skruffs. I'll have to check my reasoning there and see if it makes sense.

OTOH, why the heck would Yama kill SV? Unless he thought Skruffs was more likely to kill me. WIFOMing night choices ftl. I need to clear my had. But I'm going on holiday in two days. Really sorry about that. Actually, though, it's probably just as well: I have an atrocious endgame record. [joke]Maybe you could get Primate or something to replace me and we would have a guaranteed win.[/joke]

[Skruffs]

???
I would never kill SV, but that's metagaming.
If Yama thought I was more likely to kill you, and he was scum, wouldn't he try to kill you?
I really wasn't expecting to be here, this may be my first three person endgame.
shanba, hopefully we'll have it done in two days or less. how long are you gone for?
If you guys vote, vote each other. especially if you are townie. I'm not completely cleared, btu i'm a lot more cleared than either of you.
Was anyone still alive voting mert with zu faul?

[Shanba]

That post was not written at my most awake state. Also, it was very much stream of consciousness. Neither was this one, tbh.

Yah, that's why I'm wary of WIFOMing the nightkill.

I'm gone for three weeks.

TBH, thinking about it, it doesn't even matter if you're scum: there's no way I could convince Yama to vote

I don't believe anyone was voting for Mert, though I'd have to double check. I know neither you or I were.

[Yamahako]

Wow... just... wow.

I have no idea what to think - I was really expecting Skruffs to die and I was going to have to figure out wether I thought Shanba or SV was scum, and I was leaning toward SV...

But Skruffs is still alive... is it WIFOM, or is he a Godfather?

I'm trying to see the angle here... but I just can't see it - unless Skruffs is the Godfather...

This is going to be a lot more work for me

My thought was if I died tonight Skruffs had to be Godfather... And that otherwise Skruffs was the only logical choice.

But then again, if someone thought they had a better chance in the end game with SV dead, then maybe Skruffs innocence wouldn't have been a problem...

Which would lead me to think Shanba - since it wouldn't be hard for Skruffs to vote me and he could end it... But given my post against SV wouldn't it have been just as easy to get me to vote SV?

ARGH!

More later

[Skruffs]

Scum gambited hard in keeping me alive. I do give whoever killed SV kudos for doing the unexpected. But they've effectively lowered their chances of winning from 66% to 50% in doing so.
Both of you seem to be suspicious that I'm a godfather. But one of you is mimicking the other. There's also a very high (100%) chance that I really am a townie. Usually someone pushing that a townie might be a godfather is scum. That's a theorem to think of.
It's time to reread.

Mod

- What's going to happen with Shanba?

[Skruffs]

Shanba's post seem to have scummy mistakes in them, but Yama's is just so outright scummy. Let's *all* reread.

I can *promise* that I am town, to whatever extent you want me to. And I don't make promises very often.

[Shanba]

Alright. I can't see myself changing my mind before tomorrow when I leave on holiday, so I'll leave my vote and my reasoning and Skruffs will hopefully make the right choice.

Vote: Yamahako

Have a look through Yamahako's posting history. Look for mentions, specifcally, of the other two scum.

Post 8: He accuses thrawn of OMGUS, at the same time that he attacks thrawn's attacker, and doesn't FoS or vote either of them, choosing instead to keep his vote on Skruffs because he defended cubsfan's "fishing".

Post 15: he questions UT's vote on him, and then

ignores him for a further 30 posts

, or until well into day 2. In fact, he doesn't mention either scum in that perios of time, choosing instead to focus on Skruffs.

Post 45, 46 and 47: He offers a defence of UT's lurking, then chooses to ignore him again. Knowing as we do now that UT was a mafia doc, that seems pretty damning to me.

Post 49: He FoSses Thrawn for a very weak reason. It seems more like a "stop doing that" post than an accusation.

Post 54: Again defends UT.

Post 55: And again, though he makes sure to say that he isn't defending him

Post 58: FoSses Thrawn (mafia rber) for voting OTU/UT/Zu (mafia doc). Again he defends UT, giving him an out if he wants to claim townie

Posts 59-62: indicates he wants Zu to claim first, despite indicating before that he could well be town. I hate how he keeps repeating that he might just be a townie, not a power role. It seems like a pre-emptive defence for Zu's townie claim. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if Yama specifically told him to claim townie.

Post 65: Defends Zu

Again

(albeit against my craplogic).

Post 71: Does not actually make sense: he quotes Skruffs saying he was worried that continuing with the claims would allow a townie to be lynched and says he agrees whereas just a few posts ago he had said that he wanted to finish the massclaim.

Post 74: Defends UT

Again

Post 75: Says he is considering voting Mert instead of Zu Faul, even, because of a semantic slip in Mert's claim!

Post 76: Finally attacks Zu_faul, after defending him many, many times, only after a cop has found him guilty.

I hate the way he butters up Skruffs in post 80, after he was cleared by the cop.

After that he attacks both me and SV: he seems very much to be weighing up both options and seeing which one would be easiest. After I defend myself, he turns on SV. That doesn't quite fit with the nk, but both Skruffs and I had said we though SV was unlikely scum.

I want now to go back to day 1. He votes for and FoSses Jack, Skruffs, cubsfan, AndrewS and HD. None of them scum. He's certainly not being cautious. And yet despite attacking Thrawn over OMGUS and questioning ut's vote for him, he never FoSses or votes either of them that day.

[Skruffs]

Velly nice.
(doesn't hammer)

[Shanba]

phew. Well, at least I made the right choice. I still had doubts, even as I was writing that.