In post 135, Save The Dragons wrote:I'm bothered by malakittens's language; there's a giddy confidence in there (like Light from Death Note, or I guess early books Queen Cersei)
Like something like this is almost dismissive:
In post 118, Malakittens wrote:I'm not really sure why, but I don't like this, although, it's not where it's super scummy persay. It just might be because some players, such as me, believe we are out of RVS so trying to draw back in feels off. Is there any comments that you would like to make in regards of current happenings in thread?
I keep coming back to this, perhaps I believe in the sanctity of RVS, a happy place where you can come in and throw your vote down while you're getting your bearings in the game without fear of being harangued...okay I'm being overly dramatic, but I suppose I fail to see how one person RVSing is going to successfully draw us back into the RVS.
I might have been a little passive-aggressive towards Fench, but my question was a legitimate question to her read. Fenc already commented on it, but last time we played was Wicked and she caught a small, glimpse of what a good Mala-scum game can be like. I was kinda thinking in my head is she scum reading me for being bitter about that loss (yes it can be a thing because I have done this in the past) or does she actually find something scummy in my posts.
I always analyze RVS after a scum flip to try to eliminate players as potential partners or try to see who is a potential partners. Scum like to stay in RVS-stage because they can follick and play in the fields and coast while keeping minimum suspicion on them. (btw I'm kidding about the follicking and playing in the fields). Boons has a kind of a play that amounts to being a jokey jester at times (<3uBoon) so I'm trying to engage him so he doesn't fall into old habits, but with recent posts I don't think it helped much. I just want him to contribute, to give thoughts. Which he has in regards to his read on Pie and gives me insight to how's he's trying to sort players etc.
In post 143, Fenchurch wrote:Updated reads list:
SleepyKrew - maybe town
Micc - maybe town
Dragons - maybe town
Pieguy - maybe town
Thor - could go either way
Mala - maybe scum
jason - maybe scum
not being read yet:
Egg
Trojan Horse
sthar
Delta
Boon
Is there a way my read and the read on micc being connected? Are you trying to draw connections pre:flip or are they not connected?
In post 147, Boonskiies wrote:@sthr - Pie and I have never had a game where one of us weren't scum. We've been partners even before. I tunnel her hard. Everytime. She can catch me out as scum like a [insert ridiculous comparison here]. This is just a page 6 read for me, so not too much merit to it, but it is worth paying attention to.
Interesting. I'm liking this read on Pie based on interactions. This isn't something scum would say I don't think.
In post 149, pieguyn wrote: In post 137, Malakittens wrote:Again he hasn't posted. I already commented on his said posts that I disagreed with. I mean I would be more proactive if he actually posted...? Your chainsaw defense is noted though Pie.
Town can misrep AND scum can misrep. If I see a misrep I point it out. I'm not really sure if you are town or scum at this point, but your general posts so far aren't the greatest. You are sitting here defending the shit out of Micc, while attacking his attacker.
:/
I think Micc had a fair amount of content in between the post where you pushed him and your later posts. however, I admit I may be being too harsh there.
my aim is moreso to attack your logic than defend Micc per se; I don't have a read on Micc. either way, I don't feel as strongly as I did before about you being scum. soooooooo
where are you currently at with Fen and Thor?
Well it seemed like you were doing a bit of both from my angle. Micc had less then 3 posts from his P1 which didn't show him doing anything, but sheeping a P1 case. I mean yes he questioned STD a bit and Jason, but he flat out ignored me. He could have said something, but did nothing. Like I said I want to wait and see what he's currently thinking with current happenings. My read might change, but we'll see.
Well, the only person so far who's said anything in regards to this game was Iec. He didn't say much in regards to Thor and I hold Thor on a pedestal. I have maybe a three-person list on ms whom I do this too. I will play this dance, dance game with my emotions in regards to them, but actually pushing my emotions on paper never happens. He happens to be someone whom I think of as a good scum/town player so if I was ever wrong and mislynched him I'd feel bad. (I know it's crazy.)
I'd be interested in a Fench vote, but it would come after I made a case though. Iec made a comment last night and after this morning rereading it again and her posts I'm seeing it.
I'd be okay with a Jason vote too maybe. It seems like Jason is going after what I feel is more of a policy lynch rather than feeling someone is scum. It's giving me this horrible vibe. He's done it directly with SK, while ignoring Delta, and now he's doing it with Boonskiies. I'm having a hard time he's believing what he's actually saying IMO.
In post 150, Fenchurch wrote: In post 118, Malakittens wrote:I'd be interested in this "scumread" you got on me actually. If you could flesh that out it would be grand.
sthar8 wrote:@fen- do you feel like expounding on any of your other reads?
Mostly it's gut, and/or a couple of small things and the rest of the posts either fit with or don't contradict that read. e.g. Dragons - enthusiastic and seems to be enjoying himself. pieguy - getting reads from team, etc.
The last (and only) game I've played with Mala was Wicked, where she won as scum to my town. Reading through the scum-thread after the game, I felt it should have been a lot more obvious - the way her actual feelings as scum occasionally affected her play in the game. I kinda got the same sense from her opening posts here, that there was a bit of a facade maybe.
Sorry that's not very specific though, when I have time (tomorrow) I'll do a re-read and try and elaborate more.
Oh and SleepyKrew, CES says that Trojan is town so you don't need to worry about reading him
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile")
Well this game and that game are different. There's only like a few players I have major experience in playing with {Pie, Thor, Boons, Micc} whereas everyone else I might have played one game with or not at all. And even then Boons is more from F2F mafia and Micc I played maybe two newbies games with. Wicked half the playerlist I talked to on a daily basis so it's more common that I'd be sad to be playing against friends and having to fabricate cases and push them to get them lynched, when in fact as town, I liked working with them and solving the game. You're basically comparing an apple to an orange.
I still don't see how you could be seeing the same feelings when in fact this is a different situation as a whole.
In post 159, Trojan Horse wrote: In post 128, pieguyn wrote:
I'll go through it in detail later tonight. does Tammy have a town read on him?
Not a solid town read yet, but she seems to be leaning in that direction. She thinks she can get a solid read on Jason, but it may take some time. She isn't bothered by Jason's multiple-vote opening post.
She also likes your suspicion of mala. I'm going to take a closer look...
<: Tammy always thinks I'm scum though!
