SMITE Role Madness Mafia (OVER AT LAST!)

[FourTrouble]

@ FT, I wrote the above text which I think you mistakenly quoted Heartless on.

Mafiascum glitched. I meant to quote Heartless's reply to your text. I didn't edit the quote so I dunno what happened there.

[FourTrouble]

And also, when I say I'm not surprised Pere flipped scum, it doesn't mean I thought he was scum -- I had no idea what he was. I was waiting for him to post more, because I have a couple markers for town Pere that I look for.

[FourTrouble]

F-16, you prefer Beast to TD?

[ZZZX]

K so I decided I'll do a full pbpA for one player this week. Who should I do it for?

[Cephrir]

Don't waste your time on pointless exercises -.-

[vezokpiraka]

i don't recall a sphincteritis about voting from EITHER ffery or f16 in games i've played w/ them.

ffery

What games have YOU been playing?

Also, I believe those TD posts could still come from scum, yes. But you will notice that I am voting for beastcharizard! Half the players in this game have someone vouching for them; I don't think this one is anything but a read and I don't especially trust TSO here anyway. Furthermore, Magua is also in that neighborhood (IIRC? Well anyway SOMEONE is) and I haven't seen them expressing similar feelings that I recall.

Seriously? Me, Magua and TSO have all vouched for beast and gave reasons, but somehow you forgot.

[Metal Sonic]

3 players have to be replaced

[mastin2]

K so I decided I'll do a full pbpA for one player this week. Who should I do it for?

Hey, ZX, know that whole "one or two exceptions" I was talking about?

A full pbpA is probably a good example of a fair exception.
If you do it for just one player, sure, in here is fine.
If you do it for every player, then it'd probably be best to do it in the PT, and present the important highlights in-thread since that amount of spam is, well...spam.

If you do it, your decision where it goes, of course.

[farside22]

Prod-dodge

I'm kind of in and out of this game because I see people going off track of scum hunting and some things I feel lost.

[T S O]

How come our neighbourhood's protection on Beast isn't seen as relevant yet mastin's doing the same to multiple people and it is?

[ZZZX]

K so I decided I'll do a full pbpA for one player this week. Who should I do it for?

Hey, ZX, know that whole "one or two exceptions" I was talking about?

A full pbpA is probably a good example of a fair exception.
If you do it for just one player, sure, in here is fine.
If you do it for every player, then it'd probably be best to do it in the PT, and present the important highlights in-thread since that amount of spam is, well...spam.

If you do it, your decision where it goes, of course.

Makes sense..

[T S O]

I mean, if we're going on correctness of reads, I was somewhat right on AP and wrong on Pere, whereas mastin was wrong on AP and also wrong on Pere iirc.

[Cephrir]

i don't recall a sphincteritis about voting from EITHER ffery or f16 in games i've played w/ them.

ffery

What games have YOU been playing?

Also, I believe those TD posts could still come from scum, yes. But you will notice that I am voting for beastcharizard! Half the players in this game have someone vouching for them; I don't think this one is anything but a read and I don't especially trust TSO here anyway. Furthermore, Magua is also in that neighborhood (IIRC? Well anyway SOMEONE is) and I haven't seen them expressing similar feelings that I recall.

Seriously? Me, Magua and TSO have all vouched for beast and gave reasons, but somehow you forgot.

Well, your reasoning must not have been very good or I'd remember it.

How come our neighbourhood's protection on Beast isn't seen as relevant yet mastin's doing the same to multiple people and it is?

Because mastin says they're 100% town for sure, and had better have amazing reasons to back that up. She's accountable. If this turns out to be wrong she'll look incredibly stupid.

You guys are just using "reads" as far as I can tell. Or things about "scum wouldn't have vote manipulation powers" which given that there are at least 6 or so of those in the setup, I'm gonna go ahead and disagree with.

[Metal Sonic]

wanted to same something snarky to tso but decided not to.

so my response is

"whatever cephrir said"

[Metal Sonic]

btw if all 3 picks by farside are town i will be

rather upset

[farside22]

btw if all 3 picks by farside are town i will be

rather upset

I would be too.

I don't believe 4 is town atm. But everyone seems to be ignoring the points against him and pushing his day 1 play more.

[farside22]

And I don't see why td is a town read either.

Go back to one wagon I'll support over the other

Vote: FourTrouble

[FourTrouble]

farside, why do you think I'm scum?

[FourTrouble]

I'm trying to piece together the neighborhoods. Can someone who's been taking notes on this please help.

This is what I have so far:

1. Solar, Imperium, TD.
2. Mastin, ZZZX, and Xombie.
3. TSO, Beast, Vezok.
4. Metal, Skybird, TWIE
5. Farside, Ankamius, Pere, me.

What are the others?

[FourTrouble]

I have Mask/AP in the same neighborhood, and Ceph/Heartless in the same neighborhood.

Is our neighborhood the only 4 person neighborhood?

[FourTrouble]

And Magua is in the hood with Metal?

[Cephrir]

Ceph/ooba/Heartless/Rach.

[Imperium]

Add

1) bitmap
3) magua

Mask/ap/aceofspades

[Imperium]

How come our neighbourhood's protection on Beast isn't seen as relevant yet mastin's doing the same to multiple people and it is?

You guys protection basically boils down to too stupid to be scum, didn't fake claim (something that couldn't be fake claimed), explained role calmly - a role that doesn't make him town, and that's about it.

If there's something special about his role that makes him town, might as well out it.

[farside22]

Four: your comments about Pere is pretty fake. Plus I've prodded you to post in the pt but you don't come in or try to figure anyone out in the pt.