New York 180 (Endgame)

[Boonskiies]

I'm not believing his claim, btw.

[Grib]

Is he annoying, or scum?

[Boonskiies]

Both. He brought up the fact that I'm lurking as a scum read, when he only has like 3 posts more than me. Granted, I know I'm not being very active at the moment, but that's not alignment indicative at all for me at this point. Him and I were back and forth when he did his claim also. He had like two votes on him, and I believe I explained why I think it's fake.

[Boonskiies]

Okay, absolutely no reason to claim that right now? Pho hohoho look guys. I'm a tracker. Look guys I'm a vig. I'm a doctor. Look, cop! Way too easy to slip under the radar as scum by you claiming now, and it's in a way you can still change your claim later.

Also, why would anyone counterclaim anything on day 1 when we've already had multiple claims. That's stupid.

Here.

[Boonskiies]

It's like if I were to say I was a doctor or something. No one would really have any reason to believe it, and a CC at this point would be stupid.

[Boonskiies]

No one has any real reason to believe it, but it also causes confusion and will stop people from lynching them.

[Grib]

Well, for one, if scum claims a town PR that's in play, the other one CC's and we have a scumlynch.

We all know ABR has a scummy towngame in the early Days, is there anything that points to something more out of the ordinary?

[Boonskiies]

I've never played with him. Him and I don't know each other. But from what I'm hearing, him and I have super duper super epic early super scummy days when we're town. I just can't confirm that on his part due to never seeing it.

[Boonskiies]

I also don't like the way I've been his main target for reasons why he should be his own target.

[SilverWolf]

Kitz: Naked jogger, House [L-9]
FA_Q2: Cheetory6 [L-10]
T S O: Jared615 [L-10]
acryon: Shinobi [L-10]
Elusive: dragonspawn, Pisskop [L-9]
Klingoncelt: Aeronaut, TSO, SilverWolf, FA_Q2, vikingfan [L-5]
ABR: kitz, Boonskiies [L-9]
Boonskies: elusive, ABR [L-9]
House: Klingoncelt [L-9]

Not voting: Wake88, Grib, Nobody Special

21 alive, 11 to lynch

(expired on 2015-02-22 00:00:00)

I readjusted the vc to match up to current votes. The timer is on countdown. I think we can all agree we don't want a NL. I am very wary of putting anyone else within claiming range.

Boon-I'm not lynching a claimed tracker. Someone can check him to see if he's lying anyway. Let's move on.

[ika]

Ellie replaces jared615

[Ellie]

I am now part of this game.

[Boonskiies]

Can someone explain the Klingon case?

[Ellie]

VOTE: ABR

[FakedBlogger]

I am now part of this game.

Fucking brilliant entrance

[House]

I'm not talking about anything other than what a casual observer can see.

I read lots of ongoing games here, btw. Good way to get to know people.

For reading so many games, you sure seem ignorant of the fact that ongoing games are not to be discussed in any capacity whatsoever.

[FakedBlogger]

Can someone explain the Klingon case?

The Klingon case is something you want us to invest in so we get swayed to vote Klingon instead of you and your obvscumfuck buddies.

[House]

acryon

* - leantown, seems to be actively figure out the game

Kitz

- enigma, she's hard for me to read. She fooled me in our last game together, so I'm trying to be careful here.

Naked jogger

- townlean, I've liked most of his posts, but unsure why he's pushing Boonskiies and not ABR.

Shinobi

- Null. I find him hard to get a bead on, and have mislynched him in the past.

Pisskop

- townlean, I like his pushes, and he seems to be trying to solve the game.

dragonspawn

- townlean, he's more manipulative as scum; his deliberately scummy towngame just feels a bit forced, but I think it's an intentional strategy.

Klingoncelt

- null, I find it hard to read KC in the early game.

SilverWolf

- Pretty sure she's town, she's playing to her textbook town game, her scum game is way different. She's paranoid and actively trying to scumhunt. Scumwolf is lurky & manipulative.

elusive

- townlean for not pushing me to share my reads publicly when I mentioned having them noted elsewhere; would have expected scum!elusive to use that post to push/vote me

Grib

- This feels very much like a Grib town game. I may be biased here though, as I have only seen one Grib scum game, and it wasn't like a typical MS game.

Wake88

- Null, haven't seen nearly enough to sort him.

Aeronaut

- Still kinda leaning scum here. Post 97 is of particular concern, it feels like he's making excuses for being on mislynch wagons.

T S O

- Leaning town, but I'd like to know his read and reasons on Boonskies to shore up that read.

Cheetory6

- Null. Not seeing what I want to out of Cheetory for a townread. He's a clever player, and I'm wary.

Ellie

- Null, nothing to read her on other than jared's statement that I made a good case on viking but not even voting for him.

Boonskiies

* - Not interested in a D1 lynch for Boonskiies. My first game with him, and I'd hate to see him go on the first day before I can actually sort him.

ABR

- Scum. I haven't really been noticing ABR, and his ISO is terribad. Naked votes, bad pushes, and posting just enough to avoid prodding.

FA_Q2

- townlean, his early game was laid back. He seems comfortable, which FA doesn't seem to be so laid back as scum. That's not enough for a solid read, though. For example, if dragon were to actually flip scum (which I doubt), 577 looks like crosstalk/coaching.

vikingfan

- town, pending counterclaim.

VOTE: ABR

Contribute or swing, ABR.

[ika]

I have been trying to be lenient but enough is enough, next person to even say anything regarding ongoings gets modkilled.

IF SOMEONE SAYS SOMETHING ABOUT AN ONGOING YOU DO NOT TALK ANY FURTHER.

You are to PM me

[SilverWolf]

Why do you guys want to lynch a claimed tracker? Can you at least explain that to me so I understand it?

[House]

Why do you guys want to lynch a claimed tracker? Can you at least explain that to me so I understand it?

God my memory is shit. I even remember discussing that.

ABR's my scummiest read, I mean shit, look at them. What would you do in this case?

UNVOTE:

Fucking *sigh*.

[Ellie]

I've never played a large normal. What are the odds we have both a tracker and a cop?

[House]

Oh well, back to ol' reliable, I guess.

VOTE: Aeronaut

[Ellie]

Research says the odds are "good"

[FakedBlogger]

UNVOTE:

I like Kitz's last post and agree with her townreads (although they'd be more accurate if I were on it, just sayin').

What exactly do you like about it. The AtE, the strawman, the newbie card play or the fact that she hasn't provided any argumentation for her reads?