The argument which I said makes sense was the one about Lawrencelot not being the jester if he was not lynched the day 1. This has nothing to do with why I think you are scummy:
Lawrencelot wrote:Gorc is the jester. Let's assume this until someone else becomes more Jester-like.
Vote: Sir Tornado
And, I had said on page 2 (post 28):
Sir Tornado wrote:Ok, let us get this moving.
As far as I am concerned:
Scum = Lawrencelot and gorckat
Jester = YogurtBandit
The list is subjected to be changed many times in the future.
Then, you have a lot of JDodge posts like these:
JDodge wrote:More BS.
Your entire theory revolves around telling the scum what to do. I would not kill Lawrence in that situation if I were scum.
Besides, you can just tell yourself and Lawrence what to do at night anyways, no need to drag it out into the daytime.
JDodge wrote:I voted no-lynch because I didn't think gorckat was a good lynch choice.
Now I do.
Vote: gorckat
JDodge wrote:Sir Tornado wrote:JDodge wrote:I care not to tell at the moment.
Why not?
Because it will mess up my strategy, of course.
I know you aren't the jester, gorck. Otherwise it would be stupid to be voting you.
JDodge wrote:Nothing.
But you're making me happier with my vote with every sentence.
He was after you. So, you took him out. Any more obvious?
And, finally, your own slip:
gorckat wrote:JDodge-
if
I'm town, what does that prove that lynching Lawrence does not?
Now, I would like to draw everyone's attention to my post:
181
(day 1) where I said:
Sir Tornado wrote:No lynch?
And, exactly where does the No-Lynch lead us to?
If we do not lynch anyone today, then what we do on day 2 would be more or less determined by the NK, which the scum controls.
If we lynch someone, we can go on to day 2 based on the identity of the person we have lynched and the NK.
I believe, as I had said somewhere on page 2 that Gorckat and Lawrencelot are the scum, and am willing to take responsibility for either of their lynches (in other words, if they go bad, you can lynch me tomorrow -- no, before anyone asks, I am NOT the Jester)
Well, that still stands.