Open 27- Bird C9 (Game over!) before 466

[Aimee]

I want to hear more from Barmacral and Fernando, definitely.

Cephrir, spectrumvoid needs a prod. From her absense in other games, I am pretty sure that she is currently not here - she hasn't posted in a while in any games - so I definitely don't think it is strategic lurking from her part.

[ryan]

Any reason for you still being voteless?

[Barmacral]

Ah Ha! I do have a few minutes before I head out, well, here's my response:

Sure. Innocent.

Claiming "innocent" doesn't really do much for me, since barring extreme stupidity every player in this game would claim "innocent" if asked whether they were innocent or guilty.

Obviously. But, provided that I did have a role of any sort, do you really think I would reveal it? As it happens, I AM innocent, but it was a dumb question, and an obvious response to the question.

I do hate random votes, but you asked for one, so I gave it to you.

Um, "but you asked for one" isn't an explanation, it's a cop-out. What convinced you to cast a random vote despite your personal dislike of the concept?[/quote]

I was somewhat aggrevated by some RL issues that day. My frustration led to that. Its not a cop-out, its exactly what I said it was. However, as spectrumvoid is still not here, I'm going to keep my vote on him, as I am interested in his unexplained absense.

[Aimee]

Barma and everyone, Mr. Flay commented in a game that SV is modding that "spectrumvoid doesn't have everyday access to the site at the moment", so again, I don't think this is a deliberate lurk, so to speak (she is absent from all her newbie modding games).

[ryan]

Aimee: I noticed him in another thread that I was looking at the same thing. I'd say our best bet for now is to look at the people who are able to post and judge them that way.

[FeRnAnDo]

sorry, sorry for not adding too much content... that nonsense post about football was made because it was late on the night and i logged on mafiascum expecting some good read... then got bored a wrote that stuff

I just noticed Barmacal has only 33 game posts, 7 less than me. he may not be used to pressure... in my first game, due to pressure, i sent a pm to a player saying i was COP and that got me modkilled, i don't blame him... but that doesn't mean he's townie, since not voting is really weird.

And Tarhalindur spitting out votes all over really made me raise an eyebrown.

[Cephrir]

Vote Count

Barmacral 1 (Tarhalindur)
spectrumvoid 1 (Barmacral)
Enlightened Bystander 1 (FeRnAnDo)
ryan 1 (Enlightened Bystander)
Aimee 1 (spectrumvoid)
FeRnAnDo 1 (ryan)

Not Voting 1 (Aimee)

SV has been prodded.

[spectrumvoid]

mod + everyone

Sorry... I was hospitalised for dengue fever and dehydration. I wanted to leave a note somewhere but my brother swears he couldn't post because he didn't register.

[ryan]

mod + everyone

Sorry... I was hospitalised for dengue fever and dehydration. I wanted to leave a note somewhere but my brother swears he couldn't post because he didn't register.

Hope things are better for you

[Tarhalindur]

Ah Ha! I do have a few minutes before I head out, well, here's my response:

Sure. Innocent.

Claiming "innocent" doesn't really do much for me, since barring extreme stupidity every player in this game would claim "innocent" if asked whether they were innocent or guilty.

Obviously. But, provided that I did have a role of any sort, do you really think I would reveal it? As it happens, I AM innocent, but it was a dumb question, and an obvious response to the question.

I do hate random votes, but you asked for one, so I gave it to you.

Um, "but you asked for one" isn't an explanation, it's a cop-out. What convinced you to cast a random vote despite your personal dislike of the concept?

I was somewhat aggrevated by some RL issues that day. My frustration led to that. Its not a cop-out, its exactly what I said it was. However, as spectrumvoid is still not here, I'm going to keep my vote on him, as I am interested in

hi

s unexplained absense.[/quote]

Wait a minute, how did I not notice this before? SV is female! Lynch All Liars!

[ryan]

sorry, sorry for not adding too much content... that nonsense post about football was made because it was late on the night and i logged on mafiascum expecting some good read... then got bored a wrote that stuff

I just noticed Barmacal has only 33 game posts, 7 less than me. he may not be used to pressure... in my first game, due to pressure, i sent a pm to a player saying i was COP and that got me modkilled, i don't blame him... but that doesn't mean he's townie, since not voting is really weird.

And Tarhalindur spitting out votes all over really made me raise an eyebrown.

I actually don't mind people shuffling votes around getting the quiet players talking, right now we are dragging some serious butt and need to get some people moving along when it comes to posting

[Cephrir]

Enlightened Bystander is entering prod range soon.

[ryan]

I want to hear more from Barmacral and Fernando, definitely.

Cephrir, spectrumvoid needs a prod. From her absense in other games, I am pretty sure that she is currently not here - she hasn't posted in a while in any games - so I definitely don't think it is strategic lurking from her part.

Since you seem to be the one adding content, I'll ask you, what do you think of Fernando's latest post?

[Aimee]

I want to hear more from Barmacral and Fernando, definitely.

Cephrir, spectrumvoid needs a prod. From her absense in other games, I am pretty sure that she is currently not here - she hasn't posted in a while in any games - so I definitely don't think it is strategic lurking from her part.

Since you seem to be the one adding content, I'll ask you, what do you think of Fernando's latest post?

I am not sure, it was quite a vague summary. Fernando, could you do a player analysis of everyone up to this point?

[ryan]

Enlightened Bystander is entering prod range soon.

I think that you can safely prod him now

[Barmacral]

Sorry folks, was gone a couple of day's longer than planned. I'm back.

[ryan]

Sorry folks, was gone a couple of day's longer than planned. I'm back.

Ok welcome back, now let's see some content.

[Tarhalindur]

Given the rampant lurking and how little information we actually have, I think what we need is a new topic of discussion. In light of this, I propose that we use one of the best known of all discussion generators - the Top 2 Scum List. (Usually it's Top 3 list, but given the small size of the game I think we should cut it down to 2.)

Here's how it works: everyone posts the two people they feel are most likely to be scum, and gives reasons why they feel that way.

Sound good? I'll start us off. Tarhalindur's Top 2 Scum List:

1) Barmacral. His stance on random votes is unusual, and may indicate different motivations from the rest of us. In addition, his decision to cast a random vote due to pressure despite his personal opinion is scummy, IMO.

2) Fernando. From what I've seen, joking around during the random voting stage is a minor scumtellFernando's lack of real content also disturbs me.

[ryan]

I like the idea actually. My two scum votes right now would be........... (in order)

1) FeRnAnDo: I feel his posting isn’t of content and he’s lurking more than anything. His football comment earlier was a complete waste of a post. Post 55 seems to say, well Barmacal hasn’t posted as much as I have.” Unfortunately neither have posted content of any sort

2) Barmacal: I don’t like him not liking random votes as I always find the random vote stage a way to gauge how people vote and how they act when people vote them. THAN when asked to give a random vote he was more than happy to do it.

Pro Town Players (IMO)

1: Aimee
2: Tarhalindur

The others I don't really have a read on as of yet.

[Enlightened Bystander]

Sorry for the absence, been settling into a new job, and not been having much spare time.

Top two scum:

1. Fernando: not really added anything of worth, and tried to distract the game.

2 Tar: the drifting between fernando/bar on the first/second page still irks me, and the sillyness of picking out tar's incorrect mention of SV's gender worries me.

[ryan]

Come on game, we have 3 of 7 people posting thoughts on the game currently, with 3 pages to read I'm surprised we cant give some thoughts on the gamers currently.

[FeRnAnDo]

even tho i'm only playing one game at the moment, i can't keep as active as i wanted, i have a intense life...

ok, player analyzing... don't expect any masterpiece, there are only 3 pages of game...

Enlightened bystander²: placed a vote on someone who already had one, random or not, that's isn't a thing you should do without a reason in the same line.

Ryan: seems a decent person, he pressured barmacral, who's a newcomer like me, but also explained to him why random votes were important. Also is inquiring other players, like Aimee and myself. He's also misunderstood, in post 55, 2nd paragraph, i intended to say that he's as new as me, and mistakes are more likely... check my first game.

Tharlindur¹: well, same thing, spiting out votes, on the other hand, this top 2 cum list was a good idea.

Spectrumvoid: justified absence, but is surely the one with less content here.

Aimee: very well balanced player, i'd say town, but i don't know why her posts seems tasteless... but still nº1 in my townie list.

Barmacral³: too inconsistent... "it was a cop-out" "It wasn't a cop-out" and other things.. spooky.


¹,² and ³ is the order of my scum list.

[FeRnAnDo]

ah, the last one:

Cophrir: atentious and vote-counting fan mod.

[ryan]

mod + everyone

Sorry... I was hospitalised for dengue fever and dehydration. I wanted to leave a note somewhere but my brother swears he couldn't post because he didn't register.

So are you back with us or being replaced?

[Cephrir]

ah, the last one:

Cophrir: atentious and vote-counting fan mod.

Spelling my name wrong = no mod points for you

No votes have changed since the last vote count.