SMITE Role Madness Mafia (OVER AT LAST!)

[Solar Wind]

AP, can you talk about your Xombie read?

[Imperium]

Here are the post I have in regards to why ace is scum.
started here
what I noted about his play
issues summorized

I agree with your description of Ace's play but it feels more like you describing sub-optimal town play than scum play.

House - why did you note my defense of ace as a possible partnership tell, but skip over this?

[beastcharizard]

Eh, nix that. I don't want to vote beast until D2 at the earliest.

Can you say why that is?

Neighborhood stuff. If beast decides to share out here, that's on him.

So...

I'm suspecting beastcharizard is a vote nullifier. His vote doesn't count against me, which is a negative attribute, but in return it prevents my vote from counting against anyone else.

I can see both town & scum utility for this role, and he's been pushing it as an obvious town role in the neighborhood.

He also said he can get multivote, that the number of votes he gets changes. If he doesn't have a different # of votes tomorrow, he lied and deserves to be lynched.

iHouse: What happened between those two posts that made you reveal my info?

[farside22]

Read everything.
Still no original thought from ace so vote still staying.

Why is that scum?

I mean I know this is how you think because in the only game we played together you though KK was town for original thought but he wasn't.

But I'm just having a hard time seeing ace obvscum here.

Larger game.
Easier to lay low and offer nothing.

Who's your biggest scum read and why?

[farside22]

Actually I feel like the bashing around and disorganization isn't help bg this game.

I think instead of back and forth spam fights that are plaguing the game everyone should talk about who there biggest scum read and why.

All the infighting in the game made me lose track of some players

[Imperium]

Read everything.
Still no original thought from ace so vote still staying.

Why is that scum?

I mean I know this is how you think because in the only game we played together you though KK was town for original thought but he wasn't.

But I'm just having a hard time seeing ace obvscum here.

Probably biggest scum read is cephrir. It's gut. Need more there and want to talk to nacho but Im not sure when he'll be available.

Larger game.
Easier to lay low and offer nothing.

Who's your biggest scum read and why?

[Solar Wind]

My biggest scum read in Cephrir as well. That's probably where our vote is going to wind up once I finish re-reading the game and post my reads.

[farside22]

I don't get the cephir scum read.
Someone want to explain other then gut.

[Imperium]

Just because someone looks superficially townie doesn't mean they are.

I'm in the middle of several things right now and falcon will probably be able to explain it better than I can at the moment anyway.

[Cephrir]

Oh great! That can just be the cherry on top of this shitty day.

[Cephrir]

I'm sure someone will call that emotional manipulation though. And this too! Because that is just all I do!

[Cephrir]

...I probably shouldn't post in mafia games when I'm upset about other things, see you tomorrow.

[iHouse]

Here are the post I have in regards to why ace is scum.
started here
what I noted about his play
issues summorized

I agree with your description of Ace's play but it feels more like you describing sub-optimal town play than scum play.

House - why did you note my defense of ace as a possible partnership tell, but skip over this?

Because I have the attention span of a... what was I saying again?

[iHouse]

Eh, nix that. I don't want to vote beast until D2 at the earliest.

Can you say why that is?

Neighborhood stuff. If beast decides to share out here, that's on him.

So...

I'm suspecting beastcharizard is a vote nullifier. His vote doesn't count against me, which is a negative attribute, but in return it prevents my vote from counting against anyone else.

I can see both town & scum utility for this role, and he's been pushing it as an obvious town role in the neighborhood.

He also said he can get multivote, that the number of votes he gets changes. If he doesn't have a different # of votes tomorrow, he lied and deserves to be lynched.

iHouse: What happened between those two posts that made you reveal my info?

I saw two votes on a wagon I was on with only one being counted.

[iHouse]

Oh great! That can just be the cherry on top of this shitty day.

FWIW, I am not seeing scum in your posts.

Big comfort, amirite?

[iHouse]

Just because someone looks superficially townie doesn't mean they are.

I'm in the middle of several things right now and falcon will probably be able to explain it better than I can at the moment anyway.

That's a terribad post unless you have some decent information to back it up.

[TiphaineDeath]

My points are completely valid cephrir, so ima go with option two.

[Solar Wind]

Just because someone looks superficially townie doesn't mean they are.

I'm in the middle of several things right now and falcon will probably be able to explain it better than I can at the moment anyway.

That's a terribad post unless you have some decent information to back it up.

There will no doubt be a metric fuckton of reads and meta hitting the thread shortly. F-16 is working on his reads magnum opus. Nacho and Tammy are familiar with the games F-16 and I remember all too well where scum-Ceph was a townread for much of the town, as well as a few other nightmarish games.

You can be a judge of whether that makes a compelling case.

[beastcharizard]

Eh, nix that. I don't want to vote beast until D2 at the earliest.

Can you say why that is?

Neighborhood stuff. If beast decides to share out here, that's on him.

So...

I'm suspecting beastcharizard is a vote nullifier. His vote doesn't count against me, which is a negative attribute, but in return it prevents my vote from counting against anyone else.

I can see both town & scum utility for this role, and he's been pushing it as an obvious town role in the neighborhood.

He also said he can get multivote, that the number of votes he gets changes. If he doesn't have a different # of votes tomorrow, he lied and deserves to be lynched.

iHouse: What happened between those two posts that made you reveal my info?

I saw two votes on a wagon I was on with only one being counted.

Logical leap: "Oh Beast must be scum because someone's vote is missing."

[Cephrir]

I hate fewer things now.

I would simply like to remark that I am surprised no one else has noticed how terrible TD's posts have become. I'm disappointed. I have seen few posts so bad in my mafia career.

I fully expect to be lynched today, since apparently someone is writing a magical novel or something. I'd really have liked more than a couple pages of actually being caught up and playing the game in real time because personally I think all my catchups look the same, but sure. Whatever.

[Solar Wind]

Play in real time now?

I dunno if you're my strongest scumread. But, you scare the fuck out of me when your iso feels so laid back.

[vezokpiraka]

Cephrir is not scum. He's being pushed by scum as cw to ace.

[mastin2]

I would simply like to remark that I am surprised no one else has noticed how terrible TD's posts have become.

*raises hand*
I did!

I just haven't done anything about it. (Similar, but to a much lesser extent, to my Rach read. No, that read hasn't changed.)

[Solar Wind]

I would simply like to remark that I am surprised no one else has noticed how terrible TD's posts have become.

*raises hand*
I did!

I just haven't done anything about it. (Similar, but to a much lesser extent, to my Rach read. No, that read hasn't changed.)

Are you happy with the current gamestate?

[Ankamius]

V/LA until Friday

I got a tough schedule this week. I'll be fine on the weekend, but keep this in mind if I start talking nonsense until then.