Mini 1636: Mafialand Mayhem! - [Game Over]

[MonkeyMan576]

Is that sarcasm? Or are you going to switch your vote?

[Reticent]

...

I love you, Monkey. <3

[MonkeyMan576]

You haven't explained how Illl is town in general or how you shouldn't be held accountable for switching your vote at the last minute to a wagon that includes someone who is your biggest scumread and then causing a townlynch.

[Reticent]

You haven't explained how Illl is town in general

This is not my job since I never claimed this, nor would I need to in order to "defend against poor arguments." (Don't forget to townread me, by the way)

or how you shouldn't be held accountable for switching your vote at the last minute to a wagon that includes someone who is your biggest scumread and then causing a townlynch.

1.) Quite a few people switched to that wagon to gain a majority. Why is all of this righteous anger directed toward IIII exclusively?

2.) Did he actually say you were his biggest scumread? Maybe I just missed that, that would be an interesting detail if you don't mind directing me to it.

[MonkeyMan576]

He called me scum specifically in 582 and 586. He didn't use such strong language repeatedly to anyone else, so it's a safe leap. Then he mysteriously switched his vote close to the last minute to a wagon that ended up leaving a town dead. No one else that switched at the last minute scum read me so heavily.

[Gendaberry]

I'm only focusing on CKD because he's tunneling.

Ill is still the best lynch and I'm not wanting to start a new wagon with the short time left in day.

If IIII is the best lynch in your eyes, why the hell don't you do anything to try to get him lynched until this late in the day when people call you out on it? You've also had plenty of time to try to start a wagon on CKD, don't act like you've only just recently started calling him scummy. It looks like the only reason you're not actively trying to get CKD lynched isn't because you see IIII as "the best lynch" but because CKD is more likely to fight back due to being much more active then IIII has been today.

VOTE: MonkeyMan576

[MonkeyMan576]

because I figured the town would be smart, but if you're not going to listen to the best case that's on you. Plus obviously the replacements didn't even know he c reason for the I'lll case before voting me.

[llll]

Then he mysteriously switched his vote close to the last minute to a wagon that ended up leaving a town dead.

@Gendaberry I appreciate a good trolling

as much

very much more than the next person, so I had my jollies with Lapsa's posts. It was Day 1, and there was nothing to do aside from watching Monkey grasping at every straw he saw, so Lapsa's trolling and my following the troll didn't actually hurt a lurky town for most of Day 1.

But

clearly Lapsa's not the kind of guy who gets night-killed, due to his unproductive posts, which meant sooner or later, Lapsa would have used up a day-lynch. Forgive me if I wanted that to happen Day 1, instead of waiting till Day 4 or later while Lapsa goes around doing the scum's work of confusing us.
For Christ's sake, the guy impersonated KatieB/sthar! Policy lynches were invented for people like Lapsa.

[Riddleton]

Votecount 2.6

MonkeyMan576 (4): curiouskarmadog, llll, Reticent, Gendaberry
llll (2): droog, MonkeyMan576
evilpacman18 (2): Aneninen, Aeronaut

Not voting (3): KatieB, Wake88, evilpacman18

With 11 players alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

The deadline for Day 2 is in (expired on 2015-01-30 13:40:00).

[Riddleton]

Prodding KatieB. This is KatieB's third and final prod.

[droog]

i think its starting to become clear
that town cant do anything productive with monkey around
i think thats mostly not monkeys fault

but he looks like lynchbait
rereading now

[droog]

Aeronaut seems completely uninvested in actively searching for an answer for his own question and so it comes across as the question being the point of that post, not the answer.

this is what i think
about aero all game

[droog]

Hey droog, let's just lynch Pacman instead. Hes lookin pretty shit to me

pamman made some good points on you
what about ti looks shit

[droog]

CKD, are you still only willing to lynch monkey?

And monkey, you seem to be spending most of your time focusing on CKD, but your vote is still parked on IIII. IIII also didnt show up in the list of players that you consider to be scummier then you in #838. Why is your vote still on IIII, when he seems to not be your top scumread?

This is a good posting

so you can read good posts
tcan you write them?

[Aeronaut]

Aeronaut seems completely uninvested in actively searching for an answer for his own question and so it comes across as the question being the point of that post, not the answer.

this is what i think
about aero all game

That sort of describes you tbh

[droog]

oh i have been a total flake
i dont deny it
whats your excuse

[droog]

1.) Day 1, His “scum is defensive/emotional” . This is a load of shit. This is a tactic scum uses to explain bad votes.



3.) HE HAS DONE NO SCUM HUNTING. NONE. Why?

4.) He said Wake was scum because he left the game (couldn’t handle the pressure?). I asked him (3 times) to provide a game where he developed this theory. He gave a newbie game (that he was in) from 2012. Really? This is the game you have based this bullshit theory? He has been around since 2008. If MM was really trying to find scum, why didn’t he meta Wake to see if this was a common problem with his other current games? (Hint: it is a common problem). No, instead he just throws that crap out there to see if it will get started. MM, why didn’t you see if Wake was having problems in other threads?

5.) he voted IIII today (the wagon that countered his own) ONLY when the wagon started gaining steam, stating his wagon switch yesterday was scummy. Really? If it was so scummy why didn’t you vote him when the day started, versus now? I have asked him why he didn’t vote him at the start of the day 3 fucking times, he has seemed to “miss” the question every time. Why?

This guy is so scummy it hurts.

If you guys don’t hang him today and I get offed tonight…PLEASE MAKE HIM ANSWER TO THIS CASE.


here is the case droog, thoughts? Am I wrong, why?

thank you for finally maing one
no one all game could point me to anything good


1) i agree
this was why i scumread monkey at first
but stupid thoughts arent scummy

2) give me time to look at this
that sounds scummy for sure
but isnt he always picking wagons because theyre not him?

3) i think this is just poor plaf

4) was a load of bullshit

5) is a good point let me think on it

[droog]

what bothers me most about monkey
si his townread on me

it feels a little too much like buddying

[Aeronaut]

I don't need excuses, because I'm one of the few people active in this game. I made a very good case on monkey, and an even better case on Pacman. All you've done is come in, vote ||||, say our cases are bad, and then do nothing again.

It's pretty easy to be like "yea all yo cases are bad", but it's much more difficult to actually say why.

Tell me why Monkey and Pacman are town

[Aeronaut]

Hold on, you're scumreading monkey?

You're saying you were

waiting for a case

on monkey before you said he was scummy yourself?

[droog]

you accuse me of not reading?
i was scumreading monkey
then i saw the wagons on him as really bad
so bad i didnt want to be on them

when no one can bring a case
for ~400 posts
i dont want to be anywhere near that wagon

[droog]

I don't need excuses, because I'm one of the few people active in this game. I made a very good case on monkey, and an even better case on Pacman. All you've done is come in, vote ||||, say our cases are bad, and then do nothing again.

but hey
mr 46 pages since game start
just over 1 post per page

keep riding me for no content
while im in the middle of making content

[KatieB]

Sorry guys, we're up to three kid-crises this week, and I have to find an apartment that I can afford in the next three weeks or I'll be couchsurfing.

I'm having a hard time engaging with this game but I'm trying not to replace because I respect riddles.

Droog is town unless monkey flips scum, for fighting the wagon to no apparent towncred.

Monkey seems town to me. He's grasping, sure, but he seems to genuinely be trying to figure out the game. I disagree with just about every one of his methods and conclusions, but I know he does get lynched a lot as town. He looks like low hanging fruit here.

Given that, I'd like to set Genda on fire. He's been on both the big wagons today and his justifications for both are utter shit. He's just looking for a lynch other people will vote for.

VOTE: Gendberry

I'm still townreading pacman, im doubting my townread on CKD from yesterday.

Did I miss anything important?

[curiouskarmadog]

Given that, I'd like to set Genda on fire. He's been on both the big wagons today and his justifications for both are utter shit. He's just looking for a lynch other people will vote for.

VOTE: Gendberry

I'm still townreading pacman, im doubting my townread on CKD from yesterday.

Did I miss anything important?

Have you read the game today or did you skim?

[curiouskarmadog]

Hint: if you say you have thoroughly read today, you have just got yourself a spot on my scum list and a ton of followup questions.

if you say you have skimmed, I am going to be asking you why the fuck are you voting if you havent read and if you know there is a deadline approaching.

either way, please break down my case on MM, what do you not like exactly? What part of Gen's involvement in the IIII "wagon" was scummy?