Open 26 - Vengeful Mafia (Abandoned) before 462

[yellowbounder]

Vote Count

1 - IH (Per)
1 - xyzzy (IH)

2 - cmckinney (xyzzy, Sir Tornado)

1 - Not Voting (cmckinney)

With

5

alive, it's

3

to lynch.

Post!

[Per]

Per, IH isn't lurking. His sig says he'll be away till 29th.

I know what his sig says, I can read. I wasn't talking about these last couple of days, because that's not lurking, and it's not in plain sight.

When he was only being silly and not contributing anything, no matter how small, that's what I call lurking in plain sight.

[xyzzy]

Per, who do you think the GF and goon are?

[Per]

I think cmckinney is scum. My point (his question "how are we supposed to vig someone if we're all vanilla townies?") wasn't too big at first but I don't like it that he still hasn't replied to me or explained why he asked that question.

I don't know who his buddy is. I haven't spotted any pro-town behaviour from any of you yet so I haven't ruled anyone out yet.

Why are you asking this to me only? Why not to the rest of the town? And what do you think yourself?

[xyzzy]

Well, I personally have to agree with you...

But why aren't you voting for him if you think he's scum?

[Per]

Because that would mean the end of the day, and I want to hear more from you all.

[Per]

Edit: Also, it's one slip-up. One slip-up, with no explanation afterwards (because cmckinney hasn't posted ever since). That does NOT warrant a lynch, though I do think that he is scum. There is always a chance that I'm wrong, and if I hammer wrongly, he would almost certainly vig me which would lose us the game.

I don't mean you have to be 100% sure before hammering, but there is too little to go on so far.

[xyzzy]

Well, it doesn't seem our fellow players are too excited about the idea of posting, which makes any action difficult at this point.

[Sir Tornado]

Edit: Also, it's one slip-up. One slip-up, with no explanation afterwards (because cmckinney hasn't posted ever since). That does NOT warrant a lynch, though I do think that he is scum. There is always a chance that I'm wrong, and if I hammer wrongly, he would almost certainly vig me which would lose us the game.

I don't mean you have to be 100% sure before hammering, but there is too little to go on so far.

I think this is worth taking seriously.

CMC?

[xyzzy]

*Sigh*

Someone do something. There's not even anything to analyze.

[Per]

Waiting for IH and CMC here...

[Sir Tornado]

I am waiting for CMC to clarify his post (which xyzzy has quoted)

This is getting nowhere, really. You can't have a game with just 3 players around and the rest lurking...

[Sir Tornado]

EBWOP: Which

Per

had quoted.

[xyzzy]

Perhaps the game would move if CMC was replaced, so we could get to the more important detail of getting his clarification?

[IH]

back I'll look over the last page or two in a bit. Probably tonight.

[Per]

Perhaps the game would move if CMC was replaced, so we could get to the more important detail of getting his clarification?

The thing is, if CMC is replaced, the replacement can never explain why CMC said that. That would mean we're back to square one.

But yeah, I'd rather have an active player than one who can explain this slip-up.

[yellowbounder]

Aimee totally replaces cmckinney.

[Aimee]

hai peeps

<3 IH, xyzzy and Sir Tornado.

Per, I don't know you. Well, I do now = )

[Aimee]

Questions for people:

Per: Why did you find my predecessor scum?

IH: You don't get a question, cuz you ain't special =D Mainly waiting on your re-read thoughts.

Sir T: Who do you actually suspect right now?

xyzzy: Er... dunno. Comments?

I am pretty sure someone else is in the game, but I can't remember. I feel so dumb! = ( Enlighten me, other person, with your presence!

Also, pre-emptive

FoS: xyzzy, Sir Tornado

they are scum

obvobv

(I actually will explain why later, after I get the answers to the questions. Kthx.)

[Aimee]

xyzzy: Who do you suspect at the moment?

[Sir Tornado]

Questions for people:

Per: Why did you find my predecessor scum?

IH: You don't get a question, cuz you ain't special =D Mainly waiting on your re-read thoughts.

Sir T: Who do you actually suspect right now?

xyzzy: Er... dunno. Comments?

I am pretty sure someone else is in the game, but I can't remember. I feel so dumb! = ( Enlighten me, other person, with your presence!

Also, pre-emptive

FoS: xyzzy, Sir Tornado

they are scum

obvobv

(I actually will explain why later, after I get the answers to the questions. Kthx.)

Hi Aimee!

I suspected cmckinney for this:

awwwwwww, come on, i just haven't been able to get on recently.

Im new to this whole vengeful setup, but how are we supposed to fig them if we are all just townies?

I take it that fig = typo for vig, because "f" is just above "v". It was clearly explained in role PMs how were are supposed to do that. Well, if he'd received a townie role PM, then he shouldn't be asking this.

And, IH was acting (I thought) a bit strange, but then, I haven't played with IH before this, so I can't rule out that being his usual play (and almost everything acts strange on the first couple of pages).

Apart from that, nothing. It's too early for any concrete suspicions.

And I will

Unvote Aimee

[Sir Tornado]

In my above post:

First para:

It was clearly explained in role PMs how

were

are supposed to do that.

Is supposed to be:

It was clearly explained in role PMs how

we

are supposed to do that.

[Sir Tornado]

EBWOP: In post 70,

(and almost every

thing

acts strange on the first couple of pages)

Should mean:

(and almost every

one

acts strange on the first couple of pages)

[Per]

Hello Aimee.

Well, Sir_Tornado already answered the question you asked me. Cmckinney asked how we are supposed to vig the scum. Since you cannot explain that, because, umm, you're not cmckinney (are you?), I can't make a case against you.

IH is taking WAY too long now.

I don't get a read on Sir_Tornado or xyzzy.

[xyzzy]

Unvote

I wouldn't be caught dead voting Aimee intentionally. <3

Unfortuately, though, CMC's actions are suspicious enough thay you might be scum. Hmm...

I'm slightly suspicious of Per for saying a lot without really saying anything.