Mini 1636: Mafialand Mayhem! - [Game Over]

[evilpacman18]

Gimme a couple more hours

[Lapsa]

hi

pacman

. who's scum?

[Riddleton]

BP and Ollie are being replaced.

[Aneninen]

Is there anyone still here? ^_^

[Lapsa]

Is there anyone still here? ^_^

true

[evilpacman18]

I have to say I don't like where the conversation went in the early pages of the game. I'm looking at the page 3 exchange between ckd and Wake88 that I don't like a lot. Ckd asks Wake two shitty questions. I think Ckd seems more town, he's prodding a lot which, fine, although I would've liked him to do more with the answers Wake gave to "what is an acceptable fluff ratio" and "what do you think of someone confirming but not posting." The first question in particular works really well as a trap and I hope that's what ckd meant it for and Wake might have fallen for it. "Fluff" of course is definition-less

[evilpacman18]

shit I was in the middle of writing that hold on, I'll just continue from where I left off but I needa finish reading and stuff.

[evilpacman18]

"Fluff" of course is definition-less, completely subjected to context, and probably scummier when it is made to seem like it is content. For instance, I would probably be less likely to see it as scummy fluff if someone had a really long discussion about jam recipes than if someone posted a lot of stuff that seems like content and tried to pass it off. This is why I think it is scummy when people spend too much time talking about game rules and semantics. But again, context, and the worst thing about 67 I think is that Wake answers ckd's question without seeming to think in terms of context.

Lapsa can be a bit short and I think some people are mistaking that for being uncooperative but he seems town to me and actually answers most things he is asked. Agree with ckd's 81.

Luca looks way scummier than Katie in their page 4 exchange and I don't trust monkeyman for opting to vote for her... or him. hi sthar.

I'm scumreading Wake and MonkeyMan right now.
Glad Aeronaut recognizes ckd's questions are bullshit in 178.

still a bit more to read but I want a breakfast burrito.

[evilpacman18]

Is that fluff? Hopefully it's within my designated fluff-to-content ratio

[Aneninen]

Hmmm... I think your theory about fluffing was interesting, I've never thought about that before. Talking about the rules and general theories are a null, though.

I disagree with some of your reads. Eg. I don't think either Luca or Wake are scums right now. What's your read on Drake Crusader?

In general, your posts have given town vibes.

[Luca Blight]

Evilpacman, are you reading a different game to me?

You think Lapsa has "actually answered most things he's asked"? That is a very weird reason to townread someone, given they have avoided more questions than anyone this game!

In what possible way do I look 'way scummier' than Katie in the page 4 exchange?

[llll]

KatieB is being super defensive right now, which seems scummy to me, and maybe I missed something, but I didn't see her ever addressing Luca's initial question which led to her wagon.

Vote: KatieB

[Riddleton]

Droog replaces BP.

[Aneninen]

Lol, hi, Druuge!

[Riddleton]

Votecount 1.6

KatieB (4): Luca Blight, MonkeyMan576, Drake Crusader, llll
MonkeyMan576 (2): curiouskarmadog, Aeronaut
Wake88 (1): Lapsa
Drake Crusader (1): Aneninen
evilpacman18 (1): KatieB

Not voting (4): evilpacman18, droog, Wake88, Ollie,

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

The deadline for Day 1 is in (expired on 2015-01-12 21:44:00).

[Aneninen]

KatieB is being super defensive right now, which seems scummy to me, and maybe I missed something, but I didn't see her ever addressing Luca's initial question which led to her wagon.

Vote: KatieB

Is that all? after 10 pages?

[llll]

Well, the people who posted the most mostly posted blather. I'm not sure what to make of that, other than take an aspirin.

[MonkeyMan576]

It's day 1. Why do people expect game changing posts this early in the game?

[droog]

read the first five pages
literally nothing scummy or towny
bah humbug

[droog]

And you still haven't explained why I'm scum.

Right but I'm not posting a 'case.' You are.

And it's a case that nowhere ever actually suggests a scum motivation for anything I've done.

laughing
the sooner 'suggests a scum motive' stops being site meta
will be just great

[droog]

Being defensive and emotional is indicative of scum, because scum are more worried about their own survival because there are fewer of them than town. Town worry about scum hunting over survival.

Also, saying someone is probtown this early in the game sounds like someone trying to whiteknight their scum partner.

cereal box facts are more accurate.
hinting scum motive without saying it straight
or pompous mafia theories that mean nothing
are scummy
so youre scummy

[MonkeyMan576]

Being defensive and emotional is indicative of scum, because scum are more worried about their own survival because there are fewer of them than town. Town worry about scum hunting over survival.

Also, saying someone is probtown this early in the game sounds like someone trying to whiteknight their scum partner.

cereal box facts are more accurate.
hinting scum motive without saying it straight
or pompous mafia theories that mean nothing
are scummy
so youre scummy

This is the stupidest post I've ever read. I never hinted anything, I outright said it.

[MonkeyMan576]

Vote: Droog

[droog]

Being defensive and emotional is indicative of scum

[MonkeyMan576]

Misrepping is indicative of scum.