Mini 427 - Clue Mafia 2 - GAME OVER

[BillyTwilight]

So who would have eaten the soup and who would have pitched it, and why?

I wouldn't have eaten it, mostly because it is an unknown and who knows what that could mean with MoS modding this game. I figure that with the way these Clue games are set up, MoS has to be modding at least one of them with some crazy atypical roles/gameplay, etc. Throw that in with some random soup showing up would make me extremely nervous about chowing down, whither it was cold outside or not.

Don't like CES or BM voting for MBL. BTW, aren't we supposed to be using Accuse in these games instead of Vote? BM claimed cop day 1 but I'm beginning to not like that claim. His post #164 makes me wonder about his claim now, and the nonsensical attack on MBL for not participating in an unknown variable bothers me. Couple that with the fact that BM claimed so quickly on day 1 (at Lynch-1) makes me nervous about that claim.

[al_kohaulec]

Would somebody risk eating soup if it came up again?

[Battle Mage]

err, i dont really get what you mean here. I have very good reason to vote for MBL. However, i wasnt intending to reveal it until AFTER he'd answered my questions. Note that he has refused to do this, at least twice!

still if it makes you feel better.

Accuse: MBL

So who would have eaten the soup and who would have pitched it, and why?

I wouldn't have eaten it, mostly because it is an unknown and who knows what that could mean with MoS modding this game. I figure that with the way these Clue games are set up, MoS has to be modding at least one of them with some crazy atypical roles/gameplay, etc. Throw that in with some random soup showing up would make me extremely nervous about chowing down, whither it was cold outside or not.

Don't like CES or BM voting for MBL. BTW, aren't we supposed to be using Accuse in these games instead of Vote? BM claimed cop day 1 but I'm beginning to not like that claim. His post #164 makes me wonder about his claim now, and the nonsensical attack on MBL for not participating in an unknown variable bothers me. Couple that with the fact that BM claimed so quickly on day 1 (at Lynch-1) makes me nervous about that claim.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Would somebody risk eating soup if it came up again?

I would. For the Good of the Towne.

[dahen]

Exactly. I dont see why they are up in MBL's case about pitching some unknown random variable in the game. (so far as we know)

Well, I guess you can see it like this: Say it's 50% that it kills you and 50% that you get some fancy power. Would you take the chance?

If you were SK, you would have a 50% chance of losing right away.
If you were scum, your team would suffer quite badly from being killed.
If you were town, your team would suffer, but not that badly.

If the soup would give you a fancy power, you would benefit from it no matter what role you are, but if any information about it leaks out, then you would probably be helping town the most.

This reasonin say to me that scum would probably be more inclined to throw it away. Of course WIFOM applies as usual. Players that prefer to be alive at all costs will probably be more inclined to pitch it, while curious players would drink it.

My point is that the discussion is valid, and that I don't like when people are turning down such a discussion. Maybe it's a bad idea to lycnh solely based on the soup issue, but to disregard from what's happening; no, that's generally not good.

I realize I have posted way too little in this game, and it's not that fair for me to vote Ancalagon for being quiet, but could you please explain your posts Anca, they don't make sense to me.

mini-fos: Ancalagon

[Ectomancer]

Exactly. I dont see why they are up in MBL's case about pitching some unknown random variable in the game. (so far as we know)

Well, I guess you can see it like this: Say it's 50% that it kills you and 50% that you get some fancy power. Would you take the chance?

If you were SK, you would have a 50% chance of losing right away.
If you were scum, your team would suffer quite badly from being killed.
If you were town, your team would suffer, but not that badly.

If the soup would give you a fancy power, you would benefit from it no matter what role you are, but if any information about it leaks out, then you would probably be helping town the most.

This reasonin say to me that scum would probably be more inclined to throw it away. Of course WIFOM applies as usual. Players that prefer to be alive at all costs will probably be more inclined to pitch it, while curious players would drink it.

My point is that the discussion is valid, and that I don't like when people are turning down such a discussion. Maybe it's a bad idea to lycnh solely based on the soup issue, but to disregard from what's happening; no, that's generally not good.

I realize I have posted way too little in this game, and it's not that fair for me to vote Ancalagon for being quiet, but could you please explain your posts Anca, they don't make sense to me.

mini-fos: Ancalagon

Really? And where exactly did you get the information that the soup has a 50% chance of giving the recipient a power?

[Mastermind of Sin]

YARRRRR Vote count:

MrBuddyLee - (Cogito Ergo Sum, Battle Mage)

Cogito Ergo Sum - (Ectomancer)

[dahen]

Really? And where exactly did you get the information that the soup has a 50% chance of giving the recipient a power?

Are you trying to misunderstand me? I think the soup has 100% chance of having a certain effect. Since I don't know what the effect is, I find it as likely as not that it is dangerous vs. beneficial, hence 50%. If you find any alternative more likely, just shift the numbers a bit and read my post again.

[Ectomancer]

The rest of your post makes sense, but it annoys me that people leapt to the supposition that the soup gives you a power and then used it in their argument as if it was a given fact.

[al_kohaulec]

It's more plausible that the soup (IMO) would be beneficial than harmful, though I could see it causing something bad like maybe a voteblock or something. I really doubt it would've killed anybody (unless if it gave him a vig ability).

[Battle Mage]

can MBL either be Prodded, or replaced. we need a response from him ASAP.

[Mastermind of Sin]

YARRRRR More posts please Vote count:

MrBuddyLee - (Cogito Ergo Sum, Battle Mage)

Cogito Ergo Sum - (Ectomancer)

Deadline will be instated without more posting

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

The most damning aspect I consider the quickness of MBL's decision, which I would personally attribute to a desire to pre-empt any discussion.

[Jack]

dude, he already said the thread was closed until mbl made his decision.

vote:CES

[Battle Mage]

hello? is nobody listening to me? am i invisible or something?

here's the facts. MBL has refused to answer questions posed to him. Until he does so, i reccommend nobody does anything. I want a response out of him, and by voting for CES, you are taking pressure off MBL so he can continue to lurk evasively.

Mod: please prod MBL

[BillyTwilight]

Why is everyone so concerned about the soup? It's a wild-card and nothing about MBL's reaction to it is scummy.

Going to reread and give a player analysis; expect it sometime tomorrow. [/hopefully]

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

dude, he already said the thread was closed until mbl made his decision.

vote:CES

MBL's decision was made in an open thread while other people were posting. There was no urgency or a limitation on the amount of discussion that could take place.

[al_kohaulec]

According to what MBL claimed, the thread was closed until MBL PMed his response, and then reopened the thread and requested that MBL post his response.

It'd be nice if the mod could confirm that the thread was locked during day, or if anybody noticed it.

[al_kohaulec]

So is everybody done talking?

[Battle Mage]

im here, waiting for MBL to post. until that, we could keep pressurising him with votes.

[al_kohaulec]

Didn't he also go quiet in Clue Mafia 1, as scum? I don't really know MBL's playstyle that well when he's scum, but it's reminding me of how Twito purposefully lurks as scum.

[Mastermind of Sin]

YARRRRR More posts please Vote count:

MrBuddyLee - (Cogito Ergo Sum, Battle Mage)

Cogito Ergo Sum - (Ectomancer, Jack)

Deadline will be instated without more posting

MBL has been prodded.

[Battle Mage]

thanks MoS.

[MrBuddyLee]

Oh, BM wants you all to stop playing until these questions are answered:

MBL- what are your views on Billy Twilight?
do you believe that he is TCS's scumbuddy, or genuine town?
who do you consider the play for today?

zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Twilight seems fine. I don't know who today's play is. We've only just begun and you've told everyone not to say anything because you're retarded.

Any more questions before we resume?

[al_kohaulec]

No, resume, I just can't remember where we are in this game because I keep getting it confused with Clue 3 or 1.