In post 5043, Thor665 wrote:(and, heck, the whole rolecop/suicide play applies equally if you're scum, really, so it's a very thin defense you're sitting on)
scum!beast doesnt (or may not have absolute knowledge of Reinoes alignment)
If Beast believes reinoe is scum(mafia), and that he(believed to be scumreinoe) and reinoes (team mates) were doing push to lynch him, to secure mafia (not WW) as the way most likely non town faction to win... (3M vs 1 WW)
Then beast can make the play.
beast can be wrong.
so yeah we need not to do
In post 5043, Thor665 wrote:Town mislynched me anyways because town is dumb and sheeps PRs whenever they get the
excuse to shut down their brains and not do that painful "thinking" business.
We have to decide for ourselves is Beast scum, fake claiming for one of several scenarios.
and even if he is fake claiming and scum
Does that make Reinoe scum or town or do we still have to do that awful thinking stuff?
Some things mean we can mainly take our thinking hats off....
If beast flips town cop at some point, it is very likely he didn't lie about the check.
If Reinoe flips town cop at some point, it is even more very likely he didn't lie about the check.
most other thing means we still ought mainly decide for ourselves.
In particular a scum mafia Reinoe flip does not mean absolutely Beast is town or a cop.
A scum beast flip, does not mean abolutely Reinoe was actually town cop.
I suggest we lynch scummy people.
I am voting beast as i find his actions and reasoning today scummy, convenient and shallow(façade like) .