Haunted Mansion| GAME OVER (Feedback?)

[Mokina]

Or very possibly priests. My suspiscion on Mokina was that she acted as if she did not know what her book did at first, then revealed the title of it which made it obvious.

That was intentional, actually. Initially, I avoided revealing too much about the exorcism item (figuring that it would be best if ghosts didn't know I had it). However, a certain perceptive player figured it out immediately and I decided it wasn't worth trying to conceal anymore.

On another note entirely, I find Khelvaster's protective attitude a little odd. If he's innocent, though, it makes sense... he wants the town to have proof of said innocence.

[Khelvaster]

well, I figure you and whoever else is in the room will both see that someone else tried something funky before I attacked, if I end up attacking, so I will be justified in defending.

[johhan]

well, I figure you and whoever else is in the room will both see that someone else tried something funky before I attacked, if I end up attacking, so I will be justified in defending.

So, you're going to get to wait and see if anyone else attacked you before deciding to attack? Just how will you do that?
This makes absolutely no sense. and you're not an innocent, you're a question mark, suspected ghost/priest by a lot of these people. which is why I'm stabbing you with my fork. Unless you're a ghost, in which case it's supposed to explode. 1 dmg to an innocent, 2 to a priest and 5 to a ghost.

[Shanba]

problem is, with that armour Khel is wearing, it'll be hard to tell wth is going on. If he is a priest, as I suspect, it might end up doing only 1 damage because of the armour and fake confirming his innocence

[YagamiLight]

With the armor, we should look at it like this, 0 or 1 is innocent, 0-2 priest, 0-5 but explodes ghost. Basically because we don't know how much it will depend we can only say if he's ghost or not, not priest or innocent.

[Khelvaster]

well, I figure you and whoever else is in the room will both see that someone else tried something funky before I attacked, if I end up attacking, so I will be justified in defending.

So, you're going to get to wait and see if anyone else attacked you before deciding to attack? Just how will you do that?
This makes absolutely no sense. and you're not an innocent, you're a question mark, suspected ghost/priest by a lot of these people. which is why I'm stabbing you with my fork. Unless you're a ghost, in which case it's supposed to explode. 1 dmg to an innocent, 2 to a priest and 5 to a ghost.

Well, my message to occult was "wait and see if anyone else makes an offensive action towards myself or mokina. If someone does, I kill them with my sword."

problem is, with that armour Khel is wearing, it'll be hard to tell wth is going on. If he is a priest, as I suspect, it might end up doing only 1 damage because of the armour and fake confirming his innocence

Meaning, whoever tries to stab me is just asking to get killed. Also, if I am priest, wouldn't it be prudent of me to keep townies alive, since they are trying to do stuff to ghosts as well?

[Mokina]

Remember that I'm testing the guy too, and exorcisms don't seem like the sort of thing that would be affected by armor.

[Mokina]

On the other hand...

*suspicions kick in*

Maybe exorcisms show up normal (Godfather-style) on this particular ghost... and he wants to be proven innocent to the town. That would explain his phobia of normal attacks. Just a theory.

[Xdaamno]

Also, Xdaamno is a ghost.

Why?

The way he adamantly says Khel and Mokina are priests, but then completely flip-flops and says "They're probably ghosts".

Can you read my quote? Quoted:

Or very possibly priests. My suspiscion on Mokina was that she acted as if she did not know what her book did at first, then revealed the title of it which made it obvious.

Probably ghosts, though.

Notice how I said 'Very Possibly Priests' and 'Probably Ghosts'. In what way do they contradict? IGMEOY, JDodge, because that's grasping from my POV.

Mokina, want to roleclaim or not?

[Xdaamno]

With the armor, we should look at it like this, 0 or 1 is innocent, 0-2 priest, 0-5 but explodes ghost. Basically because we don't know how much it will depend we can only say if he's ghost or not, not priest or innocent.

I don't recall when the values of damage were given. Can you give me the quote?

[Xdaamno]

And, finally:

and coolbot is a ghost too, because he said his weapon, which damages ghosts and not innocents, did nothing to me (this was before I found the armor.)

And how exactly does this prove he's a ghost?

[JDodge]

Or very possibly priests. My suspiscion on Mokina was that she acted as if she did not know what her book did at first, then revealed the title of it which made it obvious.

Probably ghosts, though.

Notice how I said 'Very Possibly Priests' and 'Probably Ghosts'. In what way do they contradict? IGMEOY, JDodge, because that's grasping from my POV.

Mokina, want to roleclaim or not?

Now now, we all know that's a lie. You've been pushing the priest angle for ages.

[Xdaamno]

Uhm, no I haven't. Other people have been pushing the priest wagon, I've been pushing the ghost wagon but saying the priest wagon is very much possible.

Care to give quotes, in that case, of when I've pushed the priest wagon?

[Xdaamno]

EBWOP: And if you think my point about the book was pushing her as priest, re-read it. I purposefully pointed it out, and I was looking for reactions before I did anything further. It was neutral.

[JDodge]

I'm willing to bet he's a priest, in all seriousness. It's unlikely the armor would do anything but reduce damage. We really need something that does a little more damage to priests to check >.<

Well, at least there's

that

, which is odd.

[Xdaamno]

I'm willing to bet he's a priest, in all seriousness. It's unlikely the armor would do anything but reduce damage. We really need something that does a little more damage to priests to check >.<

Well, at least there's

that

, which is odd.

Congratulations on finding the only thing I've said that implicates Khel (Not Mokina) as priest

That was based on factual evidence apparent to anyone. I think he took 0 damage (IIRC?), and so I doubted he'd be ghost due to the armor probably wouldn't negate 81+% of the damage, and I seriously doubt he's innocent. I think my statement was justified.

I don't definativly know about either of them; there's arguments for both sides. You'll see my opinion changing as new evidence comes into a light against either side, but at the moment I'm unsure.

[Khelvaster]

Never mind...I am just going to hide from creature based traps. Mod informed me that readying actions are illegal in this game.

[YagamiLight]

well, I figure you and whoever else is in the room will both see that someone else tried something funky before I attacked, if I end up attacking, so I will be justified in defending.

So, you're going to get to wait and see if anyone else attacked you before deciding to attack? Just how will you do that?
This makes absolutely no sense. and you're not an innocent, you're a question mark, suspected ghost/priest by a lot of these people. which is why

I'm stabbing you with my fork. Unless you're a ghost, in which case it's supposed to explode. 1 dmg to an innocent, 2 to a priest and 5 to a ghost.

Xdaamo the damage is in bold.

[CoolBot]

I did attack Khel, and it did occur before I was yanked away. I hit him, but it was ineffective. In my mind, he is most likely innocent.

[Xdaamno]

Thanks, Yagami.

[Occult]

'bout 18 in

[The Greg]

I'm a little nervous about that corpse, but no one else in the Master Bedroom has suffered injuries, so I'll search.

[Khelvaster]

And, finally:

and coolbot is a ghost too, because he said his weapon, which damages ghosts and not innocents, did nothing to me (this was before I found the armor.)

And how exactly does this prove he's a ghost?

Got sarcasm? I was showing that saying I'm ghost would require making 3 or 4 other people ghosts too.

On the other hand...

*suspicions kick in*

Maybe exorcisms show up normal (Godfather-style) on this particular ghost... and he wants to be proven innocent to the town. That would explain his phobia of normal attacks. Just a theory.

Or, it could be that I am at 3 HP...

[YagamiLight]

Khel the part that you say is sarcasm, is how I would see it. In my eyes it seems that the ghosts would have to stick together more, because they are either alone or with another ghost when they are pushing the trap buttons to avoid being seen by innocents and priests.

[Occult]

21 in and missing..... Eteocles.