In post 3381, AxleGreaser wrote:@Goodmorning
I would only be telling you that if you cant/didnt read my post
you apparently also dont remember what you asked
You asked: " what is your read on Thor?" << does not ask for a reason (a because)
and I told you, and I never stated a reason at all.
(I did tell you why I had downgraded it, from what would have been a stronger town read)
Actually I asked several times for anyone with a townread on Thor to explain it to me. (see 2855, 2919 below)
Rereading your post in this light, it makes more sense.
On that note,
please explain your townlean on Thor
.
Axle wrote:Please state your reasoning for wanting to lynch Thor.
2800 I point out Thor's hypocrisy with his Shiro case and question his discomfort with Slandaar's Shiro vote
2852 I point out that Thor took very easy actions for all of D1, never taking a stance he couldn't go back on with ease
2855 I point out that the basis for literally every single read Thor provided was "gut" and mention that the multiball thing was bullshit
goodmorning wrote:There's literally nothing anywhere here that he couldn't just go "oh, I changed my mind" or "oh, I don't remember that" except the Pere thing.
Also in 2855 I asked anyone with a townread on Thor to explain it.
ALSO in 2855 I pointed out some discrepancies in his readslist, most notably his read on Tier.
2857 Thor doesn't hide as Town.
2892 goodmorning wrote:I'm pointing out that you're being inconsistent and not doing much scumhunting and you're choosing to focus on semantics and attempting to paint my argument as fallacious.
In post 2919, goodmorning wrote:YOU IGNORED THE PART OF THE POST IN WHICH I PROVIDED EVIDENCE THAT YOU'VE DONE LITTLE, AND THAT LITTLE NOT MAKING MUCH SENSE
AND
YOU IGNORED IT IN FAVOUR OF A CHEAP DISCREDIT
HOW MUCH MORE ATTENTION-GRABBING DO I HAVE TO MAKE THIS:
IS ANYONE AT ALL TOWNREADING THOR RIGHT NOW?
FUCKING EXPLAIN IT
.
3104 goodmorning wrote:D1 what I had was a tone-based read. D2, looking back, Thor didn't say anything he couldn't take back, only pushed Pere, not very Town-Thor actions. Now he's beginning to worry about my read on him because I can back it up; you'll notice he's tried to discredit me pretty much every time he posts.
Can you please stop pretending to have read my posts, Axle?
-----------
Axle wrote:on D1 you claimed it was all tone and feels and refused to provide details.
I believe on D2 all of sudden you have started being able to provide details based on D1 posts.
Yup. The magic of hindsight.
I did mention that I felt he had a certain whingey quality as Scum that he lacked as Town, but other than Thor I don't think anyone looked at the games I brought up.
Axle wrote:The D1 lynch mislynched one townie who was being wagoned against another(Anen)
and you rather conveniently were not pushing your wagon with reason so it didnt go anywhere.
It was bigger than the Anen wagon for a while iirc, not that it really matters. You're saying Scum-me would fake-push a 3rd townie when two easy marks were already on the block?
Axle wrote:I call BS, explain your case
explain why on D2 it has details and on D1, you didnt have any
Reading D1 page-by-page is a lot different than reading D1 as a whole, especially in a Large. It's really easy to get swamped in the RIGHT NOW.
My failing in case-making was a failure to look at the bigger picture.