Open 571- Pick Your Poison Game over

[aphix]

Does alc providing the link indicate that scum wants to release it? Or do we need all mafia to say so?

[reinoe]

I'm pretty sure only the mod can make it public, even if you provide the link.

[notscience]

I want approval from all slots (so only one of the hydra heads from each)

[Alchemist21]

Oh well. If anyone has any questions, I can still answer them, right?

[Fluminator]

The thing I am most curious about is that reaction test Krystal and Matsumi did on D1. Was it a scumslip?
Also, did you just get lucky with killing our power roles, or did you actually figure them out?

[Alchemist21]

As promised Flum, here's that thread I talked about before I got lynched. http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=59703

I have no idea what was up with KB's reaction test. It was never discussed in the PT.

Ank being a PR was dumb luck, Anatole was killed because Sakura thought she saw him hinting a PR guilty on him, and Newbie died because KB and myself thought we saw a PR hint from Flames when he was still in.

[Sakura Hana]

I want approval from all slots (so only one of the hydra heads from each)

Go ahead.

[Sakura Hana]

The thing I am most curious about is that reaction test Krystal and Matsumi did on D1. Was it a scumslip?

It looked like a natural quesiton to me, the same thing happened in another game with similar mechanics (Stack the deck), and i'd have reacted the same way to his "reaction test" as town.

[Randomnamechange]

Nah, Flum was town MVP. I say KB was scum MVP. Sorry I screwed you over, KB.

I agree with this. Superb job pulling it back flum and gaiden. I guess now I know not to trust hydras. I genuinely thought scum would win from Day 2. Nice playing with yall apart from reinoe.

[reinoe]

Nah, Flum was town MVP. I say KB was scum MVP. Sorry I screwed you over, KB.

I agree with this. Superb job pulling it back flum and gaiden. I guess now I know not to trust hydras. I genuinely thought scum would win from Day 2. Nice playing with yall apart from reinoe.

Weren't you too busy being lynched day way to play with me?

[Randomnamechange]

Nah, Flum was town MVP. I say KB was scum MVP. Sorry I screwed you over, KB.

I agree with this. Superb job pulling it back flum and gaiden. I guess now I know not to trust hydras. I genuinely thought scum would win from Day 2. Nice playing with yall apart from reinoe.

Weren't you too busy being lynched day way to play with me?

I've been following the game. I worded it badly.

[Nikanor]

GG town, I wish I hadn't been so busy from lylo on, I had no time at all to play otherwise I certainly would've put more effort in. Alas, c'est la vie. You did a good job though, we probably wouldn't have won even if I had had time.
The reaction test wasn't a slip, although it was pretty stupid. I'm ok with sharing the scum PT, in it you'll see that I have low expectations for myself as scum, maybe I was trying to live up to that?

[notscience]

Maf QT is now available

[Nikanor]

RE: People saying I should have hammered Alc:
You don't think that would've been weird if I just hammered someone I was townreading in lylo? Like, I'd been defending him all game, it would've been kinda screwy if I'd just hammered him out of nowhere.

[Alchemist21]

RE: People saying I should have hammered Alc:
You don't think that would've been weird if I just hammered someone I was townreading in lylo? Like, I'd been defending him all game, it would've been kinda screwy if I'd just hammered him out of nowhere.

I think you could have done it after I slipped, and you still could have made Flum look guilty.

[reinoe]

RE: People saying I should have hammered Alc:
You don't think that would've been weird if I just hammered someone I was townreading in lylo? Like, I'd been defending him all game, it would've been kinda screwy if I'd just hammered him out of nowhere.

Not really. Flum chainsaw defended Matsumi Sisters and then Chainsaw defended Alchemist before his vote switch.. Flum reasonlessly switched to Alchemist whom he was also townreading all game. You would have had a legitimate reason to hammer before Flum did.

[reinoe]

Nothing really surprising in the scum thread but I was amused by this...

point trying to lend credence to her claim. reinoe is a subpar kill anyway since so many people suspect him apparently for who knows what reason.

Aphix can explain that "everything reinoe does is scummy really everything" scumread he had on me any day but I doubt it'll come.

[Fluminator]

I'm not sure what Krystal's best move would have been. It's hard to plan with such wildcards as caledfwitch and Gaiden. You never knew what they were going to do. I half expected to be voted right away by caled in the last day.
I think the biggest mistake Krystal made in the game was targeting caled instead of me in 3 player lylo. Other than that, she played a really good scum game in most of her posts imo.

[Fluminator]

I bet mafia were scared by you Reino when you pegged Alchemist and Matsumi so quickly. XD
I mainly suspected you for because you always seemed to target people who were pressing you. You scum read Matsumi when she went against you. Then Majiffy went against you and you scum read him. Then I pressed against your actions and you scum read me.
That and a bunch of your actions D2.
Although I started suspecting you were town D4, especially when Krystal started doing suspicious things.

[Sakura Hana]

You scum read Matsumi when she went against you.

That's because pie still has issues getting his thoughts straight as scum, dunno how much different the game would've been had I gone solo, but I also got busy anyway.

[aphix]

Nothing really surprising in the scum thread but I was amused by this...

point trying to lend credence to her claim. reinoe is a subpar kill anyway since so many people suspect him apparently for who knows what reason.

Aphix can explain that "everything reinoe does is scummy really everything" scumread he had on me any day but I doubt it'll come.

yeap, because I alone was involved there.. Least I was right about what your town flip meant.

[Newbie]

My play was pretty horrible. Pushed the wrong person. Sorry, Majiffy. >.< In all fairness, you did come of extremely scummy.

[Anatole Kuragin]

Good job pulling it out flum/caled.

[LlamaFluff]

end