In post 2655, TierShift wrote:I'm yet to form an opinion on boon's push on iz and his reaction to it. It all reads a bit vague to me.
Here's *my* take of Boon's case against me, take it as you will:
1)
I'm vying for towncred by NOT killing Boonskiies based on discussion about his role that happened in neighborhood thread.
2)
Aneninen's final posts of the night suggested a plan to form a wagon on me, and then he died, which means there must be scum in our hood
So apparently, I killed Aneninen because he was planning to form a wagon against me and because I would get towncred for not killing Boonskiies.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now, here's why I think Boon's case is BS:
1) How would I get towncred for not killing Boonskiies, when the discussion we had about his role was only visible to the 5 of us in the hood? None of the other 15 players would have batted an eye at it, nor would they have townread me for it.
At the very most
, there would be
4 people
townreading me for it,
Boonskiies included
.
2) If the only players who would possibly townread me for not killing Boonskiies are the ones in my neighborhood, why would I kill one of them? That's one less person left to townread me for not killing Boonskiies, which based on the hard number crunching above would put me at...
3 max players townreading me, Boonskiies included
.
3) I didn't have anything to fear from Aneninen's plan. It was rushed in before thread lock and I don't think he really thought out all of the variables involved. I sincerely doubt it would have ended with my mislynch.
4)
He is assuming that Aneninen's death is the direct result of our neighborhood's activity, despite the fact that there were two deaths and therefore the two events could be completely unrelated.
Even if there was only one death, his assumption here isn't a safe one to make. Two deaths makes it an even more narrow-sighted assumption.
If he's PR-town, then he's applying a
logical fallacy to paint me as scum.
If he's scum, then there are any number of possibilities for why he would be pushing this; more if it's multiball.
If he's SK, then I'm not sure what he's hoping to achieve here, and yet this one makes the most sense to me when I look at his play overall.
5)
Boonskiies agrees with me that it is multiball (or SK in play) and yet had the gall to push point #4.